Picture yourself at a fancy party. There is a group of high-powered professionals is in the corner guffawing and comparing the performance of their investment managers. Strange, unfamiliar terms drift through the air: Sharpe ratio, alpha, r-squared, down-market capture ratio ... You hear the term "batting average" and think you can join in, but it's quickly apparent they aren't talking baseball.
There are many statistical factors that professional analysts use to assess an investment manager. They may seem confusing at first, but many of these factors can be used by non-professionals to determine the value of their own investment managers. To make calculations easier, several of these statistical measures are available in commercial software packages such as Wilshire, Zephyr, or PSN Informa. In this article, we'll go through the key statistics you need to know to assess your own managers performance.
Alpha is a measure of investment performance adjusted for the risk taken. It indicates the portion of a manager's return that can attributed to the manager's skill rather than the movement of the overall market. A positive alpha implies that a manager has added value over and above the performance of the market; conversely, a negative alpha would indicate that the manager has reduced value by underperforming the market. (To learn more, read Adding Alpha Without Adding Risk.)
Beta measures the manager's systematic risk. It compares the return volatility of the manager to the volatility of returns for a comparable market index. The index has a beta of 1 by definition. A beta of 1.20 would imply a volatility level 20% higher than the overall market, and a beta of 0.80 would indicate volatility 20% lower than the market. (For more insight, read Beta: Gauging Price Fluctuations and Beta: Know The Risk.)
R-squared measures how closely the manager's returns match the returns of the market index against which it is compared. Derived from regression analysis, it essentially indicates alpha and beta's reliability in explaining the manager's return and risk. An R-squared of 90% indicates the manager correlates with the style or benchmark index by a factor 90% over time. An R-squared of 40% would indicate very little correlation with the chosen benchmark and, therefore, alpha and beta might be considered statistically insignificant. (To learn more on alpha, beta, R-squared and others, see Understanding Volatility Measurements.)
The standard deviation is a gauge of the variance, or dispersion, of the manager's return over its average or mean. Statistically, it is the square root of the variance. Because it measures total variation of the return, standard deviation is a measure of total risk, unlike beta, which measures only market risk.
The tracking error, conceptually, is the inverse of R-squared. It is a measure of how closely the manager tracks the index returns. Statistically, it is the annualized standard deviation of the difference between the manager's return and the benchmark return. (For further insight, see Is tracking error a significant measure for determining ex-post risk?)
The Sharpe ratio measures the manager's excess return over the risk-free rate of return (normally the cash return), divided by the standard deviation. It is a statistical measure that incorporates return and risk into a single number. (To learn more on this important measure, see Understanding The Sharpe Ratio.)
Up-Market Capture Ratio
The up-market capture ratio is a measure of a manager's performance in up markets relative to the index during the same period. A ratio value of 115 indicates that the manager has outperformed the market index by 15% in periods when the index has risen.
Down-Market Capture Ratio
This ratio is the direct opposite of the up-market capture ratio, gauging performance of the manager relative to the index in down markets. A ratio value of 80 would indicate the manager has declined only 80% as much as the declining overall market, indicating relative outperformance.
The batting average measures the manager's ability to meet or beat the market consistently. It is calculated by diving the number of quarters (or months) in which the manager beats or matches the index by the total number of quarters (or months) in the period. A manager who outperforms the market one-half of the time will have a statistical batting average of 50. The longer the time period analyzed, the more statistically significant the measure becomes.
Putting It All Together
Investment Manager XYZ
(Three Years Ending December 31, 2006)
|Alpha||Beta||R-Squared||Track Error||St. Dev||Sharpe||UpCap||DCap||BA|
It's two weeks later, and you're at another party, but this time you've come prepared with the above statistics. Here's what you can say about your manager. The advisor generated solid excess, non-systematic returns over the past three years, but at a somewhat higher systematic risk level, as indicated by the higher beta. This pulled down the Sharpe ratio somewhat, although it is still higher than the index Sharpe ratio. Your manager doesn't hug the index, as indicated by the R-squared correlation coefficient of 88% and the fairly wide track error of 10%. The manager might have explained this by stating that making bets away from the index (insofar as sector/industry weights, holdings, etc.), is what allows him or her to generate the excess returns over time.
The level of the R-squared coefficient confirms the statistical significance of alpha and beta. The capture ratios indicate positive relative performance in up markets, but clear underperformance in down markets. The batting average indicates the manager's ability to outdistance the overall market roughly 80% of the time.
These stats may not make you the life of the party; however, they will let you determine whether your money is being managed effectively - and that's pretty exciting!
ProfessionalsThe start, stop, start Social Security strategy is complicated. Here's what retirees considering it need to consider.
ProfessionalsThe market has corrected...now what? Here's what you should consider rather than panicking.
ProfessionalsParents should make sure their kids realize their home is a launching pad not a landing spot, and advisors can help clients talk to their children.
ProfessionalsGlobal wealth is rising and expected to continue. Advisors should know that the wealthy value fee transparency, performance.
ProfessionalsThink a robo-advisor might be the right choice for you? Be sure to ask these questions first.
ProfessionalsAre hedge fund ETFs right for you? Here's what investors need to consider.
ProfessionalsA common question is whether or not plan participants should choose index or target date funds in a 401(k). The answer depends on different scenarios.
ProfessionalsPrenups aren't just for the rich. Here's how to help clients agree to one if you think they'll benefit.
ProfessionalsWith the biggest transfer of wealth underway, advisors need to ensure that clients don't also inherit debt.
ProfessionalsIf you are not collaborating with other professionals in your circle, you could be doing your clients a disservice.
A financial singularity is the point at which investment decisions ...
Fintech is a portmanteau of financial technology that describes ...
The endowment effect describes a circumstance in which an individual ...
Anchoring and adjustment is a cognitive error described by behavioral ...
Definition of Robo Financial Advisers
An arrangement whereby one holds an asset or property on behalf ...
A high-net-worth insurance policy is specifically tailored to suit the needs of high-net-worth individuals. It is specifically ... Read Full Answer >>
An investor who is a high-net-worth individual (HNWI) may require private wealth management services. HNWIs have unique financial ... Read Full Answer >>
Typically, litigation is better than mediation in high-net-worth divorce cases for two major situations – when there are ... Read Full Answer >>
“Fee-only” and “fee-based” sound similar, but there are important differences between these types of financial advisers. ... Read Full Answer >>
While the majority of financial advisers provide wealth management and comprehensive financial planning to a wide range of ... Read Full Answer >>
Morningstar, Inc. (MORN) is a leading provider of financial information via Internet, software and print-based products to ... Read Full Answer >>