Is it better to be bad than to be good? It is a question that has plagued humanity since the beginning of time, and the world of investing has not been immune to the controversy. In one corner are the fans of socially responsible investing (SRI), and in the other corner are the fans of sin stocks.

fans prefer an investment strategy that views successful investment returns and responsible corporate behavior as going hand in hand. They believe that by combining certain social criteria with rigorous investment standards, they can identify securities that will earn competitive returns and help build a better world.

Proponents of sin stocks have traditionally favored companies in the gambling, alcohol, tobacco and firearms industries. Any companies that make a profit have a place in their portfolios, regardless of whether the firm builds nuclear power plants, sells components for land mines or has questionable labor practices. This camp points out that somebody is going to profit from these industries, and argues that there's no reason to sit on the sidelines and miss out on the opportunity. (For more on this investment strategy, read our related article A Prelude To Sinful Investing.)

Buy in to Sin or Put Your Money Behind Your Convictions?
SRI fans argue that it's possible to do some good while making money. Their argument rests on the idea that socially responsible companies are likely to be well managed because their underpinnings are based on solid values. Sin stock fans argue that SRI mandates pass up good opportunities in companies that have strong fundamentals, trading profits for a feel-good factor. The sin stock crowd feels good when their investments deliver solid returns. They would rather put money in the bank by backing industries that meet consumer demand than starve for their convictions. Modern portfolio theory (MPT) seems to back their argument, as constructing the optimal portfolio should be more challenging if some stocks are removed from the universe of possible investments. (To learn more, read Modern Portfolio Theory: An Overview.)

A Look at the Numbers
The Pax World Balanced fund, launched on August 10, 1971, is the oldest operating SRI fund in the business. The Vice Fund, launched on August 30, 2002, is the industry's oldest sin fund. A look at their annualized returns (as of July 31, 2008) tells an interesting story. Both lost money during the past year, although Pax lost a lot less. During the last three years, Vice gets the edge, but just barely. For five years, the sinners get the nod.

Fund Name 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year Since Inception
Pax World Balanced -4.89% 3.74% 7.32% 5.96% 9.03%
Vice Fund -13.46% 4.12% 12.75% N/A 11.45%

Comparing the funds to their respective indexes provides another perspective. Pax delivered index-like performance across the board, while Vice bested its benchmark in all but the one-year period.

Fund Name 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year Since Inception
Pax World Balanced -4.89% 3.74% 7.32% 5.96% 9.03%
Dow Jones U.S. Moderate -4.31% 3.43% 7.29% 6.00% N/A
Fund Name 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year Since Inception
Vice Fund -13.46% 4.12% 12.75% N/A 11.45%
Russell 1000 -10.62% 3.08% 7.55% 3.38% N/A

Comparing the Vice Fund and the Domini Social Equity Fund to the Russell 1000, it is clear that the SRI fund lost less over the last year, but was outperformed over the three- and five-year periods.

Fund Name 1 Year 3 Year 5 Year 10 Year Since Inception
Russell 1000 -10.62% 3.08% 7.55% 3.38 N/A
Domini Social Equity Fund -11.89% 0.73% 4.70% 1.56% 8.37%
Vice Fund -13.46% 4.12% 12.75% N/A 11.45%

While there is no unilateral victory for either camp, things are not always as they seem. Where SRI once avoided gambling and alcohol, the Pax fund and a few others have relaxed that mandate, arguing that there are greater social ills and corporate governance issues to be concerned about and that gambling and alcohol are no longer viewed in the same light as they once were.

Interestingly, the funds tend to invest heavily in technology, healthcare and financial services. With scandal-plagued Enron and American International both making headlines for all the wrong reasons, and gambling and alcohol stocks now in their portfolios, the value of SRI screens seems to have at least a small question mark beside it in the minds of neutral investors who favor neither the sinners nor the saints. Screens aside, it is also important to consider the cyclical nature of the markets. When sectors, such as technology and healthcare, are topping the charts, sin stocks may be out of favor or at least underperforming the market leaders. Similarly, when stocks that SRI funds won't buy are leading the pack, sin stocks will outperform.

