There has been a lot of discussion about the uptick rule and whether it should be a part of the financial markets. First instituted by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) in 1938 as Rule 10a-1, the uptick rule prevents securities from being consecutively short sold without the stock trading higher at least once between short selling orders. The rule was first instituted after the Depression-era turmoil in the financial markets and was maintained until 2007 when the SEC eliminated it. This article summarizes the history of and debate surrounding the uptick rule. (For background reading, see The Uptick Rule: Does It Keep Bear Markets Ticking?)

Institution and Elimination of the Uptick Rule
Prior to instituting the rule in 1938, the SEC performed a study of the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) and found that of the 20 securities it studied during two periods of 1937, short sales accounted for a significant portion of the overall trades. Based on that study, it was concluded that the rule should be instituted in order to prevent short sellers from adding to the downward spiral of specific securities - and the overall market - to protect stocks and the NYSE in periods of sharp decline. (Read about historical declines in A Review Of Past Recessions.)

In 1963, the SEC established three objectives in order to assess whether the uptick rule continued to be effective. Those guidelines stated that the rule should accomplish the following:

  • Allow relatively unrestricted short sales in an advancing market
  • Prevent short selling at successively lower prices, thus eliminating short selling as a tool for driving the market down
  • Prevent short sellers from accelerating a declining market

Keeping those guidelines in mind, the SEC's Office of Economic Analysis established a pilot program in 2004 to determine whether the uptick rule was still effective. In doing so, it suspended the uptick rule for one-third of the stocks in the Russell 3000 Index while maintaining the rule for the remainder of the stocks. In doing so, it was able to compare results from two groups of securities under identical market conditions - one group for which the uptick rule was suspended and one group for which the rule was upheld. (For more, read The Uptick Rule: Does It Keep Bear Markets Ticking?)

Results from that pilot program demonstrated that although the elimination of the uptick rule increased the volume of stocks that were shorted, it did not increase the overall short interest in a security. And since the interest in shorting a particular security remained undiminished, the study concluded that the uptick rule had no real ultimate impact. Following the results of this study, the uptick rule was repealed in 2007. (Find out how this figure can be a real eye-opener on market sentiment of a given stock in Short Interest: What It Tells Us.)

Outcry Following Elimination of the Uptick Rule
Following the repeal of the uptick rule in 2007, widespread mortgage defaults caused the housing bubble to burst, and the economic ripple effect rapidly spread to financial institutions and their stock prices. Financial institutions that were over-leveraged with toxic mortgage-related assets such as mortgage-backed securities (MBS) and collateralized debt obligations (CDOs) became a target of market short sellers. (Learn more in The Risks Of Mortgage-Backed Securities and Collateralized Debt Obligations: From Boon To Burden.)

While the uptick rule was repealed in 2007 without significant attention, by 2008-2009 there was a loud clamor to reinstate the rule to provide protection from bear raids, not just the share prices of financial stocks, but for rapidly declining market averages as well.

Those that are in favor of the uptick rule argue that the conditions of the 2004-2006 markets under which the pilot program was tested are far different from the dramatically down market conditions of 2008-2009. They maintain that the rule was implemented after the Great Depression in order to protect companies and the financial markets specifically in dire economic circumstances, whenever they arise.

They argue that reinstating the rule will protect the share prices of struggling companies, some of which are artificially driven down past their fair market values during bear raids. And, because the markets are often driven by psychology, proponents of the uptick rule suggest that having it in place not only hinders bear raids against stocks in struggling sectors, but may also impede a bear market from spreading into healthier sectors of the economy. (To discover what on-balance volume, accumulation/distribution and open interest can tell you about the market, see Gauging The Market's Psychological State.)

Tinkering With the Uptick Rule
Some proponents of the uptick rule in general argue that if it is instated, it needs to be adjusted to reflect the fact that the markets have changed in the 70 years since it was first instituted. One of the big changes is that equity markets began quoting prices in increments as small as pennies in 2001. This is relevant to the rule because after markets began pricing in pennies, short sellers needed to wait only until the price of a stock went up a single penny to short the stock again.

