Loading the player...

In capital budgeting, there are a number of different approaches that can be used to evaluate any given project, and each approach has its own distinct advantages and disadvantages.

All other things being equal, using internal rate of return (IRR) and net present value (NPV) measurements to evaluate projects often results in the same findings. However, there are a number of projects for which using IRR is not as effective as using NPV to discount cash flows. IRR's major limitation is also its greatest strength: it uses one single discount rate to evaluate every investment.

Although using one discount rate simplifies matters, there are a number of situations that cause problems for IRR. If an analyst is evaluating two projects, both of which share a common discount rate, predictable cash flows, equal risk, and a shorter time horizon, IRR will probably work. The catch is that discount rates usually change substantially over time. For example, think about using the rate of return on a T-bill in the last 20 years as a discount rate. One-year T-bills returned between 1% and 12% in the last 20 years, so clearly the discount rate is changing.

Without modification, IRR does not account for changing discount rates, so it's just not adequate for longer-term projects with discount rates that are expected to vary. (To learn more, read Taking Stock Of Discounted Cash Flow, Anything But Ordinary: Calculating The Present And Future Value Of Annuities and Investors Need A Good WACC.)

Another type of project for which a basic IRR calculation is ineffective is a project with a mixture of multiple positive and negative cash flows. For example, consider a project for which marketers must reinvent the style every couple of years to stay current in a fickle, trendy niche market. If the project has cash flows of -$50,000 in year one (initial capital outlay), returns of $115,000 in year two and costs of $66,000 in year three because the marketing department needed to revise the look of the project, a single IRR can't be used. Recall that IRR is the discount rate that makes a project break even. If market conditions change over the years, this project can have two or more IRRs, as seen below.


Thus, there are at least two solutions for IRR that make the equation equal to zero, so there are multiple rates of return for the project that produce multiple IRRs. The advantage to using the NPV method here is that NPV can handle multiple discount rates without any problems. Each cash flow can be discounted separately from the others.

Another situation that causes problems for users of the IRR method is when the discount rate of a project is not known. In order for the IRR to be considered a valid way to evaluate a project, it must be compared to a discount rate. If the IRR is above the discount rate, the project is feasible; if it is below, the project is considered infeasible. If a discount rate is not known, or cannot be applied to a specific project for whatever reason, the IRR is of limited value. In cases like this, the NPV method is superior. If a project's NPV is above zero, then it is considered to be financially worthwhile.

So, why is the IRR method still commonly used in capital budgeting? Its popularity is probably a direct result of its reporting simplicity. The NPV method is inherently complex and requires assumptions at each stage - discount rate, likelihood of receiving the cash payment, etc. The IRR method simplifies projects to a single number that management can use to determine whether or not a project is economically viable. The result is simple, but for any project that is long-term, that has multiple cash flows at different discount rates, or that has uncertain cash flows - in fact, for almost any project at all - simple IRR isn't good for much more than presentation value.

For more information on capital budgeting, see Spotting Profitability With ROCE.

  1. How much debt is too much when calculating capital budgeting?

    Learn how companies determine how much debt is acceptable when funding a new project by using the net present value to estimate ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the difference between the cost of capital and the discount rate?

    Learn about the differences between the cost of capital and the discount rate as they relate to estimating a required return ... Read Answer >>
  3. How can I calculate the hurdle rate in Excel?

    Learn how to evaluate potential investments. Common desktop software provides functions that can help make the decision with ... Read Answer >>
  4. What is the formula for calculating net present value (NPV) in Excel?

    Understand how net present value is used to estimate the anticipated profitability of projects or investments, and how to ... Read Answer >>
  5. What are the disadvantages of using net present value as an investment criterion?

    While net present value (NPV) calculations are useful when you are valuing investment opportunities, the process is by no ... Read Answer >>
  6. How do you use DCF for real estate valuation?

    Learn how discounted cash flow analysis is used for real estate valuation and the various factors that go into calculating ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Small Business

    Capital Budgeting: Which is Better, IRR or NPV?

    Using internal rate of return and net present value for capital budgeting evaluations often end in the same result. But there are times when using NPV to discount cash flows makes more sense.
  2. Investing

    Return on Investment (ROI) Vs. Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

    Read about the similarities and differences between an investment's internal rate of return (IRR) and its return on investment (ROI).
  3. Investing

    Internal Rate of Return Formula for Excel

    The internal rate of return, or IRR, is a popular metric businesses use to measure a project’s return on investment.
  4. Investing

    An Introduction To Capital Budgeting

    We look at three widely used valuation methods and figure out how companies justify spending.
  5. Financial Advisor

    Understanding Internal Rate Of Return

    Internal rate of return, or IRR, is one of the most popular methods of evaluating potential projects. Learn more about this important metric.
  6. Financial Advisor

    How to Compare Permanent Life Insurance Policies

    How you can use the internal rate of return to compare and purchase a permanent life insurance policy.
  7. Small Business

    Modified Internal Rate of Return (MIRR)

    Modified internal rate of return (MIRR) is a variant of the more traditional internal rate of return calculation.
  8. Financial Advisor

    A Guide on the Risk-Adjusted Discount Rate

    When a project or investment faces higher amounts of risk or uncertainty, it may be appropriate to utilize the risk-adjusted discount rate.
  9. Managing Wealth

    What's a Hurdle Rate?

    Hurdle rate has two meanings. In the business world, a business typically makes a decision on a capital project based on the net present value approach. To determine the net present value, the ...
  1. IRR Rule

    A measure for evaluating whether to proceed with a project or ...
  2. IRR

    The currency abbreviation or currency symbol for the Iranian ...
  3. Pooled Internal Rate Of Return - PIRR

    A method of calculating the overall internal rate of return (IRR) ...
  4. Modified Internal Rate Of Return - MIRR

    While the internal rate of return (IRR) assumes the cash flows ...
  5. Annuity Method Of Depreciation

    A method of depreciation centered around cost recovery and a ...
  6. Profitability Index

    An index that attempts to identify the relationship between the ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Return on Market Value of Equity - ROME

    Return on market value of equity (ROME) is a comparative measure typically used by analysts to identify companies that generate ...
  2. Majority Shareholder

    A person or entity that owns more than 50% of a company's outstanding shares. The majority shareholder is often the founder ...
  3. Competitive Advantage

    An advantage that a firm has over its competitors, allowing it to generate greater sales or margins and/or retain more customers ...
  4. Mutual Fund

    An investment vehicle that is made up of a pool of funds collected from many investors for the purpose of investing in securities ...
  5. Wash-Sale Rule

    An Internal Revenue Service (IRS) rule that prohibits a taxpayer from claiming a loss on the sale or trade of a security ...
  6. Porter Diamond

    A model that attempts to explain the competitive advantage some nations or groups have due to certain factors available to ...
Trading Center