Are companies with a negative return on equity (ROE) always a bad investment?

By Ryan C. Fuhrmann AAA
A:

Companies that report losses are more difficult to value than those that report consistent profits. Any metric that uses net income is basically nullified as an input when a company reports negative profits. Return on equity (ROE) is one such metric. However, not all companies with negative ROEs are always bad investments. 

Reported Return on Equity

ROE is calculated as:

Net income / Shareholders’ equity   

To get to the basic ROE formula, the numerator is simply net income, or the bottom-line profits reported on a firm’s income statement. The denominator for ROE is equity, or more specifically – shareholders’ equity.

Clearly, when net income is negative, ROE will also be negative. For most firms, an ROE level around 10% is considered strong and covers its costs of capital.

How it can Mislead

A firm may report negative net income, but it doesn’t always mean it is a bad investment. Free cash flow is another form of profitability and can be used in lieu of net income. Below is an example of how looking only at net income can be misleading.

Back in 2012, computer and printing giant Hewlett-Packard Co (HPQ) reported a number of charges to restructure its business. This included headcount reductions and writing down goodwill after a botched acquisition. These charges resulted in negative net income of $12.7 billion, or negative $6.41 per share. Reported ROE was equally dismal at -51%. However, free cash flow generation for the year was positive at $6.9 billion, or $3.48 per share. That’s quite a stark contrast from the net income figure that resulted in a much more favorable ROE level of 30%.

For astute investors, this could have provided an indication that HP wasn’t in as precarious position as its profit and ROE levels indicated. Indeed, the next year net income returned to a positive $5.1 billion, or $2.62 per share. Free cash flow improved as well to $8.4 billion, or $4.31 per share. The stock rallied strongly as investors started to realize that HP wasn’t as bad an investment as its negative ROE indicated.    

The Bottom Line

The HP example demonstrates how looking at the traditional definition of ROE can mislead investors. Other firms chronically report negative net income, but have healthier free cash flow levels, which might translate into stronger ROE than investors could realize.

At the time of writing, Ryan C. Fuhrmann did not own shares in any of the companies mentioned in this article.

RELATED FAQS

  1. What is the difference between return on equity and return on capital?

    Return on equity (ROE) and return on capital (ROC) measure very similar concepts, but with a slight difference in the underlying ...
  2. What are the main components of the Federal Reserve's balance sheet?

    Find out which items are listed as assets and liabilities on the balance sheet of the Federal Reserve, and how to read the ...
  3. What's more important, cash flow or profits?

    Learn about the different effects that cash flow and profit have on a business so you can decide which aspect to focus on.
  4. Which leverage ratios are most useful for analyzing manufacturing companies?

    See which leverage ratios investors and creditors are likely to use when analyzing the debt burdens for manufacturing companies.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Return On Equity - ROE

    The amount of net income returned as a percentage of shareholders ...
  2. Return on Average Capital Employed - ROACE

    A financial ratio that shows profitability compared to investments ...
  3. Return On Assets Managed - ROAM

    A measure of profits shown as a percentage of the capital that ...
  4. Best's Capital Adequacy Relativity (BCAR)

    A rating of an insurance company’s balance sheet strength. Best’s ...
  5. Deferred Tax Asset

    A deferred tax asset is an asset on a company's balance sheet ...
  6. Earnings Per Share - EPS

    The portion of a company's profit allocated to each outstanding ...
Related Articles
  1. FYI On ROI: A Guide To Calculating Return ...
    Active Trading

    FYI On ROI: A Guide To Calculating Return ...

  2. SIC Vs. NAIC -An Introduction To Industry ...
    Fundamental Analysis

    SIC Vs. NAIC -An Introduction To Industry ...

  3. Investing In New York City REITs
    Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Investing In New York City REITs

  4. The Big Credit Card Companies Have Room ...
    Stock Analysis

    The Big Credit Card Companies Have Room ...

  5. Why Wall Street Is A Key Player In The ...
    Investing Basics

    Why Wall Street Is A Key Player In The ...

Trading Center