Seven years have passed since the worst housing market crash in United States history triggered a global financial crisis. Lehman Brothers declared bankruptcy, and a host of other banks came close to joining them before being rescued in a series of shotgun mergers and acquisitions, the largest of which included Bank of America – Merrill Lynch, JP Morgan Chase – Bear Stearns, and Wells Fargo – Wachovia. Alongside bailouts and a beleaguered stock market, home prices continued to fall, foreclosure rates increased, and by the end of June 2010, it was estimated that nearly a quarter of all U.S. homeowners were underwater – a situation when a home is worth less than its outstanding mortgage. In the years since the crash and financial crisis, the housing market has been making a slow – and bumpy – recovery.
The Slow and Tenuous Recovery
During the first quarter of 2012, an unsettling 31.4% of homeowners were underwater. Since then, however, about 5 million homeowners have been freed from negative home equity, thanks to rising home prices. Although that still leaves as many as 10.8 million – or 21% – of homeowners underwater as we approach the New Year, the number is expected to continue improving as the real estate market and broader economy continue to improve as well.
The housing recovery has struggled against disruptions to the broader economy. As we approach the end of 2013, Frank Nothaft, vice president and chief economist with Freddie Mac noted, “We’re likely going to see the housing recovery slow down, but not shut down, as we close out the rest of this year due to tight inventories in many markets, rising mortgage rates and slumping consumer confidence.” Looking to 2014, Nothaft said, “Fortunately, the housing recovery should continue to absorb the economic shocks in stride and improve next year.”
In addition, there is expected to be a shift in the coming year from a refinance-dominated mortgage environment to one driven by purchases – for the first time in over a decade. “With the close of 2013 will also come a major transition in the housing finance industry,” said Nothaft. “For the first time since 2000, we’re going to see the mortgage market dominated by purchase activity as the refinance share drops below 50%. And with mortgage rates rising, we’re also going to see the home-sales gains as well as the impressive house price growth begin to moderate to more sustainable levels.”
In the third quarter of this year, lender-initiated foreclosure action fell to the lowest level since the second quarter of 2006, according to foreclosure listing firm RealtyTrac, Inc. About 120,000 homes nationwide were taken back by lenders during this year’s third quarter, putting the country on track to end the year with about 507,000 completed foreclosures – down about 24% from 2012 numbers. The number of foreclosures reached a high in 2010 at 1.05 million, and since then rates have been declining.
As the housing market continues its recovery, we can expect a few things to happen in 2014:
- House prices will continue to rise, but at a slower rate than 2013.
- As home prices rise, more homeowners will emerge from being underwater, putting them in the position to finally buy and sell properties.
- Mortgages will be dominated by purchases rather than refinance activity, for the first time since 2000.
- Higher mortgage rates will slow home sales and price gains to more sustainable levels.
- Low inventories will be helped by an increase in new construction and a decrease in investor purchasing.
Rising Prices in 2013 for Most U.S. Metro Areas
The vast majority of U.S. metro areas tracked by Clear Capital, a real estate data and analysis provider, have seen rising home prices during the past year. Nationwide, the median sales price of existing homes (single-family and condos) rose 10.9% over the year ending Sept. 30, 2013, boosting the median price for existing homes to $215,000. Although prices are, on average, still 31.5% below 2006 highs, a few markets have achieved double-digit gains over their 2006 peaks, including Austin/Round Rock, Texas (+12.9% from 2006 highs); Buffalo-Niagara Falls, N.Y. (+16.1%); Charleston, W.Va. (+16.4%); Ithaca, N.Y. (+14.4%); Pittsburg, Pa. (+10.0%); State College, Pa. (+13.2%); and Watertown-Fort Drum, N.Y. (+23.0%).
Low Inventories in Many Markets
Low inventories explain a lot of the price gains. As we approach the end of 2013, there is a five-month supply of homes nationwide (meaning it would take five months to sell everything at the current sales pace). In general, a market that is balanced between sellers and buyers has about a six-month supply. Much tighter inventories, however, can be seen in certain markets, such as Washington D.C., which has only a 2.1-month supply going into the end of the year.
A number of factors can contribute to lean inventories. In some markets, institutional investors have bought many of the available properties, to rent, flip or hold until prices rise. In fact, institutional investors (defined here as those purchasing 10 or more properties in the previous 12 months) accounted for 10% of all sales in August of this year, but in certain markets, those figures were much higher. Institutional investors represented 31% of purchase activity in Memphis, Tenn., 29% in Jacksonville, Fla., 22% in Atlanta, Ga., 17% in St. Louis, Mo., and 17% in Detroit, Mich.
