In times of uncertainty and volatility in the market, some investors turn to hedging using puts and calls versus stock to reduce risk. Hedging is even promoted by hedge funds, mutual funds, brokerage firms and some investment advisors. (For a primer on options, refer to our Option Basics Tutorial.)
Hedging with puts and calls can also be done versus employee stock options and restricted stock that may be granted as a substitute for cash compensation.
The case for hedging versus employee stock options tends to be stronger than the case for hedging versus stock. For example, most stock can be sold immediately without any penalties other than capital gains tax (if any), whereas employee stock options can never be sold but must be exercised and then the stock sold. The penalty here is the forfeit of any remaining time premium and an early compensation income tax.
However, a higher degree of expertise is required to efficiently hedge the employee stock options, given the lack of standardized exercise prices and expiration dates, tax considerations and other issues.
So, as a practical matter, how would an expert efficiently hedge a portfolio of stocks or employee stock options?
Understand the Risks and Rewards
The first step is to understand the risks of holding the portfolio of stock or employee stock options that you have. Options, whether exchange traded calls and puts or employee stock options, are certainly more risky to own than stock. There is a greater chance of quickly losing your investment in options compared to stocks, and the risk increases as the option gets closer to expiration or moves further out of the money (OTM). (Learn more about risks in Reducing Risk With Options.)
Next, given your better understanding now of the risks associated with holding the positions that you have, determine how much risk you want to reduce. You may perceive that you are too concentrated in one stock and wish to reduce that risk and avoid paying a capital gains tax or pay the costs of an early exercise of the employee stock options.
Make sure you understand whatever tax rules apply to hedging so that you are not surprised after the event. These tax rules are a bit complicated but sometimes offer attractive results if managed properly. There are special tax rules that apply to hedging employee stock options, and these are different from those that apply to hedging stock.
The Process of Trading
Be sure that you understand the mechanics of executing the necessary initial trades. How should you enter the trades? Should you enter market orders or limit orders or enter limit orders tied to the stock price? In my view, you should never enter market orders when trading puts or calls. Limit orders tied to the stock price are the best kind.
Next, you should understand the transaction costs and that doesn't just mean the commissions. The spread between the bid and ask and the past volume and open interests should be considered before entering trades. You do not want to enter hedges where there is little or no liquidity when you want to get out.
You must also understand the margin requirements associated with the various transactions and how those requirements might change. Of course, when selling calls one to one against each 100 shares you own, it is simple to determine the margin requirement to make the sale (i.e. there is no margin if the stock remains in your account) even if you withdraw the proceeds upon sale of the calls. Selling more than one to one versus the stock gets a little more complicated but can be handled quite easily. Hedging versus employee stock options will indeed require margin if you have no company stock.
Once You're In
Next you should understand the required time to monitor the positions as the stock moves around and premiums erode and volatilities and interest rates change. You may wish from time to time to make adjustments by replacing a set of securities you are using to hedge your portfolio with a different set of securities.
Then there are the decisions about whether you should buy puts, sell calls or do a combination of the two.
Finally, decide which calls are the best to sell or which puts are the best ones to buy. (For more information on long-term options, see Long-Term Equity Anticipation Securities: When To Take The "LEAP"?)
When to Buy and Sell
One of the most important decisions to make is when you should sell calls and buy puts. Is the best time to be selling just prior to earnings announcements when the premiums are pumped up or is the week after the earnings are announced the best time to buy puts? And should you consider the implied volatilities of the options hoping to sell overpriced calls and buy underpriced puts? Often, recently pumped up volatilities imply that something may be in the works and some people are trading on inside information. Perhaps not hedging all the positions at one time is the more prudent approach.
Would you sell calls on the day the executives were granted large amounts of options or sell them two or three weeks later? Do you know how to identify what the executive insiders are doing with the securities of the prospective hedged security? There is evidence that when employee stock options and restricted stock are granted to executives, there is a much better chance the stock will increase rather than fall in the following month.
The Bottom Line
Hedging definitely has its merits, but it has to be well thought out and it is probably best to seek advice from someone experienced in this practice before trying it on your own.
For related reading on hedging, take a look at A Beginner's Guide To Hedging and Practical And Affordable Hedging Strategies.
Investing BasicsPlain vanilla is a term used in investing to describe the most basic types of financial instruments.
Options & FuturesProfessionals choose the options available to you in your plan, making your decisions easier.
Fundamental AnalysisOptions market trading data can provide important insights about the direction of stocks and the overall market. Here’s how to track it.
Mutual Funds & ETFsExplore analysis of some of the most popular inverse and leveraged-inverse ETFs that track equity indexes, and learn about the suitability of these ETFs.
InvestingWe look at strategies to help manage taxes and the exercise of incentive and non-qualified stock options.
Investing BasicsRetirement planning using high-risk options? It is possible, and studies confirm better yields than conventional methods. Here’s how.
Investing BasicsIn options trading, vega represents the amount option prices are expected to change in response to a change in the underlying asset’s implied volatility.
InvestingIt has been nearly 10 years since the Fed last raised interest rates, and though the central bank didn’t hike rates this month, they look to be coming.
Options & FuturesOptions are often the bread and butter of day traders. Here are some of the more common types of options.
Mutual Funds & ETFsExplore analysis of popular inverse bond ETFs that track the U.S. Treasury market, and learn how to use the ETFs as a tactical day trade if interest rates rise.
Mutual funds invest in not only stocks and fixed-income securities but also options and futures. There exists a separate ... Read Full Answer >>
Forward contracts and call options are different financial instruments that allow two parties to purchase or sell assets ... Read Full Answer >>
Different types of companies may enter into futures contracts for different purposes. The most common reason is to hedge ... Read Full Answer >>
The food and beverage sector exhibits greater volatility than the broader market and tends to suffer larger-than-average ... Read Full Answer >>
The term delta refers to the change in price of an underlying stock or exchange-traded fund (ETF) as compared to the corresponding ... Read Full Answer >>
Investing style determines the best hedging techniques for the insurance sector. This sector comprises three segments, two ... Read Full Answer >>