Greater gender balance in the workplace – especially in leadership positions – can help companies improve their organizational performance, operating results and market valuations, states Axiom Consulting Partners, a firm that helps businesses to clarify strategy, focus on value and achieve sustainable, profitable growth. Yet, the company states that men still dominate leadership positions, and companies often have policies that discourage women from rising to the top. What, then, can companies looking to achieve a greater gender balance do to make themselves more female-friendly in terms of work environment, workplace culture and benefits?
Women in Charge
In 2011, women held just 16.6% of board seats in Fortune 500 companies, according to a 2012 study by Catalyst, a nonprofit organization focused on expanding opportunities for women in business. The study reported that in 2011 women held 3.3% of board chairs, 8.4% of lead directors, 15.9% of audit committee chairs, 11.3% of compensation committee chairs and 19.0% of nominating/governance chairs.
However, common explanations for why women don’t hold or aren’t qualified for many advanced positions within companies, such as a lack of commitment, lack of ambition or leaving work to care for family, may be untrue.
If a company really wants to attract and retain top female talent, it must make more effort in the area of talent development, says Adrienne Graham, a 20-year recruiting veteran and founder and CEO of EmpowerMe!, a business growth strategies consulting firm. Graham offers a number of paths companies can pursue to achieve talent development and retention of their female employees: professional development, career coaching, mentoring and grooming for bigger projects and promotions, and better communication and guidance regarding each woman’s career trajectory. She adds that some companies’ women’s affinity programs are in name only as a gesture to stay out of compliance trouble.
Alisa Cohn, an executive coach, MBA and CPA, works with women to help them achieve success as leaders and executives. She says that when women see people like them rising in the ranks at work, they believe it is possible for them to rise into senior positions, too.
Cohn offers two tools companies can implement to ensure a pipeline of women rising into senior positions. The first is mentorship programs where a senior executive takes a woman under his or her wing and evaluates her job performance, gives advice and helps her strategize how to make the most of her opportunities. The mentor should also improve visibility of her sponsor’s accomplishments by promoting her name in front of her peers and throughout the company, Cohn says.
“When a company formally or informally encourages its senior leaders to mentor and sponsor women, the company becomes a better place to work for women overall, and more women are promoted into senior ranks,” Cohn says. “The result is more of a critical mass of women and a climate of comfort for women, which causes its own upward virtuous cycle.”
Cohn also recommends what she calls “executive presence training.” She says that women who are ready to take on larger, more visible roles at work sometimes don’t come across as confident. By training women to develop an executive presence in terms of gravitas, communication and appearance, companies create a larger cadre of women who can command the room. Senior leaders are then more likely to put those women into high-stakes and high-visibility situations, she says.
Women want to rise to the top, but they don’t want to give up every other component of their lives to do it. We all want to be able to have balance in our lives, whether it’s balancing work and family or balancing work and school.
Amy Zhang, CPA and managing member of Affinity Fund Services in San Francisco, was the youngest manager in her previous firm when she was promoted, but she decided to quit two years later. She saw that the female partners in her firm worked long, crazy hours and constantly struggled to balance work and family during the firm’s busy season. She also saw that their contributions weren’t valued as much as those of the male partners since they weren’t as loud.
“Male partners usually go out and bring back business,” Zhang says. “The female partners aren’t as social, or even if they are, they don’t have the time” to be as social because of family obligations. She says the women “did a fantastic job keeping the clients happy and loyal. However, since these contributions were not as obvious, they [didn’t] seem to be valued as much.” She says women need to see the company’s female leaders demonstrating positively what it’s like to be on top while having a family. Zhang now happily runs her own hedge fund administration firm.
“Today's most talented professionals can command a flexible work situation because there are enough organizations that offer them,” says Allison O'Kelly, founder and CEO of Mom Corps, a national flexible staffing firm dedicated to connecting progressive employers with high-level
professionals seeking flexible work options. “For a company looking to remain competitive and attract top talent, the solution is to find small ways to incorporate flexibility into the organization,” she says. Job-share positions in the C-suite, high-level part-time openings and more contract and temporary openings can help companies to “not only get the best talent in the door,” but also save money, O’Kelly says.