Low housing starts are another factor. New home construction essentially came to a halt following the housing crash, remaining at historic lows for nearly five years due to tight credit, land and labor, and higher costs for materials. April of this year marked the lowest level of ready-to-occupy new construction on record, with just 39,000 new homes in the housing inventory. According to census data, however, the inventory of newly built homes (including homes that are currently under construction and those that are ready-to-occupy) is rising as demand increases. After hitting a low in July 2012, the total inventory is up nearly 10% and is expected to continue rising in 2014.
Low inventories are also the result of homeowners who, having bought at the peak, are reluctant to sell while prices are still rising. Homeowners who have been underwater (or close to it) are finally seeing the light at the end of the tunnel and know that the longer they hold on, the more likely they are to recoup their investments.
Look for Smaller, More Sustainable Gains in 2014
In the years leading up to the crash, home values nationwide, on average, had risen about 50% from the first quarter of 2000 to the first quarter of 2005. Certain markets, however, experienced price growth that was significantly higher than the national average. Prices in New York City, Miami and San Diego, for example, jumped 77%, 96% and 118%, respectively. In order to buy houses at these higher prices, of course, Americans had taken on more mortgage debt, and from 2000 to 2007, the value of gross residential mortgages in the U.S. had increased nearly $5 trillion more than household incomes. While price gains are generally a good thing, such increases are not sustainable, especially when average incomes are stagnant or rising only a small percentage.
Although the current market has enjoyed price increases, gains are expected to taper off as we enter 2014. Alex Villacorta, Ph.D., Vice President of Research & Analytics for Clear Capital, shared some observations in advance of the firm’s 2013 year-end review of home price trends and 2014 forecast, due to release Jan. 6, 2014. Regarding 2013 performance, Villacorta said, "2012-2013 was a good year for national home prices, with 2013 prices likely to end the year seeing a full 10% gain in values. This strong growth is double the rate of historical national price growth, and only eclipsed by the run-up years of 2005-2006 when end of year price gains reached 11.7% and 13%, respectively.”
Villacorta expects home prices in 2014 to fall back in line with historical norms. “National home prices have recovered from the over-correction attributed to the overall economic recession,” Villacorta said. “With prices back in line and the broader economy not yet showing sustained strength, we expect 2014 national home prices to revert to historical rates of growth of 4 to 5%.”
It’s important to acknowledge that certain markets will fall outside – either above or below – these projections. “Despite the projected moderation to historical norms, there still remain many major metros that are either outperforming or severely underperforming the national norms,” Villacorta said. In addition, he cautions, “Granular analysis of market performance remains a key lesson to avoid misleading assumptions for all market participants."
The Bottom Line
The housing market has been making a slow and steady recovery since the crash that led to rapidly declining home prices, and record numbers of foreclosures and underwater mortgages. The recovery will continue to be driven by a combination of elements including home inventories (supply), foreclosure rates, mortgage rates, availability of credit, institutional investing and factors within the broader economy.
Active Trading FundamentalsBy following the trend shown in the MBA Purchase Index, investors can identify investment opportunities in businesses that are poised to benefit, and find cautionary signals around industries ...
Personal FinanceOwning a home is still a good decision for many people and can be an important part of a long-term financial strategy.
Home & AutoHere, we introduce widely used contingency clauses in home purchase contracts and how they can benefit both Buyers and Sellers.
Home & AutoForeclosing on a home has major ramifications that can last for years, but for some, foreclosure may seem like the only option.
Personal FinanceWhen interest rates fall, real estate prices tend to increase. Why? Find out here.
Home & AutoWith interest rates still being relatively low, now is a great time to capitalize on refinancing your home. Be aware of what fees are involved in a refinance, and how to keep these costs low.
Investing BasicsThis index is a widely-used and respected barometer of the U.S. housing market and the broader economy.
EconomicsWe share some insights on how the recent terrorist attacks in Paris could impact the economy and markets going forward.
Credit & LoansIf you are underwater on your mortgage, this program may be just what you need to help build up equity in your home.
Credit & LoansAdjustable rate mortgages can save borrowers money, but they can't go into it blind. In order to benefit from an ARM, you have to understand how it works.
Mortgages are just as negotiable as any other product or service. Whether it's a new home purchase or refinancing of an existing ... Read Full Answer >>
Federal Housing Administration (FHA) loans require down payments, which can be as low as 3.5% of the total purchase price ... Read Full Answer >>
Because Federal Housing Administration (FHA) loans are provided by financial institutions, taking out an FHA loan entails ... Read Full Answer >>
In statistics, regression analysis is a widely used technique to uncover relationships among variables and determine whether ... Read Full Answer >>
Presidents George W. Bush and Barack Obama, in conjunction with Congress, signed into law several major legislative responses ... Read Full Answer >>
The American Dream was seriously damaged by the housing market collapse in 2008. In many ways, the American Dream is a self-fulfilling ... Read Full Answer >>