The Enron debacle in 2001 held many lessons to plan participants, retirement practitioners and other stakeholders. Perhaps the most important of these is that investors have a responsibility to ensure that their investments are being prudently managed. Here we'll look at some of the issues that surfaced from the mismanagement of Enron's employer stock ownership plan (ESOP) and self-directed 401(k) savings plan. Several years later, these incidents still hold important lessons for business owners who are administering a retirement plan.(For background reading, see Your Employer's Stock: Should You Buy In?)

The Fiduciaries and Their Responsibilities
According to the lawsuit filed by the Secretary of the Department of Labor (DOL), the Enron plans were managed by three distinct sets of fiduciaries:

  1. The administrative committee for the Enron plans, which was charged with the responsibility of overseeing the management of the both the ESOP and the savings plan;
  2. Enron, Kenneth L. Lay and Jeffrey K. Skilling, who were responsible for appointing and overseeing the administrative committee; and
  3. Enron's Board of Directors (including Lay and Skilling), who were responsible for appointing and overseeing a trustee to manage the ESOP's investments in Enron stock.

Fiduciary Failures
The fiduciaries failed to comply with their obligations under Employee Retirement Income Security Act (ERISA) and instead abdicated their fiduciary duties. According to the lawsuit filed by the DOL, the fiduciary failures include the following:

  • They invested all matching contributions in Enron stocks, without giving consideration as to whether it was prudent to do so.
  • They failed to monitor the administrative committee's performance of its responsibilities.
  • They failed to share critical adverse information about Enron's financial condition with committee members.
  • They failed to take steps to remove the committee members for failing to discharge their obligations before Enron's bankruptcy.
  • They violated their duties of loyalty and prudence to the plans and participants by misleading participants about Enron's financial health and encouraging them to imprudently invest plan assets in Enron stock, even as signs of danger increased.
  • Even when it was evident that Enron stocks were losing value, they kept the Enron stock fund as an investment option under the savings plan, and they continued to maintain an extensive portion of the plan balance in Enron stocks. The following chart shows the historical performance of Enron's stock during 2001.
Meeting Date Start Time End Time Meeting Length Enron Closing Price % of Jan. \'01 Price
01/02/01 $79.86 -
02/08/01 3:45 pm 4:50 pm 1:05 $80.00 100.17
05/03/01 3:15 pm 4:30 pm 1:15 $58.35 67.42
06/25/01 2:10 pm 4:50 pm 2:40 $44.07 55.17
08/15/01 3:15 pm 4:10 pm 0:55 $40.25 50.39
09/18/01 3:15 pm 4:30 pm 1:15 $28.08 35.15
11/01/01 $11.99 15.01

The plan subsequently implemented a lockdown period, during which participants were not allowed to move Enron stocks from their accounts. During the lockdown period, the stock price, resulting in a reduction of participants' plan assets by more than $150 million dollars.

  • They failed to appoint a trustee for the ESOP. As provided under ERISA code 403(a), all assets of an employee benefit plan must be held in trust by one or more trustees, and the trustee must be named in the plan document or appointed by a person who is a named fiduciary. Yet, the fiduciaries failed to abide by ERISA and the plan requirements and left the ESOP without a fiduciary responsible for managing its investments in Enron stock. As a result, there was no designated fiduciary responsible for overseeing the ESOP's investments in Enron stock, and no one was charged with the obligation to protect the ESOP's holdings.
  • They failed to operate the plan in accordance with the plan document: For employer-matching contributions, the plan provided that those amounts would be primarily invested in employer stocks. However, 100% of those amounts were invested in Enron stocks until November 2001 because the plans' fiduciaries did not exercise their discretion to invest employer contributions in anything other than Enron stock.

For more on what went wrong with Enron's 401(k) and ESOP, see details of the Enron Lawsuit at the Department Of Labor's website.

Managing Your Qualified Plan for Your Employees
The participants in Enron's retirement plans found that their retirement accounts were worth only a fraction of the amount they saved over the years. If you sponsor a qualified plan for your business, you have a responsibility to ensure the plan and its investments are managed prudently. This includes appointing a trustee to monitor plan investments. The following are some additional steps that you can take to help ensure you operate the plan in compliance with ERISA:

  • Ensure that the plan document provides for one or more named fiduciaries that have authority to control and manage the operation and administration of the plan.
  • Provide a procedure for establishing and carrying out a funding policy and method consistent with the objectives of the plan and the requirements of ERISA.
  • Describe any procedure under the plan for the allocation of responsibilities for the operation and administration of the plan.
  • Provide a procedure for amending the plan, and for identifying the persons who have authority to amend the plan.
  • Specify the basis on which payments are made to and from the plan.

These are just a few of the requirements you need to follow. Effective and prudent management of your qualified plan is a much more extensive process. When in doubt about whether you are doing the right things, ask yourself the following questions:

  • Am I discharging my duties with respect to the plans with the care, skill, prudence and diligence under the prevailing circumstances that a prudent person acting in a like capacity and familiar with such matters would use?
  • Am I discharging my duties with respect to the plans solely in the interest of the participants and beneficiaries of the plans and for the exclusive purpose of providing benefits to participants and their beneficiaries and defraying reasonable expenses of administering the plans?
  • Am I discharging my duties with respect to the plans in accordance with the documents and instruments governing the plans in so far as such documents and instruments were consistent with ERISA's other fiduciary provisions?
  • Are the plan fiduciaries reviewing the prudence of the plan's investments?
  • Is the plan being operated as defined by its terms?

