On May 6, 2010, the Dow Jones Industrial Average plunged 998.5 points in just 20 minutes, wiping out more than $1 trillion in market value, before rebounding and closing only slightly down for the day. More than 21,000 trades were canceled as a result, 68% of which were ETF trades. An investigation by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) cited ETFs as a significant player in the crash. In November 2010, the Kauffman Group threw fuel on the fire, with a controversial report about the perils of ETFs. Although the authors were forced to revise and tone down their remarks in response to an onslaught of bad press from ETF providers, the press heavily reported the Kaufmann Group's initial findings.

SEE: Exchange Traded Funds

What Happened on May 6
The SEC's reconstruction of the events of May 6 begins with a volatile day in the markets due to concerns over Greek debt. When a single firm, Waddell & Reed Financial, placed a sell order for E-Mini S&P 500 futures contracts (one of the two most active stock index products) the automated sell order was set to be executed based on trading volume, with no relationship to price or time. These intricacies of electronic trading would play a key role in the crash, as other traders saw the sell order and placed their own sells. Arbitrage trades kicked in, with investors seeking to profit from price differences created on various exchanges by the high volume of sell requests, which further increased trading volume.

SEE: Minis Provide Low-Cost Entry To Futures Market

As the number of requests to sell increased while remaining unfilled, volume accumulated and the algorithm behind Waddell's trade sped up. The automated trading program attempted to dump in 20 minutes a volume of contracts that generally takes most of a full day to trade. The automated sell order was placed, even though Waddell's initial sell orders had not been filled.

Between 2:45:13 and 2:45:27, automated, high-frequency trading accounted for 27,000 E-mini trades as prices continued to decline. At 2:45:25, the Chicago Mercantile Exchange (CME) halted trading for five seconds in an effort to break the pattern of declining prices. The move was effective in that the E-mini market bounced back when trading resumed, but the volatility in trading served as a catalyst for a sell-off in the broader market.

Automatic trading systems at other firms paused because of the broad market decline. By 2:45 PM, the liquidity crisis that led to a downward price trend in E-minis had spread to the broad market as automatic trading programs weren't trading and humans stepped in to review the state of the market and attempt to determine its impact on their profits and losses. During this time, automated trades weren't taking place and trade requests found no buyers or sellers. This led to the execution of trades based on stub quotes, which are placeholder numbers put in the system by market makers or by the security exchanges themselves on behalf of the market. This is done to maintain trading liquidity by having a price quote in response to every quote request.

These stub quotes (at prices as low as one cent and as high as $100,000) were never meant to be used for actual trades, but in the illiquid markets they were executed as legitimate quotes. In a world where trades occur in fractions of a second, 20 minutes is an eternity. From 2:40 p.m. to 3:00 p.m., the SEC reported that two billion trades were executed, with a trading volume in excess of $56 billion. As a result, 8,000 individual equity securities and ETFs posted losses with "over 20,000 trades across more than 300 securities…executed at prices more than 60% away from their values only moments before." Regulators reversed many of the trades - with ETF trades accounting for a disproportional 68% of the reversals.

Investor Awareness
In the aftermath of the crash, ETFs came under heavy scrutiny and criticism. Since the time of their invention, ETFs had been marketed as "mutual funds that trade like stocks." The high liquidity was noted as the primary difference between ETFs (which are priced and traded throughout the day like stocks) and mutual funds (which are priced and traded once per day). The liquidity hurt during the flash crash. While ETF investors took a wild ride, mutual fund investors did not.

The lesson here is that while ETFs are not evil, they are complex. The oversimplification of ETF marketing masks a complex world of high-frequency trading, short selling, complex investment structures and other complicated machinations and practices that most investors aren't even aware of, much less understand. In the aftermath of the flash crash, the industry predictably defended the fast-growing ETF market and automated, high-frequency trading practices. Industry "experts" claimed that concerns about ETFs are only theoretical and that the investments are safe. Of course, in recent memory other "experts" said that the banks were solvent, Enron and AIG were good companies, the real estate downturn wouldn't last, diversification would help during a broad market decline and competition would create a good healthcare system too. As usual, "let the buyer beware" is a good mantra for investors.

