In the beginning, Dow created the index, and Wall Street saw that it was good. Then, the Dow begat the S&P 500, which begat the Nasdaq Composite, which begat the Russell 1000, 2000, and so on, and so on…

Despite the proliferation of indexes, the "big three" - Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA), Nasdaq Composite and the S&P 500 - rule the headlines, influence the investment decisions of fund managers and command the emotions of the individual investor. And this is not so good. In fact, many times it is bad, and it makes for an ugly market.

The Good
Indexes are useful tools for tracking market trends. Despite the shortcomings discussed below, indexes are the only tool we have that provides a historical perspective to a market with a chronically short memory. By understanding how and why the indexes react in the economic trends over time, investors might gain insight that will help guide better investment decisions.

For example, there have been a growing number of charts that compare recent index trends to the patterns from the 1929 Crash and the Japanese bubble. While there are many differences between the economies of then and now, studying the similarities and differences will help us prevent repeating the sins of our fathers (although this did not happen during the dotcom bubble). (Learn when to jump ship, read Riding The Market Bubble: Don't Try This At Home.)

The Bad
There are two main criticisms of indexes:

1. Calculation Bias (the way the indexes are calculated) - Most indexes are market-cap weighted, meaning that the stocks with the largest market capitalization have the larger weighting in and larger influence on the index. This overweighing means that if the "big dog" is sick, the whole market gets the flu, regardless of the strength in the smaller stocks that are in the index. It could be argued that market weighting is a legitimate way to capture an image of the market, because it represents the impact of the bigger stocks on the market being measured. However, this methodology will result in increased volatility because of the overweighed influence the big dogs have as they go up and down. A more equally-weighted index is more democratic and captures the impact of smaller stocks that may be rising.

2. Representative Bias (what the indexes do not measure) - By definition, an index is comprised of a small number of stocks, picked to represent some universe of stocks. Committees pick which stocks are included in the index, and these stocks are changed over time, in order to reflect the economy as it is for that year. Consequently, you cannot look at a historical chart of any index and assume that it represents the trading pattern of the same stocks over a long period of time. This also means that committees, being human, can make mistakes and pick the wrong stocks to be in the index. (Find out how to avoid costly surprises in Don't Judge An Index Fund By Its Cover.)

The Ugly
Because we are a lazy society with apparently no long-term memory (or else more people would have recognized the last bubble sooner), we have come to rely on indexes and 30-second trend analysis as reality, paying attention to soundbites instead of sound reasoning. Consequently, if the index is down, the bears are in town and we are down. We become more intent on watching the tickers on our computer screens and forget why we are at work. Maybe that is why the economy remains in a recession: everybody is watching CNBC instead of being productive.

However, the market is more dynamic than the indexes are. There are many publicly-traded companies that have strong fundamentals and growing earnings, but they remain undervalued because nobody knows about them. Maybe that is why some say the economy is ahead of Wall Street. (Learn how to tell a bargain from a scam, read Relative Valuation: Don't Get Trapped.)

The Bottom Line
Indexes are useful tools, if you know what they represent and what they don't represent. They provide a good historical perspective, but they should not be viewed as the market. Yes, Virginia, there is a bull market out there, but it isn't where Wall Street is looking.
more than 50% of the index's value.

Related Articles
  1. Chart Advisor

    ChartAdvisor for February 12 2016 (SPY, DIA)

    A weekly technical summary of the major U.S. indexes.
  2. Active Trading Fundamentals

    4 Stocks With Bullish Head and Shoulders Patterns for 2016 (PG, ETR)

    Discover analyses of the top four stocks with bullish head and shoulders patterns forming in 2016, and learn the prices at which they should be considered.
  3. Investing Basics

    How liquid are Fidelity mutual funds?

    Review the liquidity features of mutual fund shares and an overview of Fidelity mutual funds. Most investors look for convenient access to their investments.
  4. Sectors

    3 Cyclical Industries To Exploit in 2016

    Learn about the three industries at the down end of their business cycles, and discover how these industries may improve in years to come.
  5. Stock Analysis

    If You Had Invested Right After Berkshire Hathaway's IPO (BRK.A)

    Learn how much you would now have if you had invested right after Berkshire Hathaway's IPO, and find out the classes of shares that you could invest in.
  6. Stock Analysis

    Is Now the Right Time to Buy Coty? (COTY)

    Find out whether fragrance and color cosmetics powerhouse Coty deserves a place in your portfolio. Will recent acquisitions help turn the company around?
  7. Active Trading

    Market Efficiency Basics

    Market efficiency theory states that a stock’s price will fully reflect all available and relevant information at any given time.
  8. Economics

    The History of Stock Exchanges

    Stock exchanges began with countries who sailed east in the 1600s, braving pirates and bad weather to find goods they could trade back home.
  9. Fundamental Analysis

    3 Long-Term Investing Strategies With Strong Track Records

    Learn why discipline and a statistically valid investment strategy can help an investor limit losses and beat the market over the long term.
  10. Investing Basics

    5 Common Mistakes Young Investors Make

    Missteps are common whenever you’re learning something new. But in investing, missteps can have serious financial consequences.
  1. What is finance?

    "Finance" is a broad term that describes two related activities: the study of how money is managed and the actual process ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What is the 'Rule of 72'?

    The 'Rule of 72' is a simplified way to determine how long an investment will take to double, given a fixed annual rate of ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What is a stock split? Why do stocks split?

    All publicly-traded companies have a set number of shares that are outstanding on the stock market. A stock split is a decision ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Have hedge funds eroded market opportunities?

    Hedge funds have not eroded market opportunities for longer-term investors. Many investors incorrectly assume they cannot ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What fees are associated with target-date funds?

    Target-date funds have two types of fees. The first type of fee is paid to the company managing the fund and selecting the ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Some of the Best No-load Funds to Consider

    Some of the most well-known no-load funds are the DoubleLine Total Return Bond Fund (DLTNX), Vanguard Short-Term Investment-Grade ... Read Full Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Liquidation Margin

    Liquidation margin refers to the value of all of the equity positions in a margin account. If an investor or trader holds ...
  2. Black Swan

    An event or occurrence that deviates beyond what is normally expected of a situation and that would be extremely difficult ...
  3. Inverted Yield Curve

    An interest rate environment in which long-term debt instruments have a lower yield than short-term debt instruments of the ...
  4. Socially Responsible Investment - SRI

    An investment that is considered socially responsible because of the nature of the business the company conducts. Common ...
  5. Presidential Election Cycle (Theory)

    A theory developed by Yale Hirsch that states that U.S. stock markets are weakest in the year following the election of a ...
Trading Center