Ever wonder what makes prices fluctuate so frequently? Ever consider why your paycheck rarely does that? Wages are one of the big economic mysteries because they tend to be so rigid, and because wage rates fly in the face of a number of economic principles. Now economists are revisiting this minefield of a question to see if the old adage stands up to a new sort of recession.

Wage Stickiness
Wage stickiness, as an economic concept, has been around for a while. Economists theorized that, as unemployment rose, wages were not as likely to fall. They would simply grow at a slower rate, meaning that the real rate would decrease but the nominal rate would remain about the same. This seems a little counter-intuitive at first. For example, when the demand for oil or copper decreases, the price for those resources will usually fall as well. Why would labor prices be any different?

The idea that wages are fundamentally different from other inputs is at odds with how markets are theoretically supposed to work. If markets are truly competitive, wages should move in step with the demand for labor. In times of growth, wages should rise because demand for labor increases. In a recession, when unemployment results in a larger labor pool, wages should fall. The tricky part about wages is that they don't seem to follow these rules at all.

The Economists' Debate
Economists have been unable to agree as to why wages are so rigid, or even if wages are rigid at all. Neoclassical economists who believe in efficient markets don't think that wages are rigid, since employees unhappy with pay will quit their jobs. This gives employers flexibility, and diminishes the need for pay cuts. The drawback to this is that it implies that unemployment is voluntary, which it certainly doesn't have to be. Keynesian economists have an even less-concrete explanation, and blame everything from unions to efficiency wages. The problem with Keynes' theory is that it assumes that employees know what wages in similar firms are like, which is not necessarily the case. Other economists believe in the idea of an "implicit contract" between the employer and the employee. The options are dizzying, and the answers few. (For more on the controversies surrounding unions, see Unions: Do They Help Or Hurt Workers?)

The Employer/Employee Dance
The interplay between employers and their employees makes the relationship between labor demand and wages a touchier subject. Factors of production other than labor simply don't take wage adjustments to be a signal of potential doom-and-gloom the way employees will (after all, oil isn't going to bad mouth a company if prices fall). Because of the "softer" aspects associated with wages, employers might be more willing to lay off workers, thus reducing labor expenses, then to cut wages. While workers might miss their departed co-workers, they won't feel the same desperation as they would if their boss cuts the number of hours they work or cuts their wages altogether. Wage cuts can erode morale and productivity at a time when employers need it the most. In fact, a cut in nominal wages can be viewed by the employee as a sort of "breach of contract," even if the contract is only implied.

Re-Examining Wage Stickiness
It turns out that some employers are no longer afraid of cutting wages and benefits. They have shown an increased willingness to both lay off workers and cut pay when times are tight, and have introduced furloughs (unpaid, required vacations) as pay cut alternatives. In addition, the threat of a bankruptcy filing by a company can make labor unions more likely to accept pay cuts in order to stave off the company going completely under.

Why is the Shift Taking Place?
Inflation and debt seem to be two of the likeliest culprits. Employers are less likely to cut wages when inflation rates are high because increased prices allow them to keep wages stagnant or raise them slowly while still keeping their doors open. As long as any increase in nominal wages is lower than the rate of inflation, employers can achieve real wage rate decreases without actually reducing the nominal wage rate. This is a clever play on worker psychology, since increased inflation and stagnant pay actually mean that employees earn less, but because employees don't see a lower figure on their monthly statements, they are less likely to notice. This "money illusion" seems to go against rational economic behavior, but because the effects of inflation may be masked or only partially noticed, employees essentially are acting rationally with the information that they have at hand.

Interestingly, a 1999 survey conducted by the International Monetary Fund (IMF) found that employees thought that an actual pay cut was worse than an equivalent reduction in pay through the effects of inflation. (Learn more about inflation in our Inflation Tutorial.)

