One of the key benefits of any kind of life insurance is the tax-free death benefit. However, some speculators began to transfer life insurance policies between parties in order to reap large tax-free windfalls. In order to discourage this, Congress declared that any life insurance policy that is transferred for any kind of material consideration may become partially or fully taxable when the death benefit is paid out.

This rule is known as the transfer-for-value rule, and it stands as one of the few exceptions to the general exemption from taxation accorded to all life insurance death benefit proceeds. However, the rule itself has several exceptions. We will examine these exceptions as well as the conditions under which a policy transfer may result in taxation. (Tough times call for desperate measures, but is raiding your life insurance policy even worth considering? To learn more, read Cashing In Your Life Insurance Policy.)

The Transfer-for-Value Rule
The transfer-for-value rule states that once the recipient of a life insurance policy transfers the benefit to another party, the tax exempt status of the policy will be removed and the purchaser will have to pay income tax on a portion of the death benefit. The rule apples if the policy is received in return for valuable consideration of any kind. The amount of death benefit that is not taxed equals the value of the consideration received, plus any subsequent premiums that are paid into the policy by the recipient after the transfer. The rest of the death benefit is fully taxable as ordinary income.

XYZ Corporation purchases a $10,000 life insurance policy on one of its key employees. It pays the premiums on this policy for five years and then transfers the policy to another employee for $8,000. The new employee pays an additional $4,000 of premiums into the policy. The original key employee passes away and the death benefit are paid to the second employee. Only $12,000 ($8000 + $4000) of the death benefit can be excluded from taxation; the remainder is taxed as ordinary income to the employee.

In theory, this rule is conceptually fairly simple. But the definition of "consideration" must be examined carefully in order to establish when it applies. Despite the common understanding that consideration refers to a form of monetary payments, sometimes no formal transfer of any kind need take place or tangible consideration be provided in order to violate this rule. Consideration can in this case be merely a reciprocal agreement of some sort that is tied to the transfer of the policy.

For example, if two shareholders in a closely held business take out life insurance policies on themselves and name each other as beneficiaries, then the recipient of the death benefit proceeds from the policy of the partner who dies first will face a substantial tax bill under the transfer-for-value rule. The rule applies here because the two partners presumably agreed to name each other as beneficiaries, thereby introducing the receipt of consideration into the equation. (Decrease the value of your taxable estate and prevent the taxman from getting you one last time. Check out Shifting Life Insurance Ownership.)

Although such rules are subject to interpretation, formal tax code is somewhat ambiguous in terms of what justifies a violation to the tax exempt status. If the IRS has reason to believe that any kind of verbal or tacit agreement was made, then the rule will be upheld. The criteria for determining this lies in the question of whether the transfer would have been made if not for the additional consideration.

In the previous example, the IRS would find that an agreement had been made because each partner would most likely not have named the other as beneficiary on his or her policy without reciprocation. As mentioned previously, the transfer-for-value rule does not only apply to policy sales per se; changing or listing a beneficiary in a policy in return for consideration of any kind will trigger the rule as well.

Special Cases
There are several specific instances where there are exceptions made to safe-harbor the insurance proceeds. In most cases, this rule is breached unintentionally when a policy is transferred to another party with the mistaken assumption that the rules are being followed. One of these happens when the owner of a policy sells the policy to the corporation for which he or she works or sits on the board of directors, and the insured on the policy is also either a shareholder or officer of the corporation. Other situations involve buy-sell agreements, where a privately-held corporation transfers policies between employees in a manner that does not fall under the list of qualified exceptions.

Allowable Exceptions
When Congress created the transfer-for-value rule, it recognized that there are some valid reasons why a business would transfer a policy to one of its employees. To this end, Congress included five specific exceptions to the rule, thus allowing the death benefit of a policy that has been transferred to be paid tax-free to the beneficiary.

