A:

The most recent guidance issued by the IRS and the Treasury Department is Revenue Ruling 2002-62. There is some disagreement in the field about the definition of account as it relates to "changes to account balance" in this ruling and both sides make convincing arguments.

Argument A:
One side of the argument is that you can transfer a part of your account balance to another account, provided the amount transferred is not added to an IRA that already has assets. According to this argument, this type of transfer is acceptable, provided the following requirements are met:

1. You continue your substantially equal periodic payments (SEPP) according to the schedule. The SEPP payments can be made from either of the two IRAs or both.
2. Should you need to refigure your amount each year, as is required under the required minimum distribution (RMD) method, you include the balance of both IRAs.

An individual need not limit his or her SEPP calculation to one IRA. In fact, many individuals include the balances of more than one IRA in an SEPP calculation. Although the individual may be able to identify the assets by different account numbers, many feel that this is defined as one account, particularly if they are all established under one IRA adoption agreement.

Argument B:
The other side of the argument holds to the traditional definition of an account, which states that if you have an account number from which you are receiving SEPPs, you can't transfer a portion of the balance of that account number to another retirement account with a different identifying number. This seems to meet the definition as provided in Revenue Ruling 2002-62, but the question then becomes whether the Treasury and the IRS place such limitations on an individual's ability to diversify his or her investments.

Both sides of the argument make sense. However, while Argument B seems to take on the literal meaning of Revenue Ruling 2002-62, splitting the IRA should not be considered a modification, provided the SEPP IRA assets are not commingled with other IRA assets. To be sure, you may want to consider getting a private letter ruling (PLR) from the IRS if the assets are of significant value. Or you may want to go along with any recommendation from your own tax professional.

You are, however, allowed to transfer the full IRA balance, provided the assets are transferred to an IRA that holds no other assets and you continue the SEPP from the new IRA.

For further reading, see Moving Plan Assets: How To Avoid Mistakes, Moving Your Plan Assets? and Rules Regarding Substantially Equal Periodic Payments (SEPP).

This question was answered by Denise Appleby
(Contact Denise)

RELATED FAQS
  1. Will I incur a tax penalty when making withdrawls from my IRA in excess of my SEPP?

    Unfortunately, the IRA is "locked" for five years because of the requirement that the substantially equal periodic payment ... Read Answer >>
  2. What are the "certain requirements" that must be met for substantially equal periodic ...

    For substantially equal periodic payments (SEPPs), the distributions would occur from your IRA after you rollover the assets. ... Read Answer >>
  3. I stopped distributions from my retirement account while under Rule 72(t). Will this ...

    If an individual modifies a substantially equal periodic payment (SEPP), including discontinuing the SEPP before the end ... Read Answer >>
  4. Do I have to continue SEPPs for an inherited IRA?

    You may discontinue the payments. Once the person who is taking the substantially equal periodic payment (SEPP) dies or becomes ... Read Answer >>
  5. Once substantially equal periodic payments (SEPP) of an IRA have started, is the ...

    Typically, if you withdraw assets from an IRA or a qualified retirement plan sponsored by your employer while under the age ... Read Answer >>
  6. Can I move my IRA to a better income-producing opportunity?

    Yes. You may want to compare the IRA products offered by different financial institutions. Once you determine the financial ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Retirement

    Traditional IRAs: Eligibility Requirements

    By Denise ApplebyWho Can Establish a Traditional IRA?Any individual who has taxable compensation or self-employment income (earned by sole proprietors and partners) for the year, and will not ...
  2. Personal Finance

    Avoiding "Prohibited Transactions" In Your IRA

    To avoid jeopardizing your IRA assets, find out what transactions are prohibited.
  3. Retirement

    9 Penalty-Free IRA Withdrawals

    If you need to take early distributions, find out which exemptions allow you to avoid expensive consequences.
  4. Retirement

    Analyzing The Best Retirement Plans And Investment Options: Individual Retirement Accounts (IRAs)

    What they are: An individual savings account with tax incentives. Pros: Tax benefits - investments grow tax-deferred and contributions may be deductible; variety of investment options ...
  5. Retirement

    Moving Retirement Plan Assets: How To Avoid Mistakes

    Sometimes things go wrong in a simple transfer of funds. Make sure you know how to avoid penalties.
  6. Retirement

    How an IRA Works After Retirement

    You've read a lot about saving for your future retirement with IRAs. But what happens to the account when the future is here, and you actually retire?
  7. Retirement

    Unexpected 1099-R Form: What To Do

    Did your IRA custodian report distributions you thought were non-reportable? Find out what went wrong.
  8. Personal Finance

    5 Unusual IRA Investments Options

    These investment vehicles are less common, but could provide great returns while diversifying your retirement holdings.
  9. Retirement

    Tips On How To Use IRAs To Boost Retirement Savings

    According to the Trustees of the Social Security Fund, the fund will be depleted by 2037. Are you ready?
  10. Retirement

    Top 10 Mistakes To Avoid On Your IRA

    IRA rules are complicated. It's easy to make mistakes – and they can cost you big time.
RELATED TERMS
  1. IRA Transfer

    The transfer of funds from an Individual Retirement Account (IRA) ...
  2. Substantially Equal Periodic Payment - SEPP

    A plan that allows individuals who have invested in an IRA or ...
  3. IRA Rollover

    A transfer of funds from a retirement account into a Traditional ...
  4. Traditional IRA

    An individual retirement account (IRA) that allows individuals ...
  5. IRA Asset Will

    A document that specifies how the assets in an individual retirement ...
  6. Rule 72(t)

    An Internal Revenue Service (IRS) rule that allows for penalty-free ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Glass-Steagall Act

    An act the U.S. Congress passed in 1933 as the Banking Act, which prohibited commercial banks from participating in the investment ...
  2. Quantitative Trading

    Trading strategies based on quantitative analysis which rely on mathematical computations and number crunching to identify ...
  3. Bond Ladder

    A portfolio of fixed-income securities in which each security has a significantly different maturity date. The purpose of ...
  4. Duration

    A measure of the sensitivity of the price (the value of principal) of a fixed-income investment to a change in interest rates. ...
  5. Dove

    An economic policy advisor who promotes monetary policies that involve the maintenance of low interest rates, believing that ...
  6. Cyclical Stock

    An equity security whose price is affected by ups and downs in the overall economy. Cyclical stocks typically relate to companies ...
Trading Center