The Bottom Line
In the wake of the flash crash, some firms put circuit breakers in place to halt ETF trading if market events appear abnormal. Also, most ETFs have the right to reject redemption requests, a clause that can be invoked in response to a run on a fund, so the fund itself would not collapse if everyone wanted to redeem at the same time - but the investors wouldn't get their money.

The crash is a reminder to investors to do the research before investing. Understand what you are buying (Did you know that ETFs may contain derivatives? Or that some experts argue that ETFs are derivatives? Do you know what a derivative is? Does your ETF have the right to refuse redemption requests?). By learning about and paying attention to the details, investors can make informed decisions. If you have done the research and understand the investment, but you are still comfortable, then you can place an informed order to buy.

SEE: Dissecting Leveraged ETF Returns

Related Articles
  1. Investing Basics

    Learn How To Trade Crude Oil in 5 Steps

    Crude oil and energy markets are specialized venues. Here are five steps to take to build consistent profits.
  2. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Top 3 Japanese Bond ETFs

    Learn about the top three exchange-traded funds (ETFs) that invest in sovereign and corporate bonds issued by developed countries, including Japan.
  3. Chart Advisor

    4 European Stocks to Consider Buying

    European companies, listed on US exchanges, that are providing buying opportunities right now.
  4. Savings

    Become Your Own Financial Advisor

    If you have some financial know-how, you don’t have to hire someone to advise you on investments. This tutorial will help you set goals – and get started.
  5. Investing Basics

    6 Reasons Hedge Funds Underperform

    Understand the hedge fund industry and why it has grown exponentially since 1995. Learn about the top six reasons why the industry underperforms.
  6. Professionals

    10 Must Watch Documentaries For Finance Professionals

    Find out about some of the best documentaries that finance professionals can watch to gain a better understanding of their industry.
  7. Chart Advisor

    ChartAdvisor for October 2 2015

    Weekly technical summary of the major U.S. indexes.
  8. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Top Three Transportation ETFs

    These three transportation funds attract the majority of sector volume.
  9. Investing Basics

    Tops Tips for Trading ETFs

    A look at two different trading strategies for ETFs - one for investors and the other for active traders.
  10. Investing

    How Diversifying Can Help You Manage Market Mayhem

    The recent market volatility, while not unexpected, has certainly been hard for any investor to digest.
  1. What are some of the most common technical indicators that back up Doji patterns?

    The doji candlestick is important enough that Steve Nison devotes an entire chapter to it in his definitive work on candlestick ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Can mutual funds invest in IPOs?

    Mutual funds can invest in initial public offerings (IPOS). However, most mutual funds have bylaws that prevent them from ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Tame Panic Selling with the Exhausted Selling Model

    The exhausted selling model is a pricing strategy used to identify and trade based off of the price floor of a security. ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Point and Figure Charting Using Count Analysis

    Count analysis is a means of interpreting point and figure charts to measure vertical price movements. Technical analysts ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What assumptions are made when conducting a t-test?

    The common assumptions made when doing a t-test include those regarding the scale of measurement, random sampling, normality ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Does index trading increase market vulnerability?

    The rise of index trading may increase the overall vulnerability of the stock market due to increased correlations between ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Hot Definitions
  1. Capitalization Rate

    The rate of return on a real estate investment property based on the income that the property is expected to generate.
  2. Gross Profit

    A company's total revenue (equivalent to total sales) minus the cost of goods sold. Gross profit is the profit a company ...
  3. Revenue

    The amount of money that a company actually receives during a specific period, including discounts and deductions for returned ...
  4. Normal Profit

    An economic condition occurring when the difference between a firm’s total revenue and total cost is equal to zero.
  5. Operating Cost

    Expenses associated with the maintenance and administration of a business on a day-to-day basis.
  6. Cost Of Funds

    The interest rate paid by financial institutions for the funds that they deploy in their business. The cost of funds is one ...
Trading Center
You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!