Is tracking error a significant measure for determining ex-post risk?

By Casey Murphy AAA
A:

Before we answer your question, let's first define tracking error and ex-post risk. Tracking error refers to the amount by which the returns of a stock portfolio or a fund differ from those of a certain benchmark. As you might expect, a fund that has a high tracking error is not expected to follow the benchmark closely, and it is generally seen as being risky.

The other component of the question is ex-post risk, which is a measure of the variance of an asset's returns relative to a mean value. In other words, ex-post risk is the statistical variance of an asset's historical returns. Many individuals would argue that tracking error is not the best measure to determine ex-post risk because it looks at the returns of a portfolio relative to a benchmark rather than looking at the variability in the portfolio's returns. Tracking error can be a useful tool when determining how closely a portfolio mimics a stable benchmark, or how efficient a portfolio's manager is at tracking a benchmark, but many would argue that this is not a good measure of how much an investor can expect to gain or lose on any given trading day. However, ex-post risk, unlike tracking error, can provide an estimate of the probability that the expected return of a portfolio will drop by a certain amount on any given day, which is why it is a common risk metric used by professionals when studying things such as value at risk.

Using tracking error as a measure of ex-post risk would only make sense when tracking error is equal to zero because when an investor's portfolio consists of many stable companies that have produced predictable, stable returns, the historical variance of the benchmark's returns would be equal to those of the portfolio.

To learn more see, Introduction To Value At Risk (VAR) - Part 1 and Part 2 and Determining Risk And The Risk Pyramid.

RELATED FAQS

  1. Is the Bureau of Labor Statistics accurate?

    Read this brief analysis of the accuracy of Bureau of Labor Statistics, including a summary of the types of reports issued ...
  2. Where is cost of living lowest in the world?

    Learn how the cost of living is the lowest in India based on numbers derived from the CPI and organizations like Expatistan ...
  3. How does the Bureau of Labor Statistics define contingent workers?

    Discover how contingent workers are a significant part of the labor force and are defined as persons who do not expect their ...
  4. How does the Bureau of Labor Statistics determine the Consumer Price Index (CPI)?

    Changes in the average price level of more than 200 goods and services across the U.S. economy are used to determine the ...
RELATED TERMS
  1. Forex Spread Betting

    A category of spread betting that involves taking a bet on the ...
  2. Compound Annual Growth Rate - CAGR

    The year-over-year growth rate of an investment over a specified ...
  3. Mass Index

    A form of technical analysis that looks at the range between ...
  4. Money Flow Index - MFI

    A momentum indicator that uses a stock’s price and volume to ...
  5. On-Balance Volume (OBV)

    A momentum indicator that uses volume flow to predict changes ...
  6. Negative Volume Index - NVI

    A technical indicator that relies on changes in a security’s ...
comments powered by Disqus
Related Articles
  1. Trading Volatile Stocks with Technical ...
    Trading Strategies

    Trading Volatile Stocks with Technical ...

  2. The Top Technical Indicators For Commodities ...
    Technical Indicators

    The Top Technical Indicators For Commodities ...

  3. All About Liquid Commodities
    Options & Futures

    All About Liquid Commodities

  4. The Six Things Investors Should Do Now
    Fundamental Analysis

    The Six Things Investors Should Do Now

  5. Lognormal and Normal Distribution
    Fundamental Analysis

    Lognormal and Normal Distribution

Trading Center