If you’ve ever been exposed to even one commercial on a financial TV network, you’ve been told that gold was, is, and forever will be the greatest investment of all time. Retention of value, millennia-long history, scarcity, etc., etc. However, the companies selling gold will take gladly take your cash in exchange, which ought to tell you something about gold’s short-term prognosis and the likelihood of imminent inflation.

A moment’s examination will show that a permanent bull market for gold is impossible. If gold had risen consistently and measurably in value since the days of Tutankhamen, its price would now be borderline infinite. The metal’s price clearly rises and falls daily, so what makes one day’s supply and demand curves intersect at one price, and the next day’s at another? (For a look into the fascinating, arcane conventions by which gold is priced, see "The Insiders Who Fix Gold, Interest, and LIBOR rates.")

The supply of gold is largely static from one period to the next. Gold mines are large and plentiful, but almost the entirety of what they produce is dross. As technology improves, ore with ever-lowering concentrations of gold becomes economically feasible. Ore that contains as little as one part of gold per 300,000 is worth mining. Discard all the billions of tons of worthless ground rock, and it’s been estimated that all the gold ever mined would fit on a football field, piled less than 10 feet high. The gold mined each year adds less than the thickness of a coat of paint to the total.

As a commodity of long standing, gold is not a security for the speculative. No one, or at least no one sane, buys physical gold in the hope that it’ll sextuple in value over the next year. Instead, buying gold is a defensive measure: a guard against inflation, currency devaluation, the failure of less tangible assets, and other woes.

Unlike many other commodities – light sweet crude oil, pork bellies, ethanol, cotton – precious metals differ in that for the most part, they aren’t consumed. Only about 10% of gold is mined for industrial purposes (e.g. rheumatoid arthritis drugs, dental bridges), leaving the rest to be held and later sold at the buyer’s will, whether in bullion, coin, or jewelry form. It’s only simplifying the situation a little to assume that the total supply of gold is more or less static.

Five years ago, Aaron Regent, the president of Barrick Gold Corporation (ABX; the world’s largest gold producer), stated that production had peaked at the turn of the millennium and would continue to fall. And prices did indeed correspondingly rise over the next 2½ years. In fact, they doubled. Yet they’ve since lost 50% off that all-time zenith. Given that corporate executives typically have an incentive to issue cautiously worded forward-looking statements, it’s reasonable to speculate as to Regent's motives. Whatever they were, the price of his own company’s stock has halved since his pronouncement. Barrick’s annual gold production has gone from 7.42 million ounces then to 7.17 million in June 2014, when gold sits at around $1300 an ounce.

Gold’s most pronounced price fall in the last decade happened between September of 2012 and April of 2013, a half-year in which the metal lost a third of its value. Classical economic theory would blame the bear market on either an increase in supply, which we’ve already determined is unlikely, or a decrease in demand. The latter was indeed responsible, but why?

Short answer: Speculation, in the sense of speculating as to what governments and central banks are going to do and then acting accordingly. Gold’s latest historic drop came on the heels of the Federal Reserve announcing it was wrapping up its controversial stimulus program. Couple that with the preternaturally low inflation of the time (and since), and gold’s role as a hedge against rising price levels becomes moot. Throw a red-hot stock market into the mix, and the temptation for increasing returns as contrasted with maintaining one’s store of value becomes too great. Why sit on the sidelines with an inert shiny metal when other investors are getting at least temporarily rich?

It’s hard for some younger investors to believe, but in the late 1990s gold was hovering in the $250 range. That’s per ounce, not per milligram. The people shrewd and patient enough to have held onto their gold stashes throughout terrorism, war, prolonged recession(s) and other assorted global upheaval are justifiably proud. And probably still not selling. Especially when you consider that worldwide economic and political distress are often the norm, not the exception.

The Bottom Line

It’s tempting to think that gold represents an objective, unswayable measure of wealth, especially given the metal’s role as an investment throughout the course of civilization. And yet it isn’t. Gold’s value rises and falls with respect to anything else, indeed just as anything else does. While gold will almost certainly never gain nor lose relative value as quickly as penny stocks and dot-com initial public offerings can, gold’s price movements can still convey information – about investor confidence, the probability of stock price and currency increases, and more. A wise investor is one who recognizes gold’s place in the market, without attaching too much nor too little significance to it.

Greg McFarlane owns physical gold, and holds no position in ABX.

Related Articles
  1. Trading Strategies

    Day-Trading Gold ETFs: Top Tips

    Learn when is the most favorable time to day-trade gold ETFs and how to take advantage.
  2. Economics

    What To Do About Gold Now

    Gold has made gains of more than 16% since January. These tips will help you ride the gold wave.
  3. Personal Finance

    Wall Street History: Y2K, Milton Friedman And Golden Watches

    This week in financial history has a bit of everything, including murder.
  4. Personal Finance

    Water Cooler Finance: Goldman Fined, Financial Fixes And Apple's "Apology"

    This week marked some huge financial changes and conclusions.
  5. Home & Auto

    Goldman: Guilty Of Finance, Innocent On Fraud

    While Goldman is no angel, the focus on CDO and derivatives transactions is misguided at best.
  6. Personal Finance

    The Goldman Sachs Accusation Explained

    Despite the airtime this scandal has received, the details aren't clear. Find out what happened and how it affects you.
  7. Professionals

    The Evolution Of Goldman Sachs

    The fraud allegations against them have tarnished the reputation of the firm. But how exactly did they get to this point?
  8. Options & Futures

    Goldman Sachs: By The Numbers

    While Goldman's guilt or innocence is not yet clear, these key numbers help tell part of the story.
  9. Personal Finance

    Corzine: Goldman Targeted Because Of Success

    Democratic stalwart tells Wall Street crowd to accept financial reform.
  10. Investing

    Are There More Cockroaches In Goldman's Kitchen?

    If you have you ever seen a cockroach in the kitchen, you know there are more. The same concept applies to bad financial news.
  1. Which country has the most gold?

    Acquiring gold for a nation is a costly expense, but in times of economic trouble, countries want more gold in their reserves. ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Which mutual funds made money in 2008?

    Out of the 2,800 mutual funds that Morningstar, Inc., the leading provider of independent investment research in North America, ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Do hedge funds invest in commodities?

    There are several hedge funds that invest in commodities. Many hedge funds have broad macroeconomic strategies and invest ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What techniques can be used for hedging exposure to the electronics sector?

    Hedging exposure to the electronics sector offers an investor a way to insulate his portfolio from losses during periods ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What techniques are most useful for hedging exposure to the banking sector?

    The banking sector moves in the same direction as the broader market, but its volatility is much lower. The sector's stability ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Is credit a form of fiat money?

    To understand why credit is a form of fiat money, one must first understand what money is. At its most basic level, money ... Read Full Answer >>
Trading Center