Leigh Steere, co-founder of Managing People Better, a research company that looks at gender and generational differences in management styles, lists several attributes that prevent employers from attracting and retaining top female talent:
- a commute that eats up time
- expectations to be available during a fixed set of business hours that make it difficult to volunteer in a classroom or attend children's school and extracurricular events
- endless meetings that chew up time or get scheduled at the last minute, creating conflicts with childcare arrangements, school pickups, pediatrician's appointments and other obligations
- an environment that allows a boss or colleague to commit an employee’s time without asking her first
- messages that taking time out for family or using flex options will slow or stall one’s career or that women who do so aren’t pulling their weight
- seeing similarly qualified single employees get promoted over working mothers
- business travel expectations that create logistical nightmares at home
Steere says that traditional work–life benefits like flex time, telecommuting and part-time schedules don’t help all women and suggests project-based employment as an alternative. Under such an arrangement, the employer defines the end product, deadline and compensation. A working mother gets the flexibility she needs to manage both work and family responsibilities, and the employer gets the benefits of the working mother’s expertise.
“As long as the employee delivers a quality end result by the deadline, it doesn't matter if the employee works at 2 a.m., or writes on a laptop while waiting for a child to finish soccer practice, or spends 40 hours on the project or 10 hours on it,” Steere says.
Family Friendly Benefits
According to the 2012 Working Mother 100 Best survey, a large percentage of the 100 best companies offered the following benefits that appeal to female employees:
- 100% offer paid maternity leave
- 98% offer health screening programs
- 96% offer on-site seasonal flu vaccinations
- 93% offer nutrition counseling
- 81% offer on-site fitness centers
- 100% offer telecommuting
- 62% offer dry-cleaning services
- 100% offer an on-site lactation room
- 97% offer a weight-loss program
- 95% offer a smoking-cessation program
- 93% offer adoption assistance
- 23% offer an on-site nap room
A dramatically smaller percentage of all U.S. companies offer these benefits. For example, only 57% offer telecommuting, and only 9% offer adoption assistance. Companies that want to attract more top female talent might look to the benefits offered by the 100 best companies as a model.
The Bottom Line
Attracting and retaining top female talent can bring companies many benefits, including a deeper talent pool, a more engaged leadership team and increased job satisfaction and company loyalty, Axiom states. Eliminating barriers to women’s advancement in the workplace through talent development, mentorship and executive presence programs; arrangements that respect working mothers’ scheduling needs; and a wide range of family-friendly benefits will help companies to achieve these goals.
Fundamental AnalysisCEOs, CFOs, presidents and vice presidents: learn how to tell the difference.
ProfessionalsWorkplace stress can cost companies tons of money in lost productivity and absenteeism. Some of that is out of their control, but often they are the cause.
Personal FinanceMany employees blame office politics when they fail to get promoted, but they may be sabotaging their own careers with these behaviors.
ProfessionalsRead an in-depth review and comparison of a career in investment banking and a career in corporate finance, with advice about which one to choose.
ProfessionalsCyber security attacks from a current or ex-employee can cause a lot of pain. Here is how to avoid such attacks.
EntrepreneurshipAnd how to make sure you do it the right way, following IRS guidelines.
EntrepreneurshipSTART-UP NY is an initiative designed to attract companies to New York State by giving them 10 years of tax breaks. Sounds good, but is it a success?
Investing NewsThe number of women entering the finance world continues to decline for a variety of reasons but a game-changing new nonprofit challenges the status quo.
EconomicsA silo mentality occurs when certain departments in an organization do not share information or knowledge with other departments.
EntrepreneurshipA self-employed individual works for herself instead of working for an employer that pays a salary or hourly wage.
Whistleblowers can play a critical role in ensuring the compliance, safety, honesty and legal fairness of governments and ... Read Full Answer >>
Before a business can assess or mitigate business risk, it must first identify probable or likely risks to its bottom line. ... Read Full Answer >>
Corporate governance refers to operational practices, management protocols, and other governing rules or principles by which ... Read Full Answer >>
Although specifically prohibited by employment law, employer retaliation against whistleblowers for exposing employers' wrongdoings ... Read Full Answer >>
After a prolonged period of corporate scandals involving large public companies from 2000 to 2002, the Sarbanes-Oxley Act ... Read Full Answer >>
C-suite executives are essential for creating and enacting overall firm strategy and are therefore an important aspect of ... Read Full Answer >>