The U.S. Senate, Friday, approved a budget amendment sponsored by Sen. Lamar Alexander (R-Tenn.). Senator Alexander’s amendment allows states to collect sales taxes on purchases made from Internet-based retailers even if the retailer has no physical presence in that state.
Currently, online retailers have to collect sales taxes on purchases made by consumers who live in states where those retailers have a physical presence. In most states, consumers have to pay tax on purchases made online even if the retailer doesn’t collect it at the time of purchase. This is known as use tax and the rules for this tax vary by state.
A Non-binding Amendment
The budget amendment, passed by the Senate, was based on the Marketplace Fairness Act. The purpose of both the amendment and the act is to make the collecting of sales tax consistent nationwide.
The Senate measure, a largely ceremonial amendment to a largely ceremonial budget, passed by a vote of 75-24. Why is it largely ceremonial? Because the Senate budget has virtually no chance of adoption thanks to the ongoing rancor between the Senate and the House about – well, everything.
As Reuters reports, "Still, the approval should reassure states and 'bricks and mortar' retailers that Congress will come together to pass a bill soon."
The Amazon Tax
The Marketplace Fairness Act was first introduced in the Senate in 2011, and reintroduced in February. Also known as the “Amazon (Nasdaq:AMZN) tax,” the legislation is designed to force online retailers like Amazon to collect sales tax on virtually all online sales.
Proponents and Opponents
Proponents and opponents alike have been vocal on the subject. Supporters of the measure include bricks-and-mortar retailers like Wal-Mart (NYSE:WMT), Best Buy (NYSE:BBY), Target (NYSE:TGT), and Dollar General (NYSE:DG).
Opponents, not surprisingly, include online companies such as eBay (Nasdaq:EBAY), Facebook (Nasdaq:FB), and Oracle (Nasdaq:ORCL). Joining the opposition side are several anti-tax groups including Americans for Tax Reform and Campaign for Liberty.
Brian Bieron, Senior Director of Global Public Policy at eBay, said, “Small business retailers who use the Internet should be protected from any new grant of power to far-away state government tax collectors so that they cannot be threatened or sued by states that are thousands of miles away and have no connection to the local communities where those small businesses create jobs and opportunity. Any Internet sales tax legislation, amendment or other legislative vehicle should include clear, direct and meaningful protection for all small businesses that are using the Internet.”
The anti-tax groups maintain that passage of the Marketplace Fairness Act would, first, constitute a new type of taxation and, secondly, allow states to reach across their borders to force retailers to comply with their tax laws.
Proponents believe the law would level the playing field, forcing all retailers to play by the same rules. The measure, as currently written, includes an exception for smaller online retailers with gross annual sales of under $1 million.
A Surprising Supporter
One of the more surprising supporters of the law to emerge is Amazon. Many find it curious that the world’s largest online retailer supports the notion that Internet sellers should be required to collect sales taxes – even in states where they don’t have a physical presence.
With Amazon expanding its physical presence into more states and the fact that it would be required to collect taxes in those jurisdictions, the company’s position isn’t so unusual.
From Amazon’s perspective, passage of the law would force competitors with smaller geographic footprints to collect sales taxes everywhere. In other words, as the company expands, Amazon is viewing itself more as a brick and mortar business.
The National Retail Federation, another supporter of the law, sees Amazon’s position as a good thing. It estimates that state and local governments lose as much as $24 billion a year in taxes from all non-taxed Internet purchases.
Taxes Are Inevitable
Because of the recent attention and the overwhelming Senate vote, many experts and analysts, including Forbes’ Robert W. Wood, believe we are moving closer to a day when sales tax will be collected on all online purchases nationwide.
Eventually, the Supreme Court could rule. If that happens, Wood suspects the high court might reinterpret the term “physical presence” effectively mandating universal collection.
It seems inevitable that, at some point in the not so distant future, what is now called a usage tax will transform from a combination of patchwork enforcement and relying on people’s honesty to the levying of a sales tax for all online purchases.
Like most things in Washington, chatter comes and chatter goes. If we’re at the beginning of one of those cycles where the internet sales tax again makes headlines, trading opportunities in brick and mortar retailers like Target, Best Buy, and Wal-Mart, as well as online sellers like Amazon, eBay, might present themselves.
If nationwide legislation is passed, that will alter the online retail business model and, at least for the short term, the fundamentals of the stock.
TaxesLearn about the Marketplace Fairness Act of 2015 being reviewed by congress and the differences between it and the 2013 Marketplace Fairness Act.
TaxesMost states have sales taxes of some kind for goods and services. Here's a rundown of the states that have the highest sales taxes.
TaxesHere are five unusual taxes and ways that you can avoid them.
TaxesCongress is set to pass a bill that will give states the power to tax online sellers. But will it benefit Americans or just hamper online-based small-businesses?
TaxesMany retail industry observers expect an online state tax bill to pass in 2012; if it does, how could it affect you?
TaxesThe W-9 form provides key data your clients need if you're an independent contractor. Just be sure you're not really an employee who should fill out a W-4.
TaxesLearn about the differences between sales taxes and Internet sales taxes, and the goods and services that typically incur each type of tax.
EntrepreneurshipLearn about how the Marketplace Fairness Act may impact small business owners should it pass in the House and what the act requires from business owners.
EconomicsFind out why China bothers Donald Trump so much, and why the 2016 Republican presidential candidate argues for a return to protectionist trade policies.
EconomicsFind out when, or if, Russian President Vladimir Putin will ever relinquish control over the Russian government, and whether it matters.
Interest paid on personal loans is not tax deductible. If you take out a loan to buy a car for personal use or to cover other ... Read Full Answer >>
Funds from a Flexible Spending Account (FSA) can be used to cover costs associated with installing, maintaining and removing ... Read Full Answer >>
QVC, an American TV network, is registered with states to collect sales or use tax on taxable items. QVC is also required ... Read Full Answer >>
The funds in a Flexible Spending Account (FSA) can be used to cover most common medical expenses; this includes the cost ... Read Full Answer >>
Each year, the U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) adjusts tax brackets for changes in the cost of living to calculate federal ... Read Full Answer >>
The U.S. Internal Revenue Service (IRS) allows Flexible Spending Account (FSA) funds to be used for qualified medical expenses ... Read Full Answer >>