Unless you are an expert in the area of fiduciary responsibilities, these concepts may seem like Greek to you. And if you are an expert, then you realize that prudent management of a plan goes beyond what is discussed in this article. If you are adopting a new plan, it may be worthwhile to hire an expert in fiduciary analysis to provide an outline of the steps you need to follow, in non-technical language. If you are already operating a qualified plan and you are unsure of whether it is in compliance with ERISA, an expert fiduciary analyst can help you to determine if any corrective actions should be taken and the steps you need to take to ensure fiduciary standards are met on a consistent basis. (For more on acting as a fiduciary, see Meeting Your Fiduciary Responsibilities.)

Like many catastrophic events, much caution is exercised during the periods immediately following the crisis. But eventually, we are lulled into a sense of security when the event does not immediately repeat itself. What happened at Enron must be treated as a learning experience to this day. Toward that end, as plan sponsor, you must take necessary precautions to ensure your plan operates within the confines of the plan document, ERISA and other governing laws. This includes working with professionals to ensure the job is done right. This will help to protect participants' assets through proper management, and prevent you from being fined and/or imprisoned for abdication of fiduciary responsibilities.

To find out more about Enron, or the scams investors have fallen prey to, see The Biggest Stock Scams Of All Time, Playing The Sleuth In A Scandal Stock and The Ghouls And Monsters On Wall Street.

Related Articles
  1. Retirement

    5 Secrets You Didn’t Know About Traditional IRAs

    A traditional IRA gives you complete control over your contributions, and offers a nice complement to an employer-provided savings plan.
  2. Retirement

    Using Your IRA to Invest in Property

    Explain how to use an IRA account to buy investment property.
  3. Retirement

    How a 401(k) Works After Retirement

    Find out how your 401(k) works after you retire, including when you are required to begin taking distributions and the tax impact of your withdrawals.
  4. Retirement

    Read This Before You Retire in the Philippines

    The Philippines has a warm climate, a low cost of living and plenty of people who speak English. What to do next if you think you want to retire there.
  5. Retirement

    4 Books Every Retiree Should Read

    Learn more about the current financial situations retirees are facing and discover four books that every prospective and current retiree must read.
  6. Retirement

    Are Fees Depleting Your Retirement Savings?  

    Each retirement account will have a fee associated with it. The key is to lower these fees as much as possible to maximize your return.
  7. Entrepreneurship

    4 Things to Know About Your Company To Make a Successful Pitch to Investors

    Learn how to make a successful pitch to investors. Regardless of your industry, size or market, there are some questions all investors need to have answered.
  8. Professionals

    4 Must Watch Films and Documentaries for Accountants

    Learn how these must-watch movies for accountants teach about the importance of ethics in a world driven by greed and financial power.
  9. Entrepreneurship

    Creating a Risk Management Plan for Your Small Business

    Learn how a complete risk management plan can minimize or eliminate your financial exposure through insurance and prevention solutions.
  10. Retirement

    Retirement Tips for Doctors

    Learn five tips that can help physicians get back on schedule in terms of making financial preparations they need to retire.
  1. Can a 401(k) be taken in bankruptcy?

    The two most common types of bankruptcy available to consumers are Chapter 7 and Chapter 13. Whether you file a Chapter 7 ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. When can catch-up contributions start?

    Most qualified retirement plans such as 401(k), 403(b) and SIMPLE 401(k) plans, as well as individual retirement accounts ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Who can make catch-up contributions?

    Most common retirement plans such as 401(k) and 403(b) plans, as well as individual retirement accounts (IRAs) allow you ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Can you have both a 401(k) and an IRA?

    Investors can have both a 401(k) and an individual retirement account (IRA) at the same time, and it is quite common to have ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. Are 401(k) contributions tax deductible?

    All contributions to qualified retirement plans such as 401(k)s reduce taxable income, which lowers the total taxes owed. ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Are 401(k) rollovers taxable?

    401(k) rollovers are generally not taxable as long as the money goes into another qualifying plan, an individual retirement ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Hot Definitions
  1. Turkey

    Slang for an investment that yields disappointing results or turns out worse than expected. Failed business deals, securities ...
  2. Barefoot Pilgrim

    A slang term for an unsophisticated investor who loses all of his or her wealth by trading equities in the stock market. ...
  3. Quick Ratio

    The quick ratio is an indicator of a company’s short-term liquidity. The quick ratio measures a company’s ability to meet ...
  4. Black Tuesday

    October 29, 1929, when the DJIA fell 12% - one of the largest one-day drops in stock market history. More than 16 million ...
  5. Black Monday

    October 19, 1987, when the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) lost almost 22% in a single day. That event marked the beginning ...
  6. Monetary Policy

    Monetary policy is the actions of a central bank, currency board or other regulatory committee that determine the size and ...
Trading Center