  1. Policy transfers to the insured on the policy
  2. Policy transfers to a partner of the insured on the policy
  3. Policy transfers to a partnership in which the insured on the policy is a partner
  4. Policy transfers to a corporation in which the insured on the policy is an officer or shareholder
  5. Policy transfers in which the recipient's cost basis in the policy being transferred is calculated in reference to the cost basis of the transferor. (This exception is usually applicable in tax-free corporate reorganizations, where the old company transfers the policy to the new one.)

As mentioned previously, this rule is often triggered when a company transfers a policy incorrectly. If a policy is transferred several times, the circumstances of the final transfer will generally determine how the death benefit proceeds are taxed. If the final transfer qualifies as an exception, then the proceeds will be tax-free. If not, then the rule applies. It can also apply to transfers between family members in some cases, although these transfers are usually classified at least partly as gifts. (Find out what you can do to get the coverage you need for the right price. For more information, see Can I Get Life Insurance?)

The Bottom Line
The transfer-for-value rule limits the tax advantages of life insurance for many businesses. However, the exceptions to this rule still permit corporations and other policy owners to move their policies under certain circumstances. Policy owners who are unsure of whether their policy transfer may result in taxation should consult their life insurance carrier or tax advisor. (Confused about $1 million dollar insurance advertising claims? Decide whether they'll pay off for you. To learn more, read Five Life Insurance Questions You Should Ask.)

Related Articles
  1. Insurance

    Beware the Sneaky Math of Universal Life Insurance

    Universal life insurance's cash value can be a cash cow – if there's any left. Read on to see if it'll work as an income source after you've retired.
  2. Products and Investments

    Cash Value vs Term Life Insurance: Which is Best?

    The debate between cash value life insurance and term insurance plus an investment plan is an ongoing one. Here's a look at both sides of the argument.
  3. Your Practice

    Advisors: Win Over Millennials with Insurance

    Millennials don’t have the same values and goals as previous generations. Here are some tips on how advisors can adapt to their needs and wants.
  4. Insurance

    Getting Your (Insurance) House in Order

    From starting a family to retirement, insurance can play a role in taking care of financial needs. This piece looks at some of the choices you can make.
  5. Term

    Is Term Life Insurance the Right Choice?

    Term life insurance is a policy with a limited coverage period.
  6. Insurance

    Cashing In Your Life Insurance

    In tough economic times, tapping into a life insurance policy can provide a needed source of funds.
  7. Entrepreneurship

    Becoming An Insurance Agent

    Life insurance protects families, employers and others from financial loss in the event the insured individual dies.
  8. Insurance

    Which Life Insurance is Right For You?

    Consumers have choices when it comes to life insurance. Knowing your future needs for cash or retirement can make the difference in what you select.
  9. Retirement

    3 Methods to use Life Insurance as an Investment During Retirement

    Find out whether life insurance may be a smart investment after you retire, and why it really depends on what you are trying to accomplish.
  10. Your Clients

    How to Help a Client Qualify for Medicaid

    Figuring out Medicaid eligibility can be very complicated—here are some steps to help you assist clients with qualifying for the program.
  1. Do beneficiaries pay taxes on life insurance?

    Generally speaking, when the beneficiary of a life insurance policy receives the death benefit, this money is not counted ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Can I borrow from my annuity to put a down payment on a house?

    You can borrow from your annuity to put a down payment on a house, but be prepared to pay an assortment of fees and penalties. ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What are the biggest disadvantages of annuities?

    Annuities can sound enticing when pitched by a salesperson who, not coincidentally, makes huge commissions selling them. ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What are the risks of annuities in a recession?

    Annuities come in several forms, the two most common being fixed annuities and variable annuities. During a recession, variable ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. How can I determine if a longevity annuity is right for me?

    A longevity annuity may be right for an individual if, based on his current health and a family history of longevity, he ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Can your life insurance company sue you?

    A life insurance company generally cannot sue you, but it can sue your estate. The company may do this in order to recover ... Read Full Answer >>
Trading Center