Anytime something bad happens, it doesn't take long before blame starts to be assigned. In the instance of
subprime mortgage woes, there is no single entity or individual to point the finger at. Instead, this mess is a collective creation of the world's central banks, homeowners, lenders, credit rating agencies and underwriters, and investors. Let's investigate.
The Mess
The economy was at risk of a deep recession after the
dotcom bubble burst in early 2000; this situation was compounded by the September 11 terrorist attacks that followed in 2001. In response,
central banks around the world tried to stimulate the economy. They created capital
liquidity through a reduction in interest rates. In turn, investors sought higher returns through riskier investments. Lenders took on greater risks too, and approved subprime mortgage loans to borrowers with poor credit. Consumer demand drove the
housing bubble to all-time highs in the summer of 2005, which ultimately collapsed in August of 2006. (For an in-depth discussion of these events, see
The Fuel That Fed The Subprime Meltdown.)
The end result of these key events was increased
foreclosure activity, large lenders and hedge funds declaring bankruptcy, and fears regarding further decreases in economic growth and consumer spending. So who's to blame? Let's take a look at the key players.
Biggest Culprit: The Lenders
Most of the blame should be pointed at the
mortgage originators (lenders) for creating these problems. It was the lenders who ultimately lent funds to people with poor credit and a high risk of default. (To learn more about subprime lending, see
Subprime Is Often Subpar.)
When the central banks flooded the markets with capital liquidity, it not only lowered interest rates, it also broadly depressed
risk premiums as investors sought riskier opportunities to bolster their investment returns. At the same time, lenders found themselves with ample capital to lend and, like investors, an increased willingness to undertake additional risk to increase their investment returns.