It is also worth noting that the universe of SRI funds vastly outnumbers the universe of sin funds. There are more than a dozen SRI funds, including big names, such as Dow Jones, Calvert, and KLD (PSE:KLD), and a number of exchange-traded funds (ETFs). (To learn more, read Socially Responsible Mutual Funds.)

On the sin stock side, there are fewer than half a dozen offerings, even with ETFs included, although there are plenty of individual securities that fit the mold, so constructing a portfolio based on stocks that SRI funds won't hold is easy to do. (Read Socially (Ir)responsible Mutual Funds to learn about your options.)

Investment Strategy
Where should you put your money? If your moral convictions won't permit investments in sin stocks, your choice has already been made. Just be sure to learn about the screening criteria for the funds that you are considering or you could end up with companies that don't represent your values in your portfolio.

If you're just looking to make a solid investment, moral convictions aside, a diversified portfolio including both saints and sinners may be the better choice.

Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Time to Bring Active Back into a Portfolio?

    While stocks have rallied since the economic recovery in 2009, many active portfolio managers have struggled to deliver investor returns in excess.
  2. Chart Advisor

    Now Could Be The Time To Buy IPOs

    There has been lots of hype around the IPO market lately. We'll take a look at whether now is the time to buy.
  3. Stock Analysis

    Why did Wal-Mart's Stock Take a Fall in 2015?

    Wal-Mart is the largest company in the world, with a sterling track-record of profits and dividends. So why has its stock fallen sharply in 2015?
  4. Investing News

    Should You Invest in Disney Stock Before Star Wars?

    The force is strong with Disney stock, as it continues to make gains going into the launch of EP7. But is this pricey stock a good buy at these levels?
  5. Investing News

    Silicon Valley Startups Fly into Space

    Space enthusiasts are in for an exciting time as Silicon Valley startups take on the lucrative but expensive final frontier.
  6. Chart Advisor

    Copper Continues Its Descent

    Copper prices have been under pressure lately and based on these charts it doesn't seem that it will reverse any time soon.
  7. Credit & Loans

    Pre-Qualified Vs. Pre-Approved - What's The Difference?

    These terms may sound the same, but they mean very different things for homebuyers.
  8. Options & Futures

    Cyclical Versus Non-Cyclical Stocks

    Investing during an economic downturn simply means changing your focus. Discover the benefits of defensive stocks.
  9. Insurance

    Cashing in Your Life Insurance Policy

    Tough times call for desperate measures, but is raiding your life insurance policy even worth considering?
  10. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Buying Vanguard Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs

    Learn about the differences between Vanguard's mutual fund and ETF products, and discover which may be more appropriate for investors.
  1. How liquid are Vanguard mutual funds?

    The Vanguard mutual fund family is one of the largest and most well-recognized fund family in the financial industry. Its ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Should mutual funds be subject to more regulation?

    Mutual funds, when compared to other types of pooled investments such as hedge funds, have very strict regulations. In fact, ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. How do mutual funds work in India?

    Mutual funds in India work in much the same way as mutual funds in the United States. Like their American counterparts, Indian ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Are UTMA accounts escheatable?

    Like most financial assets held by institutions such as banks and investment firms, UTMA accounts can be escheated by state ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What are the dormancy and escheatment rules for stock accounts?

    While the specific dormancy and escheatment rules for stock accounts vary by state, all states provide for the escheatment ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Does mutual fund manager tenure matter?

    Mutual fund investors have numerous items to consider when selecting a fund, including investment style, sector focus, operating ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Hot Definitions
  1. Take A Bath

    A slang term referring to the situation of an investor who has experienced a large loss from an investment or speculative ...
  2. Black Friday

    1. A day of stock market catastrophe. Originally, September 24, 1869, was deemed Black Friday. The crash was sparked by gold ...
  3. Turkey

    Slang for an investment that yields disappointing results or turns out worse than expected. Failed business deals, securities ...
  4. Barefoot Pilgrim

    A slang term for an unsophisticated investor who loses all of his or her wealth by trading equities in the stock market. ...
  5. Quick Ratio

    The quick ratio is an indicator of a company’s short-term liquidity. The quick ratio measures a company’s ability to meet ...
  6. Black Tuesday

    October 29, 1929, when the DJIA fell 12% - one of the largest one-day drops in stock market history. More than 16 million ...
Trading Center