Many investors enter into a relationship with their brokers with little or no knowledge about their background, such as time in the business, expertise or ability to manage money. Investors also are often in the dark when it comes to particulars of the firms they are dealing with.
This is a mistake.
Well-informed investors who know the lay of the land and who ask the right questions can communicate their needs to a broker more effectively. Perhaps more importantly, they can also ensure that they aren't being taken advantage of, particularly when it comes to commission charges.
To that end, below is a list of questions and actions that will help ensure that neither your broker, nor your brokerage firm, is ripping you off.
Do a Search
Go to the NASD website and conduct a search for your broker and his or her firm by name. Are there any judgments or liens against your broker? Has he or she been terminated by a prior employer? Have any complaints been registered? If so, what are they? The request for information is free, and often a detailed report will be sent to your email account within a few minutes of making a request.
This information will give you a basis for your future relationship with both the registered representative and the firm. In other words, it will either give you confidence that both parties are on the up and up, or that they are charlatans that must be avoided.
Ask your broker or prospective broker why he or she works at the firm. Inquire about how many years your broker has been in the business, as well as the number of clients with which he or she works. Also ask what his/her "money line" is! In other words, how does the broker make money? Not only will knowing about a broker's money line let you know what the broker is making/charging in terms of commission, it will also give you a good idea of whether the broker has a decent number of clients.
Does the Firm Make Markets?
Most major firms are market makers, meaning they act as intermediaries between buyers and sellers when trading Nasdaq stocks. However, many of those same brokerage firms also use their market-making status to build an inventory of stocks so that they are not only making a commission off of you, but also money on the actual purchase or sale of the stock you buy. Remember, they buy at the bid and sell at the offer or ask. As an investor, you do just the opposite.
Simply asking whether the firm makes markets in the stocks you are buying will give you a better picture of exactly how much money is being generated from your account. This will also give you some leverage when it comes to negotiating your commission structure.
Negotiate, Negotiate, Negotiate
Commissions are negotiable. Remember, with the abundance of discount brokers and stock research information available on the web, your broker needs to be competitive when it comes to commissions.
Suggest tying your commissions to the broker's performance. Most good brokers will at least be receptive to this suggestion. Of course, you should remember that you also often get what you pay for. If you want a full-service broker, access to the best research and shares in an IPO, you will almost definitely need to pay more than the pittance being charged by the deep-discount firms. Regardless of what kind of service you think you need, shop around and see what other firms are charging, then try to negotiate a mutually beneficial deal.
Read Up on the Firm
Trade journals and the web are excellent sources for researching big-name brokers. Look for any high-level departures or problems. Try to determine whether the company is competitive, not only in the commissions it charges, but in the array of products being offered.
Firms that peddle their own research, particularly those that recommend companies with which they have a banking relationship, probably have an inherent conflict of interest.
Simply knowing that these conflicts exist and letting the broker know you know should limit the possibility that your broker will take advantage of you.
Remind your broker that you are benchmarking his or her performance against other major indices such as the Dow or the S&P 500. Also make it clear that if your broker isn't out-pacing these indices after a period of time, you can always buy mutual funds or ETFs that will track those indices. This won't fail to get their attention.
Review Your Monthly Statements and Ask Questions
You must review your monthly/quarterly statement! Account for every dollar. Look at every trade and confirm that the commission you agreed upon is being charged. If there are any discrepancies or you notice that any unauthorized trades have been made, you must approach or confront your broker - or better yet, the firm's sales manager.
Talk to the Sales Manager Periodically
Sales managers typically get an override on any commissions generated on your account. This means that they make money on any trades conducted in your account for supervising your broker and making sure the trades being executed are consistent with your investment objectives.
This means that you need to speak to this person on a regular basis. The sales manager is unlikely to be familiar with every detail of your account, but he or she will be able to tell you more about your broker's - and the firm's - history. Sales managers also can help you confirm information you have received from your broker.
Communicate in Plain Terms
Tell your broker - in plain English - what your financial goals are.
In other words, don't say that you want to save money for your child's college tuition. Instead, ask about what the most efficient way is for you to accumulate funds to meet a future goal. This gives your broker a sense of not only what you need the money for, but also of your time horizon.
The Bottom Line
Be informed. Letting your broker or advisor know that you have done your homework, that you are expecting them to perform and that you are ready, willing and able to detail your financial goals in a crisp, clear manner will make your relationship more productive. It will also put the advisor on notice that you are a savvy investor who cannot be taken advantage of.
Investing BasicsYou're starting out in the investing world as a trader, so now what? We give you a few tips on how set your goals.
Active TradingUse this indicator to gauge the end of a price trend.
BrokersAltering your entry and exit strategy could save you a lot of money in fees. Find out how to pad your bottom line.
Options & FuturesSmart investors don't give away more money than necessary in commissions and fees. Find out how to save.
InsuranceDetermine what you are getting for your fees and commissions and how to get your money's worth.
Forex EducationThis reversal pattern can make sense of the seeming randomness of market movements and improve your trading.
Personal FinanceEven if you’re a finance or statistics expert, you’re not immune to common decision-making mistakes that can negatively impact your finances.
Investing BasicsA diversified portfolio will protect you in a tough market. Get some solid tips here!
EntrepreneurshipThere are a lot of risks associated with running a business, but there are an equal number of ways to prepare for and manage them.
Active TradingIt's impossible to avoid disaster without trading rules - make sure you know how to devise them for yourself.
The variance between a security's bid price and its ask price, also known as the bid-ask spread, represents the different ... Read Full Answer >>
Warrants can be purchased directly from a warrant issuer (primary market transaction) or through a listed exchange (secondary ... Read Full Answer >>
The Vanguard mutual fund family is one of the largest and most well-recognized fund family in the financial industry. Its ... Read Full Answer >>
The Personal Finance Society (PFS) and with Her Majesty's Revenue and Customs (HMRC) have outlined when a value-added tax ... Read Full Answer >>
Mutual funds in India work in much the same way as mutual funds in the United States. Like their American counterparts, Indian ... Read Full Answer >>
Like most financial assets held by institutions such as banks and investment firms, UTMA accounts can be escheated by state ... Read Full Answer >>