What is market cannibalization?

By Andrew Beattie AAA
A:

Market cannibalism is defined as the negative impact a company's new product has on the sales performance of existing products. This is best illustrated by the "Cola Wars" -

the marketing fight between Pepsi (NYSE:PEP) and Coca-Cola (NYSE:COKE), which lasted most of the 1970s and 1980s. The soft drink rivalry pushed Coca-Cola Co. to make one of the most famous marketing blunders in financial history. In the process of creating Diet Coke, the company's chemists discovered a new formulation for Coke. The new concoction was sweeter and smoother than the century-old formula upon which Coke had been built. In fact, it was similar to Pepsi - the drink that was eating away at Coke's domestic market share.

On April 23, 1985, Coca-Cola Co. announced that New Coke was on its way. Because of a strong preference for New Coke in consumer taste tests, Coca-Cola decided to pull the old Coke formula from the shelves. Essentially, the company was throwing away a century of branding by favoring the new, relatively unknown formula over the one that consumers had grown up with. For Coca-Cola executives, this made sense. Much like with software companies that pull old versions from the shelf when a new one is released, they didn't want their old product line to keep consumers from buying their new one. Unfortunately, this bold move backfired horribly.

Consumers rebelled and flooded Coca-Cola with angry letters and phone calls. Coke's stock and market share took multiple hits and Pepsi even proclaimed victory in the Cola Wars now that Coca-Cola had copied its taste. The influx of complaints led to a "We've heard you" marketing reverse. On July 11, 1985, mere months after its sudden exit, the old formula was re-introduced with "Classic" added to the title - probably better than "Old Coke". Coca-Cola Classic quickly ate up the sales of New Coke in a textbook case of market cannibalization, but the company's stock did recover for the most part. The marketing blunder may not have been as much of a disaster as it appears. The controversy and media attention attracted some fence-sitting consumers back to the Coca-Cola brand.

Nevertheless, the saga of New Coke turned off many investors and resulted in Coca-Cola becoming an undervalued wallflower that nobody wanted to touch. Due to the strong international presence of Coke, however, investing sage Warren Buffet started buying significant amounts of Coca-Cola stock in the late '80s, which proved to be one of his most profitable buys. Despite its flirtation with a branding disaster and market cannibalization, Coke remains one of the world's strongest brands and a stalwart company to boot.

(For more on this topic, read Warren Buffet: The Road to Riches.)

This question was answered by Andrew Beattie.

RELATED FAQS

  1. What is the Razor/Razorblade model?

    The Razor/Razorblade business model owes its name to one King Gillette, founder of the eponymous razorblade company. The ...
  2. What does greenwashing mean?

    The term "greenwashing" was added to the Oxford English dictionary in 1999, where it is defined as "disinformation disseminated ...
RELATED TERMS
  1. Big Data

    The growth in the volume of structured and unstructured data, ...
  2. Social Media Marketing (SMM)

    The use of social media websites and social networks to market ...
  3. Social Media Optimization (SMO)

    The use of social media networks to develop and manage an organization’s ...
  4. Electronic Commerce - ecommerce

    A type of business model, or segment of a larger business model, ...
  5. Relativity Trap

    A psychological or behavioral trap that leads people to make ...
  6. Trickle-Down Effect

    A phenomenon where an advertisement is rapidly disseminated by ...
comments powered by Disqus
Related Articles
  1. The Green Marketing Machine
    Fundamental Analysis

    The Green Marketing Machine

  2. Advertising, Crocodiles And Moats
    Professionals

    Advertising, Crocodiles And Moats

  3. The Power Of Branding
    Entrepreneurship

    The Power Of Branding

  4. How Doing Your 'Share' Has Enriched ...
    Investing News

    How Doing Your 'Share' Has Enriched ...

  5. What's At Stake As Google Takes On Amazon? ...
    Investing News

    What's At Stake As Google Takes On Amazon? ...

Trading Center