A:

Companies that report losses are more difficult to value than those that report consistent profits. Any metric that uses net income is basically nullified as an input when a company reports negative profits. Return on equity (ROE) is one such metric. However, not all companies with negative ROEs are always bad investments.

Reported Return on Equity

ROE is calculated as:

Net income / Shareholders’ equity

To get to the basic ROE formula, the numerator is simply net income, or the bottom-line profits reported on a firm’s income statement. The denominator for ROE is equity, or more specifically – shareholders’ equity.

Clearly, when net income is negative, ROE will also be negative. For most firms, an ROE level around 10% is considered strong and covers its costs of capital.

How it can Mislead

A firm may report negative net income, but it doesn’t always mean it is a bad investment. Free cash flow is another form of profitability and can be used in lieu of net income. Below is an example of how looking only at net income can be misleading.

Back in 2012, computer and printing giant Hewlett-Packard Co (HPQ) reported a number of charges to restructure its business. This included headcount reductions and writing down goodwill after a botched acquisition. These charges resulted in negative net income of $12.7 billion, or negative $6.41 per share. Reported ROE was equally dismal at -51%. However, free cash flow generation for the year was positive at $6.9 billion, or $3.48 per share. That’s quite a stark contrast from the net income figure that resulted in a much more favorable ROE level of 30%.

For astute investors, this could have provided an indication that HP wasn’t in as precarious position as its profit and ROE levels indicated. Indeed, the next year net income returned to a positive $5.1 billion, or $2.62 per share. Free cash flow improved as well to $8.4 billion, or $4.31 per share. The stock rallied strongly as investors started to realize that HP wasn’t as bad an investment as its negative ROE indicated.

The Bottom Line

The HP example demonstrates how looking at the traditional definition of ROE can mislead investors. Other firms chronically report negative net income, but have healthier free cash flow levels, which might translate into stronger ROE than investors could realize.

At the time of writing, Ryan C. Fuhrmann did not own shares in any of the companies mentioned in this article.

RELATED FAQS
  1. How do you calculate return on equity (ROE)?

    Return on equity (ROE) is a ratio that provides investors insight into how efficiently a company (or more specifically, its ... Read Answer >>
  2. What level of return on equity is common for a company in the banking sector?

    Discover what the average return on equity (ROE) ratio is for companies in the banking industry, and understand the significance ... Read Answer >>
  3. What is the average return on equity for a company in the financial services sector?

    Learn the importance of calculating a company's return on equity and what businesses in the financial services industry average ... Read Answer >>
  4. What is the average return on equity for a company in the oil & gas drilling sector?

    Investing in the oil and gas drilling sector can be a profitable endeavor for some investors, but it is first necessary to ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is the average return on equity for a company in the forest products sector?

    Investing in the forestry sector can provide a hedge against other asset classes, but investors should be aware of the sector's ... Read Answer >>
  6. How do you determine a tangible asset's useful life?

    Learn what the average return on equity for a company in the chemicals sector is and what factors influence changes in the ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    How Return On Equity Can Help You Find Profitable Stocks

    It pays to invest in companies that generate profits more efficiently than their rivals. This is where ROE comes in.
  2. Managing Wealth

    Analyzing BP's Return on Equity (ROE)

    Examine the return on equity (ROE) for British Petroleum, the slumping international energy company that seems to be falling behind its competitors.
  3. Managing Wealth

    Analyzing Microsoft's Return on Equity (ROE) (MSFT)

    Discover a detailed analysis of Microsoft's historical return on equity, and learn how its ROE stacks up to its competitors in the tech industry.
  4. Investing

    Decoding DuPont Analysis

    Get a deeper understanding of ROE with these three-step and five-step calculations.
  5. Markets

    Analyzing Google's Return on Equity (ROE) (GOOGL)

    Learn about Alphabet's return on equity. How has its ROE changed over time, how does it compare to its peers and what factors are driving ROE for the company?
  6. Markets

    Analyzing UPS's Return on Equity (ROE) (UPS)

    Learn about UPS's return on equity (ROE), an important metric for investors. It is useful to compare the historical ROE and in relation to peers.
  7. Markets

    Analyzing JetBlue's Return on Equity (JBLU)

    Learn about JetBlue's historical ROE and how it stacks up to similar-sized peers. ROE is a useful metric for investors to understand.
  8. Managing Wealth

    Understanding the DuPont Analysis

    DuPont analysis measures assets at their gross book value, rather than at net book value, in order to produce a higher return on equity (ROE).
  9. Markets

    Analyzing Amazon's Return on Equity (ROE) (AMZN)

    Learn how to analyze Amazon's return on equity (ROE), especially given the company's focus on capital investments, as opposed to short-term earnings.
  10. Investing

    ROA And ROE Give Clear Picture Of Corporate Health

    Both measure performance, but sometimes they tell a very different story. This is why they’re best used together.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Return On Equity - ROE

    The amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholders ...
  2. DuPont Analysis

    A method of performance measurement that was started by the DuPont ...
  3. Return

    The gain or loss of a security in a particular period. The return ...
  4. DuPont Identity

    An expression that breaks return on equity (ROE) down into three ...
  5. Net Income - NI

    1. A company's total earnings (or profit). Net income is calculated ...
  6. Net Investment Income

    Income received from investment assets (before taxes) such as ...
Hot Definitions
  1. Bond Ladder

    A portfolio of fixed-income securities in which each security has a significantly different maturity date. The purpose of ...
  2. Duration

    A measure of the sensitivity of the price (the value of principal) of a fixed-income investment to a change in interest rates. ...
  3. Dove

    An economic policy advisor who promotes monetary policies that involve the maintenance of low interest rates, believing that ...
  4. Cyclical Stock

    An equity security whose price is affected by ups and downs in the overall economy. Cyclical stocks typically relate to companies ...
  5. Front Running

    The unethical practice of a broker trading an equity based on information from the analyst department before his or her clients ...
  6. After-Hours Trading - AHT

    Trading after regular trading hours on the major exchanges. The increasing popularity of electronic communication networks ...
Trading Center