Life insurance carriers began offering return-of-premium riders on their term policies in the early 1990s as a solution to the "live-and-lose" dilemma presented by traditional term policies. As the name implies, this rider will allow term life insurance policyholders to recover all or part of their premiums paid over the life of the policy if they do not die during the stated term. This effectively reduces their net cost to zero if a death benefit is not paid.

Of course, adding this protection will raise the overall cost of the policy accordingly. In this article, we'll take a look at a new form of policy rider that may be very attractive to investment-minded individuals who are seeking the sensibility of term coverage.

Weighing Costs and Benefits
Let's take a look at an example of how to weight the decision of whether to sign up for a return-of-premium rider.

Example 1 - Cost of Premium Vs. Benefit
A 37-year-old nonsmoking male can get $250,000 of term coverage through AIG for $562 per year with a standard rating. If a return-of-premium rider is added on, the cost jumps to $880 per year, an increase of more than $300 per year. Without the rider, the policy owner will pay a total of $16,860 over the life of the policy. The additional rider will thus bring the total cost of the term policy to $26,400.

: Quote given is for a 30-year, level-term policy for a 37-year-old male, 6\'3", 220 lbs, 6 points on driving record, nonsmoker, no medications, no diseases.

For the analytically-minded, the inevitable next question is: will the recovery of this amount of money make it worth paying an additional $9,540 in the meantime? (To learn more about this, see Let Life Insurance Riders Drive Your Coverage and Understand Your Insurance Contract.)

Opportunity Cost Analysis
To find out whether the additional cost is worthwhile, you need to do the same type of analysis as used for deciding whether to purchase permanent insurance coverage or buy term insurance and invest the difference. To this end, the opportunity cost of adding the rider to the policy must be calculated using a reasonable set of assumptions.

Example 2 - Opportunity Cost of Adding a Rider

Using the numbers shown in Example 1, if the additional $318 of annual premium that is required to purchase the rider is invested in a stock mutual fund inside a Roth IRA, in 30 years the fund, will be worth a little over $50,000, assuming an annual growth rate of 10%.
In this case the policy owner would be better off investing the difference than adding the rider on to his policy. But this answer is deceptively simple because this calculation doesn\'t consider such factors as investor risk tolerance or the policy owner\'s tax bracket.

What if the policy owner has a low risk tolerance, or his income is too high to allow him to contribute to a Roth IRA? If so, then he could invest the money in a taxable certificate of deposit (CD) paying 5%. If he is in the 30% tax bracket, then this would grow to a little over $16,000 at the end of 30 years, after taxes. Therefore, if the policy owner outlives the coverage term, he will be left with the $16,000 CD balance after investing a total of $26,400 ($16,860 for the policy and another $318 per year, or $9,540 total over 30 years into the CD.) This means that the return of premium rider itself would yield a higher overall return. (To learn more about risk tolerance, read Personalizing Risk Tolerance and Determining Risk And The Risk Pyramid.)

Now, let's put this into perspective. In Example 2, $318 is spent every year for 30 years to recover a total of $26,400; this translates into an annual tax-free rate of return of approximately 6.25%. This money is tax free because it is a return of principal.

It is important to keep in mind that if the policy owner dies at any time during the term period, simply buying just the traditional term coverage and investing the difference will always provide the greatest return on capital, because in this case the policy owner's estate would not only receive the death benefit but can distribute the invested cash as well. Therefore, if the policy owner feels that there is a substantial chance that he or she will not outlive the term, then the return-of-premium rider would likely be inappropriate.

Whether it is better to purchase the return-of-premium rider or invest the difference ultimately will depend upon the policy owner's investment risk tolerance, and his or her individual tax situation. For policy owners that can invest in tax-deferred or tax-free accounts and are comfortable investing in the markets, a basic term policy without the rider probably makes more sense. Higher income, risk averse policy owners will probably find the return of income rider with its guaranteed rate of return more appealing.

Related Articles
  1. Insurance

    Getting Life Insurance in Your 20s Pays Off

    Find out how Americans in their 20s can benefit from a well-thought-out life insurance policy, especially if they are able to build cash value for retirement.
  2. Insurance

    Using LinkedIn to Find Life Insurance Leads

    Learn how LinkedIn can help you generate leads as a life insurance agent, and understand the steps to turn your profile into a lead-generating machine.
  3. Retirement

    Why Are Annuities Important for Retirement?

    Understand how annuities work, and identify the benefits they provide for retirement, the most salient being a guaranteed income stream for life.
  4. Savings

    Become Your Own Financial Advisor

    If you have some financial know-how, you don’t have to hire someone to advise you on investments. This tutorial will help you set goals – and get started.
  5. Professionals

    How to Create a Retirement Co-Op in Your Community

    As the retirement boom continues, retirement co-ops are growing in popularity. Here's how to set one up in your community.
  6. Insurance

    The 4 Best Alternatives to Long-Term Care Insurance

    Understand what long-term care insurance is and the types of people who need this coverage. Learn about four alternatives to long-term care insurance.
  7. Insurance

    How Car Insurance Companies Value Cars

    Learn the methodology used by car insurance companies to value cars, and understand why the amount they give you may not cover the cost of a similar vehicle.
  8. Stock Analysis

    How Does Oscar Work and Make Money?

    Learn how startup Oscar is taking on the health insurance giants by offering customers free doctor's visits, generic drugs and 24-hour phone access to doctors.
  9. Retirement

    The Better Way to Save: Life Insurance or IRA?

    Sure, you can tap your permanent life insurance policy to help fund your retirement. But in most cases, an IRA is the better choice. Here's why.
  10. Insurance

    Life vs. Health Insurance: Choosing What to Buy

    When you only buy the coverage you truly need, the debate over medical insurance vs. life insurance might just be one you can avoid.
  1. Can I borrow from my annuity to put a down payment on a house?

    You can borrow from your annuity to put a down payment on a house, but be prepared to pay an assortment of fees and penalties. ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Are Cafeteria plans exempt from Social Security?

    Typically, qualified benefits offered through cafeteria plans are exempt from Social Security taxes. However, certain types ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What are the biggest disadvantages of annuities?

    Annuities can sound enticing when pitched by a salesperson who, not coincidentally, makes huge commissions selling them. ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What are the risks of annuities in a recession?

    Annuities come in several forms, the two most common being fixed annuities and variable annuities. During a recession, variable ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. How can I determine if a longevity annuity is right for me?

    A longevity annuity may be right for an individual if, based on his current health and a family history of longevity, he ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Can your life insurance company sue you?

    A life insurance company generally cannot sue you, but it can sue your estate. The company may do this in order to recover ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center
You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!