What is an evergreen provision and how does it affect shareholders?

By Chris Gallant AAA
A:

It is common for publicly-traded corporations to provide more than just regular salary compensation to their management and key personnel. Often, corporate boards will decide to provide special compensation to key personnel, in order to attract and retain top talent and to help align management's interests with those of shareholders.

Such compensation commonly takes the form of stock option grants, in which a specified allotment of option contracts, with an exercise date set for some point in the future, is provided to selected employees. Selected employees can also be issued new shares by the corporation. Both forms of compensation can be very lucrative and, as the value of both common shares and stock options increases as the company's share price rises, both have the effect of aligning the economic interests of management and shareholders. In other words, if management's wealth rises and falls along with the company's stock price, managers have a real incentive to make sure they do what is needed to keep the company's share price climbing. If a company's managers were instead strictly paid a fixed annual salary with no equity compensation, they would not have as much of an economic motive to maximize shareholder wealth - at least, this is one of the primary arguments supporting the use of equity compensation for management and key personnel.

For shares or options to be legally issued to employees, a corporation's board must first approve the maximum allotment and specify the terms of the allotment. Such decisions are made at periodic board meetings, but rather than go through the process of approving allotments every year, a company can adopt what is known as an evergreen option provision, which provides for an automatic allotment of equity compensation every year.

The amount of the evergreen provision is usually based on the number of shares outstanding at the beginning of each year. For example, if XYZ Corp. had 50 million shares outstanding and an evergreen provision for equity compensation up to 5% of outstanding shares, XYZ would be able to issue 2.5 million shares' worth of compensation in the first year. Assuming the shares outstanding at the beginning of Year 2 are 52.5 million, the firm would then be able to issue 2.625 million shares (5% of the current shares outstanding) of equity compensation in the second year.

From the investor's perspective, there are both positive and negative aspects to an evergreen provision. On the positive side, this provision ensures that your company will continue to issue equity compensation to key personnel, and hopefully keep their efforts focused on maximizing the value of your shares. On the negative side, an evergreen provision represents an automatic dilution of your shares every year. In our example, since only the executives receiving the stock options get the new shares, the share issuance ends up increasing the total number of shares outstanding, but it does not increase the share holdings of current investors. Thus, current investors end up owning a smaller proportion of the company than they used to - this is called dilution. (For further reading, see The "True" Cost Of Stock Options and What is dilutive stock?)

If the benefits of equity compensation outweigh the cost of share dilution, then it is to the net benefit of shareholders to continue with the compensation system. However, evergreen provisions, unless otherwise specified, allow for equity compensation even in years when the company performs poorly, and thus can end up diluting shareholder value without providing any benefits.

To learn more, check out Lifting The Lid On CEO Compensation and

A New Approach To Equity Compensation.

RELATED FAQS

  1. What is the difference between arbitrage and hedging?

    Dive into two very important financial concepts: arbitrage and hedging. See how each of these strategies can play a role ...
  2. How do you trade put options on E*TRADE?

    Learn all about put option trading at E*TRADE. Explore margin accounts and become familiar with the different types of option ...
  3. How do you trade put options on Ameritrade?

    Learn about option trading with TD Ameritrade. Explore the different types of options and their possible impacts on the investors ...
  4. What is the difference between a short position and a short sale?

    Learn how short selling and short positioning are different, specifically in regards to the nature of the commodity being ...
RELATED TERMS
  1. Separation Of Powers

    An organizational structure in which responsibilities, authorities, ...
  2. Protected Cell Company (PCC)

    A corporate structure in which a single legal entity is comprised ...
  3. Registered Holder

    Shareholders who hold their shares directly with a company.
  4. Duty Of Loyalty

    A director's responsibility to act at all times in the best interests ...
  5. Duty Of Care

    One of two primary fiduciary duties of directors, the duty of ...
  6. Hard-To-Sell Asset

    An asset that is extremely difficult to dispose of either due ...

You May Also Like

Related Articles
  1. Options & Futures

    A Detailed Look Into China's Options ...

  2. Options & Futures

    Avoid These 10 Mistakes When Trading ...

  3. Options & Futures

    Options -- Accessing Stakes In Apple ...

  4. Options & Futures

    These Are The Top Brokerage Firms For ...

  5. Economics

    America's Most Notorious Corporate Criminals

Trading Center