In the article Analyzing Pension Risk I define pension risk and explain why it is important to assess this risk posed by a company's defined benefit pension plan. Here in this article I present one way (but not the only way) that can help you evaluate and assess whether or not a company's pension exhibits a high risk of shortfall.

Analyzing a company's pension risk should be as easy as reading the footnotes to compare what is owed (accumulated benefits due employees) to what is owned (the value of the portfolio). Unfortunately, thanks to complicated accounting and IRS rules, evaluating pension risk is a Gordian knot that is not easily unraveled.

However, there is a way to use information in the footnotes to evaluate pension risk. While it involves some work, this process will make you a more informed investor. The goal of this process is to cut through the accounting mumbo jumbo to estimate pension funding and cash risk.

The Process
In General Electric's (NYSE: GE) 2002 annual report, Footnote 6 contains the pension data we need. Under the "effect on operations" section it is disclosed that GE's pension plan contributed $1.556 billion to pre-tax income (before payments for retiree healthcare and other benefits), or $0.12 per share on an after-tax basis.

However, this amount was arrived at after using the smoothing techniques allowed by generally accepted accounting principles (GAAP). The table in Footnote 6 (shown in Table 1 below) shows that the $1.556 billion was the result of the expected return of $4.08 billion, the real costs and smoothing accounting techniques. It is these real costs that will be used to analyze the real cost of GE's pension plan.


In order to gauge the impact of "core" pension expenses on EPS, you need to examine the real annual costs of a pension plan, namely service and interest costs. The service costs represent the pension benefits earned by the employees during that year, and in GE's case, that number is the net of employee contributions. The interest cost represents the interest that accrued on the unfunded part of the projected benefit obligation. Analyzing the impact of these costs in relative isolation helps analyze the impact of pension liabilities without the smoothing allowed by GAAP.

To determine the "real" annual cost of the pension plan, you need to back out the massaged number (in this case the $1.556 billion) and add back the service and interest cost. The real annual, after-tax, per share cost of the pension plan in 2002 is $0.38.

As shown in Table 2, this calculation increases the cost 16.7% in 2001 and 6.1% in 2002. This represents a total "swing" of $0.50 from the GAAP EPS number. GE is unique because its plan contributed income whereas most plans add expense. Generally, when evaluating pension risk plans adding expense, you would add the periodic pension cost and subtract the service and interest costs to get the net effect on EPS, but in GE's case, you subtract everything:

This adjustment reduces GE's EPS growth rate by 38%. As shown in Table 3, the GAAP EPS growth rate for 2002 was 2.9% versus the 1.8% that results from making the adjustments described above.


What about Periodic Investment Gains?
This process does not factor in the return on plan assets for two main reasons. First, the above process focuses on the actual annual costs in order to gauge their impact on earnings. Second, the return on plan assets does not belong to the company but to the retirees. While an accounting convention may allow a company to net the costs against the returns, the company has no legal right to the returns. Factoring the return on plan assets into the process would distort the analysis.

If you wanted to include the return on plan assets, you would need to look at the disclosure of the Fair Value of Plan Assets. In GE's case, the actual loss on plan assets was $5.25 billion (compared to the $4.1 billion return that was expected). Including the actual loss on plan assets would reduce EPS by another $0.42 (after taxes).

The Bottom Line
This approach analyzes the EPS impact of the hard (or undiluted by accounting practices) cost of defined pension plans on EPS. Focusing on the per share impact of annual service and interest costs provides a clear view of annual costs that is unclouded by the actuarial assumptions and smoothing techniques allowed by GAAP.

Related Articles
  1. Term

    What are Pension Funds?

    A pension fund is a company-sponsored fund that provides income for employees in retirement.
  2. Term

    What are Non-GAAP Earnings?

    Non-GAAP earnings are a company’s earnings that are not reported according to Generally Accepted Accounting Principles.
  3. Retirement

    Retirement Planning for Entrepreneurs and Small Businesses

    If your business has receiveables, here's a smart way to leverage them to build up your retirement fund fast.
  4. Retirement

    Overhaul Social Security to Fix Retirement Shortfall

    There are several theories and ideas about how we can make up for the $6.6 trillion retirement savings shortfall in America. Adjustments to Social Security and our retirement savings plans are ...
  5. Investing News

    How Does US Social Security Measure Up Abroad?

    Social Security is a hotly debated topic. After examining the retirement plans of three different countries, the U.S.'s does not come out the winner.
  6. Fundamental Analysis

    Calculating Return on Net Assets

    Return on net assets measures a company’s financial performance.
  7. Economics

    Understanding Cost of Revenue

    The cost of revenue is the total costs a business incurs to manufacture and deliver a product or service.
  8. Economics

    Explaining Carrying Cost of Inventory

    The carrying cost of inventory is the cost a business pays for holding goods in stock.
  9. Investing

    How To Calculate Minority Interest

    Minority interest calculations require the use of minority shareholders’ percentage ownership of a subsidiary, after controlling interest is acquired.
  10. Retirement

    Strategies for a Worry-Free Retirement

    Worried about retirement? Here are several strategies to greatly reduce the chance your nest egg will end up depleted.
  1. Operating Cost

    Expenses associated with the maintenance and administration of ...
  2. Trade Credit

    An agreement where a customer can purchase goods on account (without ...
  3. Normal Profit

    An economic condition occurring when the difference between a ...
  4. Cost Accounting

    A type of accounting process that aims to capture a company's ...
  5. Receivables Turnover Ratio

    An accounting measure used to quantify a firm's effectiveness ...
  6. International Financial Reporting ...

    A set of international accounting standards stating how particular ...
  1. Can my IRA be garnished for child support?

    Though some states protect IRA savings from garnishment of any kind, most states lift this exemption in cases where the account ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Can I use my IRA savings to start my own savings?

    While there is no legal reason why you cannot withdraw funds from your IRA to start a traditional savings account, it is ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Can creditors garnish my IRA?

    Depending on the state where you live, your IRA may be garnished by a number of creditors. Unlike 401(k) plans or other qualified ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Can my IRA be used for college tuition?

    You can use your IRA to pay for college tuition even before you reach retirement age. In fact, your retirement savings can ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. Why are IRA, Roth IRAs and 401(k) contributions limited?

    Contributions to IRA, Roth IRA, 401(k) and other retirement savings plans are limited by the IRS to prevent the very wealthy ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. How do you calculate penalties on an IRA or Roth IRA early withdrawal?

    With a few exceptions, early withdrawals from traditional or Roth IRAs generally incur a tax penalty equal to 10% of the ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center

You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!