Homeowners who wish to reduce the risks to their home-equity investment, and/or those who have other investment opportunities with higher returns than their home equity, should consider using a REX agreement. This contract is a home-equity risk/ return sharing arrangement that allows the homeowner to effectively sell home equity (without selling the house) and reinvest the money. In this article, we'll analyze REX & Company's agreement, the after-tax financial impacts, and take a look at a few examples that will help potential users to evaluate whether they are likely to benefit from them or not. (For background reading, check out REX Agreements Climb As House Prices Decline.)

Tax Effects
A REX agreement is similar to a forward sale contract with a deposit (except it has no maturity date) in that it is an unexecuted contract prior to termination.

Tax-accounting treatment is employed the same way as for an option. When the contract ends with the sale of the house, the upfront payment will be considered part of the sales proceeds, and the final settlement payment from the homeowner to REX & Co. offsets the sales proceeds received. So, as long as the total gain on sale is within the excludable amount on the principal residence, the gain on the hedge will not be taxed.

There is no definitive treatment under the current tax code when the homeowner terminates the REX agreement before a sale. However, a net payment by REX & Co. to the homeowner (i.e., after the five-year penalty period) would surely be taxed as ordinary income. A payment from the homeowner to REX & Co. at termination would most likely be treated as a capital loss, the same as the closing of an option contract.

Breakeven Analysis
Because the homeowner cannot collect for house-price depreciation if the agreement terminates in the first five years, the contract is only useful for long-term hedging. Still, even a two- or three-year agreement may be profitable if the upfront cash earns good returns. You only need cumulative after-tax returns on the cash to exceed the penalty in order to come out ahead. Figure 1 below shows the maximum appreciation rate for which the homeowner's profit is exactly zero during each of the first six years - assuming a 50% sharing REX agreement and 6% after-tax returns on the up-front cash received by the homeowner. (Note: These calculations assume that the payments to REX & Co. are not tax deductible.)

Figure 1: All amounts expressed as a percent of house value
Investopedia.com © 2008

At this rate of return on cash, the table indicates that you should not enter the REX agreement unless you intend to keep the house more than two years. Beyond two years, you come out ahead even after paying the penalty for early termination so long as house appreciation falls below the levels shown here. Given the high probability of prices dropping during the next five years, homeowners who do not plan to sell should benefit from a REX agreement.

Numerical Example
While the risk-management benefits of using the REX agreement as a hedge are clear, a homeowner should understand the full range of possible financial outcomes. For this we must analyze the results for the various combinations of returns on cash and potential changes in house values. Assuming the REX agreement is outstanding for five years plus one day, the homeowner avoids the termination-penalty payment and will be paid for any price depreciation.

Figure 2 below provides the range of outcomes for a five-year period - assuming the maximum 50% sharing agreement. This table can be extrapolated to sharing agreements with smaller percentages of sharing by scaling down the results accordingly (i.e., a 20% share is 2/5 of the table result). In terms of actual dollars, you would multiply these percentages by the original value of the house at the inception of the REX agreement.

Figure 2
Investopedia.com © 2008

Each payoff table column shows how much you would gain (or lose) in five years with a REX agreement, assuming your returns on the upfront cash payment received match the rate shown at the top of the column. The rows correspond to assumptions about the cumulative five-year house-price changes as shown in the leftmost column. As an example, assume you entered a 50% sharing agreement when your house was worth $1 million, and you reinvested the up-front payment at a rate of 6.80% after tax. If the house declined to a value of $900,000 (down 10%) at the end of five years, then your gain from the REX agreement would be $106,000 (10.6% of $1 million).

REX's Point of View
At this point one should wonder why REX & Co. would offer this deal. Because of the long lead times in developing such financial products, it is likely that this was conceived and designed, and the funding commitments obtained, before the housing market cooled down in 2007. The product may eventually be withdrawn if the funding sources become sufficiently pessimistic about housing prices. (Learn more about the 2007 mortgage meltdown in The Fuel That Fed The Subprime Meltdown.)

Benefits to Institutional Investors
Fundamentally the concept has a lot of appeal to institutional investors because these investors will see the REX-agreement investments as providing them with a diversification opportunity. This fits with their fiduciary duties, since they are guided by a tenet of modern portfolio theory that says diversification is very important for minimizing risk for a given level of return. (To learn more, read Modern Portfolio Theory: An Overview.)

