A:

The short answer to this question is "both". Finance, as a field of study and an area of business, definitely has strong roots in other scientific fields such as statistics and mathematics. Furthermore, many modern financial theories resemble scientific nomenclature. However, there is no denying the fact that the financial industry also includes non-scientific elements that liken it to an art. For example, it has been discovered that human emotions (and decisions made because of them) play a large role in many aspects of the financial world.

Modern financial theories, such as the Black Scholes model, draw heavily on the laws of statistics and mathematics found in science; their very creation would have been impossible if science hadn't laid the initial groundwork. Also, theoretical constructs such as the capital asset pricing model (CAPM) and the efficient market hypothesis (EMH) attempt to logically explain the behavior of the stock market in an emotionless, completely rational manner, wholly ignoring elements such as market sentiment and investor emotions.

And while these and other academic advancements have greatly improved the day-to-day operations of the financial markets, history is ripe with examples that seem to contradict the notion that finance is a science. For example, stock market crashes such as the Oct 1987 crash (Black Monday), which saw the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) fall more than 22% and the great 1929 (Black Thursday) crash that spurred the Great Depression, are not suitably explained by scientific theories such as the EMH. (For further reading, see The Biggest Market Crashes.)

In addition, the track records of investors as a whole have shown that markets are not entirely efficient and, therefore, not entirely scientific. Studies have shown that investor sentiment appears to be mildly influenced by weather, with the overall market generally becoming more bullish when the weather is predominately sunny. Other phenomena include the January effect, which exposes the pattern of stock prices falling near the end of the calendar year and rising at the beginning of the next. (To learn more, see Taking A Chance On Behavioral Finance.)

Furthermore, certain investors have been able to consistently outperform the broader market for long periods of time, most notably famed stock-picker Warren Buffett, who at the time of writing is the second-richest American, his wealth largely built from long-term equity investments. The prolonged outperformance of a select few investors does much to discredit the EMH, leading some to believe that to be a successful equity investor, one needs to understand the science behind the number crunching and the art behind the stock picking exhibited by such investors as Warren Buffett. (For more about the "Oracle of Omaha", see Warren Buffett: How Does He Do It? and What Is Warren Buffett's Investing Style?)

The debate continues as to whether the field of finance is more accurately characterized as an art or a science - more than likely, it's a little bit of both.

For more detail from both sides of the debate, try reading Understanding Investor Behavior.

RELATED FAQS
  1. Is economics a science?

    Learn how economics fits into the category of social sciences, and discover the arguments critics make against this classification. Read Answer >>
  2. What does the efficient market hypothesis assume about fair value?

    Found out what the efficient market hypothesis says about the fair value of securities, and learn why technical and fundamental ... Read Answer >>
  3. What does the Efficient Market Hypothesis have to say about fundamental analysis?

    Find out what the efficient markets hypothesis has to say about fundamental analysis and how recent finance research has ... Read Answer >>
  4. What was the first stock Warren Buffett ever bought?

    Learn some the important basic principles of investing that are illustrated by Warren Buffett's first experience in the world ... Read Answer >>
  5. What are the primary assumptions of Efficient Market Hypothesis?

    Find out about the key assumptions behind the efficient market hypothesis (EMH), its implications for investing and whether ... Read Answer >>
  6. What did Warren Buffett mean when he said, “Diversification is protection against ...

    Learn what Warren Buffett meant when he stated that diversification is for ignorant investors and does not help those who ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Trading

    What Is Market Efficiency?

    The efficient market hypothesis (EMH) suggests that stock prices fully reflect all available information in the market. Is this possible?
  2. Markets

    The Efficient Market Hypothesis: Settling the Great Debate

    An understanding of neuroscience and the decision-making process provides a resolution to the decades-old debate between proponents and critics of the Efficient Market Hypothesis.
  3. Trading

    Modern Portfolio Theory vs. Behavioral Finance

    Modern portfolio theory and behavioral finance represent differing schools of thought that attempt to explain investor behavior. Perhaps the easiest way to think about their arguments and positions ...
  4. Markets

    The Uncertainty Of Economics: Exploring The Dismal Science

    Learning about the study of economics can help you understand why you face contradictions in the market.
  5. Investing

    Questions For Warren Buffett

    What would you ask this legendary investor, especially if you were told you could only ask five questions?
  6. Trading

    Understanding Investor Behavior

    Discover how some human tendencies can play out in the market, posing the question: are we really rational?
  7. Managing Wealth

    Think Like Warren Buffett

    They don't call him "The Oracle" for nothing. Learn how Buffett comes up with his winning picks.
  8. Trading

    7 Controversial Investing Theories

    We take a closer look at the theories that attempt to explain and influence the market.
  9. Markets

    The Difference Between Finance And Economics

    Learn the differences between these closely related disciplines and how they inform and influence each other.
  10. Personal Finance

    Warren Buffett's Bear Market Maneuvers

    This esteemed investor rarely changes his long-term investing strategy, no matter what the market does.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Efficient Market Hypothesis - EMH

    An investment theory that states it is impossible to "beat the ...
  2. Finance

    The science that describes the management, creation and study ...
  3. Social Sciences

    A group of academic disciplines that examine society and how ...
  4. Behavioral Finance

    A field of finance that proposes psychology-based theories to ...
  5. Market Efficiency

    The degree to which stock prices reflect all available, relevant ...
  6. Black Monday

    October 19, 1987, when the Dow Jones Industrial Average (DJIA) ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Cyclical Stock

    An equity security whose price is affected by ups and downs in the overall economy. Cyclical stocks typically relate to companies ...
  2. Front Running

    The unethical practice of a broker trading an equity based on information from the analyst department before his or her clients ...
  3. After-Hours Trading - AHT

    Trading after regular trading hours on the major exchanges. The increasing popularity of electronic communication networks ...
  4. Omnibus Account

    An account between two futures merchants (brokers). It involves the transaction of individual accounts which are combined ...
  5. Weighted Average Life - WAL

    The average number of years for which each dollar of unpaid principal on a loan or mortgage remains outstanding. Once calculated, ...
  6. Real Rate Of Return

    The annual percentage return realized on an investment, which is adjusted for changes in prices due to inflation or other ...
Trading Center