Random Reinforcement: Why Most Traders Fail

By Cory Mitchell AAA

Random Reinforcement: Using arbitrary events to qualify (or disqualify) a hypothesis or idea; attributing skill or lack of skill to an outcome which is unsystematic in nature; finding support for positive or negative behaviors from outcomes which are inconsistent in nature - like the financial markets.

One of the most interesting topics in trading, and really throughout many areas of life, is what could be called random reinforcement. Random reinforcement, as it relates to harmful trading practices, occurs when a trader attributes a random outcome to skill or lack of skill. The market occasionally rewards bad habits and punishes good habits because the market is so dynamic. It is especially negative if a new trader who wins a few trades, with absolutely no plan whatsoever, attributes this success to "intuition". Random reinforcement can also hurt experienced traders who experience a string of losses and believe they no longer possess skill. (Find out how your mindset can play a larger role in your success than market influences, see Trading Psychology And Discipline.)

Random reinforcement can create long-term bad habits which are extremely hard to break. It is equivalent to a gambling addict as they keep playing because they win just enough to keep them there, but of course they are losing their money over the long run. A successful card player may also experience a significant draw down, abandon his proven strategy and in doing so gives his edge back to the house. (Learn more in 10 Cleaning Tips To Spruce Up Your Trading.)

How Random Reinforcement Affects Us in the Markets
The concept of random reinforcement is hard to grasp for some traders, but understanding it can be the difference between actually improving as a trader or simply believing we are improving when we are not. The best way to understand this to go through a few examples.

Example #1: Relying on Random
John is a new trader. He has a business background, watches the news and follows the stock market, but has not traded personally. He feels he has a good handle on what it takes to be a good trader, but so far he has not written any of these methods down. John has opened a trading account and believes his background knowledge will make him a profitable trader. Opening his charts for the first time John see a default stock in the trading platform and it is rising quickly. He quickly buys 200 shares without even thinking. The stock continues to rise while he makes lunch. After lunch he comes back and sells his shares, making himself a $100 profit after fees. John makes another trade and ends up with the same result. He is starting to feel that he is very good at this, and that he must have a "knack" for trading.

In analyzing the situation, experienced traders will notice a few things which could lead to short-lived trading career for this trader. The main problem is that several successful trades are not a valid sampling for if a trader will be profitable over the long run. John, the trader in this case, needs to make sure that he does not fall into the trap of believing his current methods, which are still very much untested, will bring him long-term success. The danger lies in refusing proper market guidance or methods, whether self created or provided by someone else, because this initial untested method is believed to be superior based on these preliminary trades. The trader can begin to think very strongly that if it worked once, it can work most, or all, of the time. The markets will not reward erroneous thinking over the long run, but will reward random and unplanned trades some of the time. (These steps will make you a more disciplined, smarter and, ultimately, a wealthier trader, see 9 Tricks Of The Successful Trader.)

In the next example we will look at random reinforcement again, but from a different angle. This example pertains more to experienced traders, or traders who are coming to the market with a written down strategy or method which is back tested or proven to be profitable in live trading. It should be noted that not all methods that were successful in the past will continue to be, as we just found out in the previous example (on a small scale). But methods that have shown success in the past are more likely to provide a chance of profitability in the future than a method which is completely untested or has never been profitable over the long run.

Example #2: Abandoning Strategy
John has now been trading in the markets for some time. He realized that approaching the market without a well thought out, written, and well researched plan was a mistake. He has overcome the problems evident in the first example and now has a solid trading plan for approaching the markets. This method has worked well over the last two years and he has made money.

John is now facing another problem. Despite past success with this plan, his method has now led him to nine consecutive losing trades and he is starting to worry that his plan is no longer working. John therefore changes his plan for trading as he feels his method is no longer valid. In doing so John ends up trading a new untested method, possibly similar to when he started trading.

The problem in this example becomes evident when John abandons his method, which has been successful, in exchange for a method which is unproven. This could put John right back to the beginning, even after trading successfully in the markets for a number of years. (For more, check out Day Trading Strategies For Beginners and Devising A Medium-Term Forex Trading System.)

Why did this happen? John failed to realize that while randomness can create winning streaks using a flawed trading method, randomness can also create a string of losses with an excellent trading plan. Therefore it is very important to make sure a trading plan is not actually going to work anymore (was the original success random?), or determine if this could simply be a run of losses based on current market conditions which will soon pass.

All traders experience losses, and there is no definitive number of losing trades in a row which will tell a trader if their plan is no longer working. Each strategy is different, but we can learn to deal with randomness.

What We Can Learn
Once we realize that randomness can create strings of losses in great trading plans, and also strings of profits in poor trading plans, (and also scenarios which fall in between these examples) how do we adjust to trade profitably over the long term?

While each trading plan is different, each trader must have a written down trading plan which outlines how they will trade. This plan should be well researched and lay out entries, exits and money management rules. In this way the trader will know over the long run if their plan is flawed or successful. It is also extremely important to risk a very small percentage of capital on each trade; risk levels of each trade should be covered in the trading plan under the money management section. This gives leeway to the trader as they will be able to withstand a string of losses and be less likely to make a pre-mature change in their trading plan when it is not needed. (It's impossible to avoid disaster without trading rules - make sure you know how to devise them for yourself with these Ten Steps To Building A Winning Trading Plan.)

Final Thoughts
The markets are extremely dynamic and in constant flux. This brings in an element of randomness that can create profits for unskilled traders and losses for skilled traders, and it happens all the time. A trader must also determine when a certain string of losses or profits can be attributed their skill, and when it is random. The only way to do this while you are learning is to approach the markets with a trading plan and risk a small percentage of capital on each trade. In this way the trader can see how a method performs over the long run where randomness becomes less of a factor. It is also important to remember that even the best traders and trading methods experience strings of losses and this is not reason to abandon the strategy. Although, isolating why the method is no longer working may help lessen the extent of the losses when similar adverse conditions arise again. (For a complete guide, read the Financial Ratios Tutorial or Investing 101 Tutorial.)

Related Articles
  1. How Advisors Can Help Clients Stomach ...
    Investing Basics

    How Advisors Can Help Clients Stomach ...

  2. An Introduction To Price Action Trading ...
    Trading Strategies

    An Introduction To Price Action Trading ...

  3. (Un)Mapping the Trend
    Charts & Patterns

    (Un)Mapping the Trend

  4. Technical Analysis Strategies for Beginners
    Trading Strategies

    Technical Analysis Strategies for Beginners

  5. Trading Volatile Stocks with Technical ...
    Trading Strategies

    Trading Volatile Stocks with Technical ...

Trading Center