If you fill up a car with gasoline or heat a home with oil or natural gas, you know that rising energy costs have put a dent in your budget. But do you also know how easy it is to buy shares in a brokerage account or individual retirement account (IRA) that can help you hedge energy commodity price increases?
This article will help investors understand the benefits of investing in energy commodity exchange-traded funds (ETFs) and detail choices available to interested investors. It specifically covers investments that seek to track commodities prices - not ETFs that invest in energy sector stocks, in which investment returns are influenced by the overall direction of the stock market and do not always mirror energy commodities prices.
Welcome to the World of ETFs
In recent years, thanks to the growth of ETFs, ownership of energy-sector commodities has become more accessible for individuals. For example, buying one share of the United States Oil Fund (ARCA:USO) gives you exposure roughly equal to one barrel of oil. If oil prices rise by 10% in a given period, your investment should theoretically appreciate by about the same percentage. You can own oil through this ETF without incurring the cost normally associated with storage or transport. The only costs that you will pay include brokerage fees to buy and sell shares plus a modest ongoing management fee.
USO is not mentioned as a specific investment recommendation. It is significant because it was the first energy commodity ETF introduced, in February of 2006, and remains one of the most popular by asset size and trading volume. Since USO's introduction, ETF energy commodity choices have greatly expanded.
Why Invest in Energy Commodity ETFs?
ETFs are traded on exchanges (like stocks), and shares may be bought or sold throughout the trading day in large or small amounts.
At the heart of the "energy complex" is crude oil and products refined from it, such as gasoline and home heating oil. Natural gas is a by-product of oil exploration and a valuable product in its own right, used throughout the world for heat and power generation. Lesser products in the energy complex include coal, kerosene, diesel fuel, propane and carbon credits.
Energy commodity ETFs can be useful tools for constructing diversified investment portfolios for the following reasons:
Inflation Hedge and Currency Hedge Potential
Energy has recognized value all over the world, and this value does not depend on any nation's economy or currency. Over time, most energy commodities have held their values against inflation very well. For example, the spot price of a barrel of crude oil increased at an average annual rate of roughly 6.5 percent per year from 1950 through 2007. Over the same span, the annualized increase in the U.S.Consumer Price Index was 3.9 percent. Energy prices tend to move in the opposite direction of the U.S. dollar - prices increase when the dollar is weak. This makes energy ETFs a sound strategy for hedging against any dollar declines.
Participation in Global Growth
Demand for energy commodities keeps growing in industrializing emerging markets such as China and India. In 2007, as in most years, the U.S. consumed about 25% of the world's 85 million barrels of total daily oil production, and U.S. consumption has been increasing by about 3 percent per year, according to the International Energy Agency. Some experts believe that it will be difficult for global oil production to grow in the future due to dwindling reserves, especially in Saudi Arabia. In addition, several of the world's leading oil export nations (ex. Russia, Iran, Iraq, Venezuela and Nigeria) are politically volatile and could be unreliable as future sources of supply.
According to modern portfolio theory, investors can increase portfolio risk-adjusted returns by combining low-correlating assets in which returns do not tend to move in the same direction at the same time. However, few asset classes accessible to individual investors have consistently produced low correlations with U.S. stocks. Correlations are measured on a scale of 1 (perfect correlation) to -1 (perfectly negative correlation). Oil is among the few asset classes that have consistently produced very low (or negative) correlations with U.S. stocks. According to FactSet, the correlation between oil futures and the S&P 500 Index was roughly -0.31 for the five-year period 2002-2007. For this reason, investors can expect oil commodity holdings to help diversify and balance stock-heavy portfolios.
Backwardation is the most complex (and least understood) benefit of some energy commodity ETFs. These ETFs place most of their assets in interest-bearing debt instruments (such as short-term U.S. Treasuries), which are used as collateral for buying futures contracts. In most cases, the ETFs hold futures contracts with the least time left to delivery - so-called "short-dated" contracts. As these contracts approach the delivery date, the ETFs "roll" into the next shortest-dated contracts.
Most futures contracts typically trade in contango, which means that prices on long-delivery contracts exceed short-term delivery or spot prices. However, oil and gasoline historically have often done the opposite, which is called backwardation. When an ETF systematically rolls backwardated contracts, it can add small increments of return called "roll yield," because it is rolling into less expensive contracts. Over time, these small increments add up significantly, especially if backwardation continues.
Although this explanation may sound highly technical, roll yield historically has been the dominant source of investment return in oil, heating oil and gasoline futures contracts. According to an analysis by author and analyst Hilary Till, long-term annualized returns of these futures contracts exceeded spot prices significantly, as shown in Figure 1, below, and the major reason for this differential was backwardation roll yield.
|Figure 1 - Annualized Returns from 1983 to 2004|
|-||Futures Contract||Spot Price|
|Gasoline (since January 1985)||18.6%||3.3%|
|Source: "Structural Sources of Return and Risk in Commodity Futures Investments" by Hilary Till (Commodities Now, June 2006)|
It should be noted that these energy contracts occasionally move from backwardation to contango for intervals of time. During such times, roll yield may be lower than shown in the table; they may even be negative. Historically, natural gas has not shown the same tendency toward backwardation and roll yield benefit as the three contracts listed in the table.
