The much-ballyhooed Wall Street settlement is supposed to punish the perps and fix research, but it will probably do neither. The settlement will most likely decrease market efficiencies and thus increase costs of both issuers and investors. However, some good will come from the harsh glare of publicity that accompanied the process: here are the good, the bad and the ugly sides of the settlement.

The Good: Tough Love on Wall Street

The good thing about Mr. Spitzer's efforts is that it undoubtedly accelerated a necessary examination of Wall Street practices. While these practices themselves have been around since the first traders gathered, excesses served as a function of the last bubble, leading to the corruption of research staffs, the demolition of the Chinese Wall and, most importantly, the loss of investors' trust.

If left ignored, Wall Street might have never underwent this cleansing process. Wall Street has always been a closed club whose oversight actions are implemented at glacier speed, and often with a wink. Generally, it is an outside force that encourages change, and this time it was New York State Attorney General, Mr. Spitzer, who forced the issue into the glare of public scrutiny. There may be differing opinions about why he chose this issue and how efficient the results may be, but Wall Street will be better off because investors are now more informed about how Wall Street works.

The Bad: Ineffective Effort and Wasted Money
The settlement will more than likely increase costs for both sides of the Street (issuers and investors). The need to comply with all the new regulations arising from the dotcom crash (including Sarbanes-Oxley) is increasing corporate expenses across the board, which will reduce earnings and raise the cost of products and services. Investors will interpret these costs as increased brokerage fees and other hidden charges in banking and insurance rates.

If you think that is bad, just wait until you see what the lawyers do! The documents released with the settlement will provide a cornucopia of material for class action lawsuits that will do more to line lawyers' pockets than to redress past wrongs. The cost of director and officer insurance rates will therefore rise, which in turn will further erode corporate earnings.

The Ugly: The Street Remains Broken
It is hard to believe that $1.4 billion is about to be wasted on ineffective provisions. Many may think that this money will provide restitution, objective research and protection for investors, but it will probably do none of the above. Here is a summary of the SEC's press release and some comments on how we see the potential end results:

$775 million will be paid as "restitution" to investors hurt by tainted research - Half will go the SEC, NYSE and NASD while the remainder will go to the states. The amount is a joke compared to the trillions lost by investors and the billions in fees that the brokerages earned. It is also doubtful that individual investors will see much, if any, of this money, because it will be held by regulators to recoup their costs and by states to help offset budget deficits.
$432.5 million earmarked for independent research - While the intent is noble, this is not likely to result in more objective information for investors. From what I have discerned, each brokerage firm will have an employee in charge of finding an independent firm to publish research on the stocks the firm follows. This addition of independent will not add any new information; adding ten analysts to the current crop of 38 analysts covering, say, Cisco will not uncover anything new.
$80 million will go to a yet undefined investor education program - While this has potential to do some good, its success will be determined only by those who administer the funds.
• The above settlements amount to a total of $1.288 million, leaving about $112 million unaccounted for. Most of this amount appears to involve the separate $100 million settlement reached with Merrill Lynch and may be in addition to the other restitution fines, but the use of the funds was not clear in the SEC\'s release.

I think the most unfortunate thing is that funds earmarked for research will do little to bridge the information gap on Wall Street - this plan's weakness is that it will increase the number of analysts following companies that already have too many analysts! How much new information can be provided by adding more reports on big-cap stocks?

The plan instead should call for an independent administrator or committee of practitioners and regulators to establish an analyst cooperative. The coop would select qualified analysts to provide one new report for each of the firms currently covered by Wall Street, thus reducing redundancy and wasted effort. In addition, the analysts, who would be independent contractors, would be incented to provide research on orphaned stocks, which have little or no analyst coverage. If these analysts then provided good investment ideas, meaning these stocks appreciated, and were accurate with their EPS forecasts, these analysts would receive a bonus on top of a standard report fee.

The Bottom Line
In every post-bubble market, it is deemed necessary to fix the system with new regulations and to punish the wrong doers. Whether regulations actually fix the system or just present temporary obstacles to creative financiers remains to be seen. The key fact is that Mr. Spitzer helped to accelerate efforts and educate investors. It is unlikely, however, that there are any innocents left on Wall Street, at least in this generation of investors.

Related Articles
  1. Investing News

    Mexican Energy, Telecom Reforms Please Foreign Investors

    Two years into his first term, Mexican President Enrique Peña Nieto is following through on radical campaign promises he made to Mexican citizens for sweeping multi-industry reform.
  2. Investing

    Top Cities Where Airbnb Is Legal Or Illegal

    Thinking of subletting your apartment on Airbnb? Make sure that you meet your city's regulations first.
  3. Investing Basics

    Understanding the Spot Market

    A spot market is a market where a commodity or security is bought or sold and then delivered immediately.
  4. Term

    Understanding the Maintenance Margin

    A maintenance margin is the minimum amount of equity that must be kept in a margin account.
  5. Investing Basics

    Learn About the New York Stock Exchange

    The New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) is nicknamed the “Big Board,” and for good reason. It’s the largest, oldest and best-known stock exchange in the world.
  6. Credit & Loans

    Co-signing a Loan? Make Sure You Know The Risks

    Contractually, co-signers are just as responsible for the loan as the person actually borrowing the money. Be careful not to put yourself at risk.
  7. Investing

    Trends In Copyright Litigation

    The Internet has resulted in an explosion in content. An increasing number of copyright trolls are monetizing such content through litigious practices.
  8. Investing

    What Rising Volatility Means for Momentum

    After remaining torpid for most of the year, equity market volatility is once again rising.
  9. Taxes

    What's IRS Form 2848 Used For?

    It's a power of attorney tax form and here's what it can, and cannot, do.
  10. Investing

    Is Airbnb Safe? What You Need To Know

    Thinking of booking a room or listing your home on Airbnb? Get up to speed on safety features for both guests and hosts.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Emergency Banking Act Of 1933

    A bill passed during the administration of former U.S. President ...
  2. Slander

    Slander is the act of harming one person’s reputation by telling ...
  3. Libel

    Libel is publishing a statement about someone in written form ...
  4. Defamation

    Defamation is any statement (written or spoken) that damages ...
  5. Fair Housing Act

    This law (Title VIII of the Civil Rights Act of 1968) forbids ...
  6. PCI Compliance

    Technical and operational standards that businesses are required ...
RELATED FAQS
  1. Why would a corporation issue convertible bonds?

    A convertible bond represents a hybrid security that has bond and equity features; this type of bond allows the conversion ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What is the difference between shares outstanding and floating stock?

    Shares outstanding and floating stock are different measures of the shares of a particular stock. Shares outstanding is the ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What is the difference between market risk premium and equity risk premium?

    The only meaningful difference between market-risk premium and equity-risk premium is scope. Both terms refer to the same ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What is the difference between the QQQ ETF and other indexes?

    QQQ, previously QQQQ, is unlike indexes because it is an exchange-traded fund (ETF) that tracks the Nasdaq 100 Index. The ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What is the difference between an investment and a retail bank?

    The activities and types of clients for an investment bank versus those for a retail bank highlight the primary difference ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Will technology ever disrupt the role of the custodian bank?

    Custodian banks, along with other financial institutions that hold custodian accounts, are likely to be disrupted but not ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center
×

You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!