Personal debt can also exert downward wage rate pressure by increasing the possibility of deflation. As the amount of debt carried by households increases, stagnant or falling wage rates can lead to less consumer expenditure, since more money is spent servicing debt payments. While the focus on debt-reduction is not intrinsically bad, multiply this sudden drop in spending by millions of households and suddenly demand for goods and services takes a big hit. If employers are more willing to cut wages, a decline in demand may result in an even further lowering of wages. A vicious cycle can ensue. (Learn about some strategies consumers can use to combat debt in Digging Out Of Personal Debt.)

Whether wages are truly sticky or if the concept is an illusion is debatable. One of the major hurdles is procuring data necessary to actually make conclusions. While payroll data is available, is that enough? Researchers have interviewed recruiters and employers to see what they have to say about the employment outlook, but sample size issues and reliability can cause problems with this data as well. Eventually, economists looking for an all-unifying theory might throw up their hands and surrender to the unpredictability that is human behavior towards wages.

For additional reading related to wages, learn about the model that depicts the relationship between unemployment and wage inflation in Examining The Phillips Curve.

Related Articles
  1. Home & Auto

    When Are Rent-to-Own Homes a Good Idea?

    Lease now and pay later can work – for a select few.
  2. Economics

    What Qualifies as Full Employment?

    Full employment is an economic term describing a situation where all available labor resources are being utilized to their highest extent.
  3. Fundamental Analysis

    Is India the Next Emerging Markets Superstar?

    With a shift towards manufacturing and services, India could be the next emerging market superstar. Here, we provide a detailed breakdown of its GDP.
  4. Economics

    A Look at Greece’s Messy Fiscal Policy

    Investigate the muddy fiscal policy, tax problems, and inability to institute austerity that created the Greek crises in 2010 and 2015.
  5. Markets

    The Vodka Industry Keeps Growing, But Why?

    Understand what the vodka industry is and where it performs best. Learn about the growth of the industry and three reason why it continues to grow.
  6. Term

    What is the Macro Environment?

    The macro environment is the conditions existing in an economy as a whole, rather than in a single sector or region.
  7. Economics

    Puerto Rico Will Soon Become America's Greece

    Explore the similarities that exist between Puerto Rico in relation to the United States and Greece in relation to the European Union.
  8. Taxes

    What's Wrong with the American Tax System

    American's are highly taxed and we still run a deficit. We explain why.
  9. Home & Auto

    When Getting a Rent-to-Own Car Makes Sense

    If your credit is bad, rent-to-own may be a better way to purchase a car than taking out a subprime loan – or it may not be. Get out your calculator.
  10. Economics

    Understanding the Bank Rate

    Bank rate is a term describing the interest rate a country’s central bank charges its domestic banks on loans it makes to them.
  1. Derivative

    A security with a price that is dependent upon or derived from ...
  2. Cost, Insurance and Freight - CIF

    A trade term requiring the seller to arrange for the carriage ...
  3. Security

    A financial instrument that represents an ownership position ...
  4. Series 6

    A securities license entitling the holder to register as a limited ...
  5. International Monetary Fund - IMF

    An international organization created for the purpose of standardizing ...
  6. Inflation

    The rate at which the general level of prices for goods and services ...
  1. When has the United States run its largest trade deficits?

    In macroeconomics, balance of trade is one of the leading economic metrics that determines the trading relationship of a ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. How does a forward contract differ from a call option?

    Forward contracts and call options are different financial instruments that allow two parties to purchase or sell assets ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Which is more important to a nation's economy, the balance of trade or the balance ...

    There is no question the composition of a country's balance of payments is more important than its balance of trade. This ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What are the ethical arguments against government subsidies to companies like Tesla?

    The ethical argument behind government subsidies is that they should be put into place to help industries that will, in turn, ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. How can tariffs cause inefficiencies in domestic industries?

    Any government regulation naturally creates inefficiencies in a pure supply and demand marketplace. When it comes to the ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. How do changes in interest rates affect the spending habits in the economy?

    Changes in interest rates can have different effects on consumer spending habits depending on a number of factors, including ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center

You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!