Types of Energy ETFs
Energy ETFs can be divided into three main groups:
These ETFs participate principally in single futures contracts. For example, the Barclays Bank Plc iPath Exchange (NYSE:OIL) exchange-traded note (ETN) participates in the West Texas intermediate (WTI) light sweet crude oil futures traded on the New York Mercantile Exchange (NYMEX). Note: An ETN is a structure that works much the same way as an ETF. PowerShares DB Oil Fund (ARCA:DBO) participates in the same WTI contract.
USO, the pioneering energy commodity ETF, is a subject of some controversy because it nominally participates in a single contract (WTI), while also dabbling in several other energy complex contracts. Therefore, most investors do not consider it be a pure single-contract ETF.
These ETFs offer diversified exposure to the energy sector by participating in several futures contracts. The iShares S&P GSCI Commodity-Indexed Trust (ARCA:GSG) has about two-thirds of its total weight in the energy sector and the remaining one-third in other types of commodities. It tracks one of the oldest diversified commodities indexes, the S&P GSCI Total Return Index.
PowerShares DB Energy Fund (ARCA:DBE) is a pure energy sector fund diversified across commodity types. It participates in futures contracts for light sweet crude oil, heating oil, brent crude, gasoline and natural gas. The ETF seeks to track an index that optimizes roll yield by selecting futures contracts according to a proprietary formula.
Energy sector commodities can be volatile, and some investors may want to bet against them at times. The ProShares UltraShort Oil & Gas ETF (ARCA:DUG) is designed to produce two times the inverse (opposite) performace of the Dow Jones U.S. Oil & Gas Index. This means that if the Dow Jones U.S. Oil & Gas Index is negative 1% for the day, DUG should theorectically be positive 2% for the day. Another short ETF is the ProShares Short Oil & Gas ETF (ARCA:DDG), similar to the DUG but is only one times invese realtionship to the Dow Jones U.S. Oil & Gas Index.
The Bottom Line
While ETFs have made energy sector commodities more accessible to investors, it's important for investors to understand the mechanics of how individual ETFs work. Specifically, investors should realize that virtually all of these ETFs participate in futures contracts, and the "roll yield" of these contracts can be a major source of positive or negative returns, depending on patterns of backwardation or contango. Multi-contract ETFs such as GSG and DBE can be a good way to add broad energy exposure across multiple contracts. But at times, some of these contracts may be in backwardation (producing positive roll yield) while others are in contango (producing negative roll yield).
For investors who own stock-heavy portfolios denominated in U.S. dollars and wish to increase diversification and inflation-hedge potential, some energy sector exposure may be advisable. However, it's a good idea to have a long-term horizon for such investments because they can be volatile over brief periods. Crude oil can be an especially valuable commodity for adding diversification because it has consistently produced negative correlations with U.S. stocks.
Mutual Funds & ETFsFind out which energy sector ETFs may be poised for a big future, including options for investors who want clean energy, more diversity or lower expenses.
Mutual Funds & ETFsTo take full advantage of these vehicles, you need to know how they can fulfill certain strategies.
Fundamental AnalysisLearn why natural gas is playing a larger role in the energy industry.
Mutual Funds & ETFsThese funds trade like stocks, provide diversification, reduce risk and increase returns.
Options & FuturesExchange-traded funds provide unique opportunities for investors. Find out how.
Active TradingChanges in the price of oil aren't arbitrary. Read on to find out what moves them and why.
Options & FuturesFind out how the everyday items you use can affect your investments.
Mutual Funds & ETFsFind out information about the ProShares UltraPro Short S&P 500 exchange-traded fund, and learn detailed analysis of its characteristics and suitability.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn more about the SPDR Barclays Investment Grade Floating Rate Fund, which tracks an index of highly rated floating debt securities.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn more about a unique and innovative exchange-traded fund (ETF) in the biotechnology industry: the ALPS Medical Breakthroughs Fund.
The estimated volatility of a security's price.
The most basic or standard version of a financial instrument, ...
A security with a price that is dependent upon or derived from ...
A REIT is a type of security that invests in real estate through ...
A security that tracks an index, a commodity or a basket of assets ...
A transaction that can cancel out a forward contract that has ...
Generally, penny stocks are traded through the use of the Over the Counter Bulletin Board (OTCBB) and through pink sheets. ... Read Full Answer >>
Some penny stocks, those using the definition of trading for less than $5 per share, are traded on regular exchanges such ... Read Full Answer >>
Traders roll over futures contracts to switch from the front month contract that is close to expiration to another contract ... Read Full Answer >>
If an investment fund has a high turnover ratio, it indicates it replaces most or all of its holdings over a one-year period. ... Read Full Answer >>
The rise of index trading may increase the overall vulnerability of the stock market due to increased correlations between ... Read Full Answer >>
The price of an American depositary receipt (ADR) is determined by the bank or other financial institution that issues it. ... Read Full Answer >>