With extremely long investment horizons, home-equity investments provide a new opportunity to diversify into an asset class that they could not access previously. They expect the correlation of returns with their other investments to be very low. Thus, in theory, it should reduce their portfolio's overall risk. Whether this is poor market timing will not be known to them until after the fact. Institutional investors often give such issues lower priority than improving on their application of portfolio theory. (Keep reading about diversification in Introduction To Diversification and The Importance Of Diversification.)

Another point worth noting is that the REX agreement effectively provides them with a leveraged investment in housing: they get the rights to a larger percentage of the house's change in value than they must pay cash for up front. The agreement turns out to be the equivalent of the owner loaning a portion of their share to REX & Co. in return for free rent on REX and Co.'s share of the house. This relatively cheap leverage would provide very good returns if houses appreciate at their historic long-run rates.

From a homeowner's point of view the REX agreement can be an effective way to hedge against declines in house prices. This tool provides an opportunity to preserve capital and reduce risks of home ownership without selling your house. In order to take advantage, however, you will need to keep your house at least two years and invest the upfront cash wisely.

Related Articles
  1. Home & Auto

    The Pros and Cons of Buying Vs. Building a Home

    Before you decide whether to buy or build a home, you should weigh the advantages and disadvantages of each scenario.
  2. Home & Auto

    When Should You Consider Taking out a HELOC?

    Home equity lines of credit, or HELOCs, have gotten a bum rap since the housing meltdown. But used correctly, they can be a cheap way to access capital.
  3. Home & Auto

    What to Do When You Can't Pay Back Your HELOC

    Home equity lines of credit can be a cheap way to tap the equity in your home, but will you risk losing your home if you can't make the repayments?
  4. Credit & Loans

    How Balloon Payments Work

    30-year mortgage borrowers will typically make equal payments over 30 years until the loan’s principal and interest have been paid. A loan’s interest rates will likely be lower if it includes ...
  5. Home & Auto

    Buying a Home? The Best Places Share this Feature

    The most lucrative areas to invest in a home are cities where job growth is robust.
  6. Home & Auto

    How to Invest When You Buy Your First Home

    Homeownership isn't cheap these days thanks to the down payment and closing costs. Savers who are putting away money have to invest it differently.
  7. Credit & Loans

    4 Ways to Refinance a Home Equity Line of Credit

    There's more than one way to get more affordable monthly payments on your home equity line of credit through refinancing or loan modification.
  8. Credit & Loans

    Have Bad Credit? 6 Ways to a Personal Loan Anyway

    It'll cost you more, but borrowing is definitely doable. Here's how to proceed.
  9. Retirement

    5 Reasons Retirees Are Upsizing Instead of Downsizing Their Homes

    Many retirees opt to downsize to save money, but there are many who are doing the opposite and upsizing.
  10. Home & Auto

    Is Making Biweekly Mortgage Payments A Good Idea?

    Some people believe making mortgage payments every two weeks, as opposed to once a month, can chop years off of a home loan. But is it really a good idea?
  1. Do FHA loans require escrow accounts?

    Federal Housing Administration (FHA) loans require escrow accounts for property taxes, homeowners insurance and mortgage ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. How do I calculate how much home equity I have?

    Even though it is normally assumed most people know their home equity, many are still confused about the topic. It is an ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What are the typical requirements to qualify for closed end credit?

    Typical requirements for a consumer to qualify for closed-end credit include satisfactory income level and credit history, ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What are some examples of financial markets and their roles?

    Some examples of financial markets and their roles include the stock market, the bond market and the real estate market. ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What price-to-book ratio is considered average in the chemicals sector?

    You can use Microsoft Excel to calculate the loan-to-value ratio if you have the mortgage amount and appraised value of a ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. How does the loan-to-value ratio affect my mortgage payments?

    Several factors affect the mortgage rate you can obtain when you purchase a home. Lenders analyze credit histories and scores ... Read Full Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Presidential Election Cycle (Theory)

    A theory developed by Yale Hirsch that states that U.S. stock markets are weakest in the year following the election of a ...
  2. Super Bowl Indicator

    An indicator based on the belief that a Super Bowl win for a team from the old AFL (AFC division) foretells a decline in ...
  3. Flight To Quality

    The action of investors moving their capital away from riskier investments to the safest possible investment vehicles. This ...
  4. Discouraged Worker

    A person who is eligible for employment and is able to work, but is currently unemployed and has not attempted to find employment ...
  5. Ponzimonium

    After Bernard Madoff's $65 billion Ponzi scheme was revealed, many new (smaller-scale) Ponzi schemers became exposed. Ponzimonium ...
  6. Quarterly Earnings Report

    A quarterly filing made by public companies to report their performance. Included in earnings reports are items such as net ...
Trading Center