Many believe that that is why the 2004-2005 pilot study showed little difference between having the rule in place and removing it - because a stock could be shorted again after only recovering a single cent in share value. Those that follow this theory believe that if the uptick rule is reinstated, it will have to raise that penny interval if it is to have a significant impact. (Learn about the advancements in trading in The Birth Of Stock Exchanges and The Global Electronic Stock Market.)

The Other Side to the Argument
There will be those opposed to placing the disadvantage of a raised interval upon short sellers and hedge funds, specifically because they derive discernible profit from shorting strategies. And even if an effective uptick rule - whatever that may be determined to be in the future - can protect companies from bear raids, there will always be those that argue that it impedes the freedom of the markets and that the markets naturally balance themselves out when short sellers eventually buy long positions to cover potential short losses. (To learn more, read Questioning The Virtue Of The Short Sale.)

One thing that is certain, however, is that the debate over the uptick rule is one that will continue to burn brightly and echo loudly in the investment community in the years to come.

Related Articles
  1. Active Trading Fundamentals

    The Uptick Rule: Does It Keep Bear Markets Ticking?

    This rule prevents traders from driving stocks down, but its effect on market volatility is debatable.
  2. Trading Strategies

    Short Interest: What It Tells Us

    A stock’s short interest is the total number of shares that investors have sold short but have yet to close.
  3. Stock Analysis

    ValueAct Capital: An Activist Investor Analysis

    Read an in-depth review of activist hedge fund ValueAct Capital, which saw nearly all of its 2015 gains eliminated in a matter of weeks during Q3 2015.
  4. Investing

    3 Healthy Financial Habits for 2016

    ”Winning” investors don't just set it and forget it. They consistently take steps to adapt their investment plan in the face of changing markets.
  5. Investing

    How to Ballast a Portfolio with Bonds

    If January and early February performance is any guide, there’s a new normal in financial markets today: Heightened volatility.
  6. Economics

    The Truth about Productivity

    Why has labor market productivity slowed sharply around the world in recent years? One of the greatest economic mysteries out there.
  7. Personal Finance

    How the Green Card Lottery Really Works

    Here's how the popular green card lottery, run by the U.S. State Department, operates, including some tips on improving your odds of winning.
  8. Investing News

    Today's Sell-off: Are We in a Margin Liquidation?

    If we're in market liquidation, is it good news or bad news? That party depends on your timeframe.
  9. Fundamental Analysis

    HF Performance Report: Did Hedge Funds Earn Their Fee in 2015?

    Find out whether hedge funds, which have come under tremendous pressure to improve their performance, managed to earn their fee in 2015.
  10. Investing Basics

    Bill Ackman's 2 Best Investments (GGP, CP)

    Learn about the two best investments Ackman ever made. Ackman has demonstrated a consistent track record of success in all types of market environments.
RELATED FAQS
  1. What is the downtick-uptick rule on the NYSE?

    To ensure orderly markets, the New York Stock Exchange (NYSE) has a set of restrictions that it can implement when experiencing ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Are ETFs subject to the short sale uptick rule?

    Mutual fund use and development has increased rapidly ever since they were first introduced in the early 1920s. In the United ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What is a derivative?

    A derivative is a contract between two or more parties whose value is based on an agreed-upon underlying financial asset, ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What is finance?

    "Finance" is a broad term that describes two related activities: the study of how money is managed and the actual process ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What is after-hours trading? Am I able to trade at this time?

    After-hours trading (AHT) refers to the buying and selling of securities on major exchanges outside of specified regular ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is securitization?

    Securitization is the process of taking an illiquid asset, or group of assets, and through financial engineering, transforming ... Read Full Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Harry Potter Stock Index

    A collection of stocks from companies related to the "Harry Potter" series franchise. Created by StockPickr, this index seeks ...
  2. Liquidation Margin

    Liquidation margin refers to the value of all of the equity positions in a margin account. If an investor or trader holds ...
  3. Black Swan

    An event or occurrence that deviates beyond what is normally expected of a situation and that would be extremely difficult ...
  4. Inverted Yield Curve

    An interest rate environment in which long-term debt instruments have a lower yield than short-term debt instruments of the ...
  5. Socially Responsible Investment - SRI

    An investment that is considered socially responsible because of the nature of the business the company conducts. Common ...
Trading Center