A:

United States Steel Corportation (NYSE:X) was the world's first company to surpass the market capitalization mark of $1 billion dollars. In the early 1900s, John Piermont Morgan wanted to do for steel what he had done in railroads. The only problem was that Andrew Carnegie controlled the biggest and most efficient producer of steel, Carnegie Steel. Morgan worked with Charles Schwab to convince Carnagie to sell his business into the new entity envisioned by Morgan, U.S. Steel. Carnegie, already pondering retirement, agreed to sell to the Morgan-headed trust for an overall price of about $492 million in stocks and bonds of the new company. Carnegie went on to focus on philanthropy while Schwab necame the president of U.S. Steel.

Unfortunately for Schwab, U.S. Steel was an ungainly welding of mediocre businesses onto Carnegie Steel's lean frame. To bring the rest of the company up to snuff, U.S. Steel needed to raise huge amounts of capital. In 1901, Morgan issued $303 million in mortgage bonds, $510 million in preferred stock, and $508 million in common stock – creating a total capitalization of approximately $1.4 billion - on a company with real assets of $682 million. Thus, half of its worth was goodwill, but the public bought into the overvalued securities.

U.S. Steel would never fulfill its potential and, although Schwab's management postponed the reckoning, saw its market share eaten up by hungrier companies, including Schwab's Bethlehem Steel, formed when he left U.S. Steel in frustration. In fact, one of the owners of U.S. Steel's dissapointing shares was Benjamin Graham's widowed mother. Watching the family's wealth shrink with the shares might have motivated the intelligent investor to focus on hard assets and intrinsic value, discounting egregious amounts of goodwill. (Read more about the famous J.P. Morgan in our article, The Kingpin Of Wall Street: J.P. Morgan.)

This question was answered by Andrew Beattie.

RELATED FAQS
  1. What are common advantages of investing in large cap stocks?

    Learn what large-cap stocks are and how investors can benefit from common advantages of adding large-cap stocks to their ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is graphene? (HAYD.L, TSLA)

    Learn about the discovery of this new material graphene and its basic characteristics as well as how it can be used in various ... Read Answer >>
  3. What is an appropriate large cap mutual fund fee?

    Discover what an appropriate fee for a large-cap mutual fund should be, and learn how choosing index mutual funds can lead ... Read Answer >>
  4. How did Enron use off-balance-sheet items to hide huge debts and toxic assets?

    Find out how Enron misused special purpose vehicles to hide mountains of debt prior to its infamous scandal and collapse ... Read Answer >>
  5. Where did the term 'Nostro' account come from?

    Discover where the term "nostro account" came from and how, since its Renaissance foundation, its meaning has evolved to ... Read Answer >>
  6. Can the Herfindahl-Hirschman Index be used to determine competitive balance in professional ...

    Understand what types of key performance indicators can be measured more than once a month and what indicators should be ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Retirement

    Charles Schwab vs. Employee Fiduciary: Comparing Small Business 401(k) Providers

    Learn about the key differences between Charles Schwab and Employee Fiduciary 401(k) plans in terms of company structure, fund offerings and client service.
  2. Investing News

    What eBay's Valuation Means for PayPal (EBAY, PYPL)

    Discover why eBay had such a high valuation when it separated from PayPal in July 2015, and what effects the separation had on each company.
  3. Markets

    Understanding Capitalization-Weighted Indexes

    A capitalization-weighted index is a market index whose individual components are weighted according to their market capitalization.
  4. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    PRWCX: Portfolio Trends in 2016

    Discover how the portfolio trends in the T.Rowe Price Capital Appreciation Fund helped to keep performance positive in 2016 and learn how it can help your portfolio.
  5. Investing

    Ben Graham's Advice on Reading Financial Statements

    Seven pieces of advice from Benjamin Graham on understanding financial statements.
  6. Investing Basics

    What Thematic Dominance Among Mega-caps Means

    The ranks of mega-caps are now dominated by U.S. companies and two broad sectors to an unprecedented extent. Should investors be worried?
  7. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Fund Highlight: Parnassus Core Equity Fund (PRBLX)

    Learn about the Parnassus Core Equity Fund, which invests in a concentrated portfolio of stocks of companies that have socially responsible businesses.
  8. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Looking to Hedge Volatility? Try These 2 ETFs

    The U.S. equity market has been experiencing turbulence in 2016. Discover analyses of two exchange-traded funds to hedge against volatility.
  9. Stock Analysis

    2 Consumer Staples Stocks Near Their 52-Week Lows Worth Buying (WBA, FLO)

    Consider the fundamentals for Walgreens Boots Alliance and Flowers Foods as post-earnings report price reductions create bargains for investors.
  10. Stock Analysis

    2 Industrials Stocks Near Their 52-Week Lows Worth Buying (XLI, AME)

    Watch for Ametek and Steelcase to climb above their respective 50-day moving averages for the first time in 2016 as a result of strong returns on equity.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Lean Enterprise

    A production and management philosophy that considers any part ...
  2. S&P 500 Dividend Aristocrats

    Companies that have had an increase in dividends for 25 consecutive ...
  3. Purple Chip Stock

    A term coined by portfolio manager John Schwinghamer to describe ...
  4. Blue-Chip Index

    A stock index that tracks the shares of the top-performing publicly ...
  5. Blue Chip Indicator

    A formal gauge or measure of the performance of a selected group ...
  6. Graham Number

    A figure that measures a stock's fundamental value by taking ...

You May Also Like

Trading Center