A:

It depends. If the excess contribution is removed from your Roth IRA by your tax-filing deadline plus any extensions, along with any net attributable income (NIA), the 6% excise tax does not apply. If the excess contribution is not removed by the deadline, you owe the IRS a 6% excise tax for every year the amount remains in your Roth IRA as an excess contribution. An exception applies if the market value of your Roth IRA for the previous year-end is less than the excess contribution. Under this exception, the 6% excise tax would apply to the market value of your Roth IRA for the previous year-end, instead of to the contribution amount.

Note: Bear in mind that excess contributions that remain in your Roth IRA gets applied as a Roth IRA contribution for the following year, and continues until the excess is used up.

When you overcontribute to your Roth, the 6% penalty applies on the amount contributed, regardless of its current value. For example, if an excess contribution of $5,000 was made and the market value declined to $2,500 by the end of the year, the 6% penalty would still apply to the $5,000. The loss of market value does not change the rules. That may seem unfair, but look at it another way: if the original amount had grown to $10,000, the penalty would still only apply to the $5,000.

To learn more, read Correcting Ineligible IRA Contributions - Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3.

This question was answered by Denise Appleby.

RELATED FAQS
  1. My certificate of deposit (CD) has just matured and I plan to contribute $10,000 ...

    Your regular Roth IRA contribution can't exceed $4,000 annually. If you are at least age 50 by Dec 31, 2005, you can contribute ... Read Answer >>
  2. How do I open a Roth IRA if my Husband and I make over $300k?

    Between my husband and I, we make around 350k to 400k a year.  ... Read Answer >>
  3. Can an individual contribute to both a Roth IRA and a Traditional IRA in the same ...

    Yes, an individual can contribute to both a Roth IRA and a Traditional IRA in the same year. The total contribution into ... Read Answer >>
  4. Can I still contribute to my Roth IRA if my spouse earns over the requirement cap?

    My spouse makes over the amount allowed to contribute to a Roth IRA. However, I do not. Is it possible... Read Answer >>
  5. I just learned that my 2004 and 2005 Roth IRA contributions are not allowed because ...

    The 2004 excess amount to your Roth IRA would have to be removed by October 15, 2005, to avoid the 6% penalty (assuming that ... Read Answer >>
  6. I recently and accidentally established a Roth IRA for my spouse instead of myself ...

    Don't feel too badly. We all make mistakes. The good news is that you may have some time to make the proper corrections.The ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Retirement

    Roth IRA Contribution Rules: The Basics

    What you need to know about Roth IRA contributions – from eligibility to dollar limits, deadlines to tax breaks.
  2. Retirement

    Roth IRA Contribution Limits in 2016

    Discover the benefits of Roth IRA accounts and how much you can contribute for your retirement. Learn which IRA plan is best for you.
  3. Retirement

    Roth 401(k) Vs. Roth IRA: Which One Is Better?

    It all depends on your age, your income - and your plans for your retirement nest egg.
  4. Retirement

    Don't Make These Top 10 Mistakes On Your Roth IRA

    Don't lose out on the benefits of a Roth by contributing too much, breaking rollover rules or making other avoidable errors.
  5. Retirement

    How a Roth IRA Works After Retirement

    What retirees need to know about taxes, distributions and passing on your unspent savings to the next generation.
  6. Retirement

    How Can I Fund A Roth IRA If My Income Is Too High To Make Direct Contributions?

    Some high-income earners are subject to a contribution phase-out schedule that can keep them from contributing directly to their Roth IRAs.
  7. Options & Futures

    5 Secrets You Didn't Know About Roth IRAs

    Between its generous tax benefits at retirement and no required minimum distributions, a Roth IRA is well worth considering if you're eligible to have one.
  8. Financial Advisors

    Why Some Advisors are Shy to Convert Roth IRAs

    Potential upcoming changes from the Obama Administration could hit rollovers from traditional to Roth IRAs, and that has advisors reluctant to convert.
  9. Retirement

    Comparing Contributions: Roth 401(k) vs. Roth IRA

    Which one works better for you? Read on.
  10. Retirement

    The Backdoor Way to Qualify for a Roth IRA

    Meet with your tax advisor to find out what a backdoor Roth IRA is. Basically, it's a tax loophole that could help you prepare for retirement.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Roth IRA

    An individual retirement plan that bears many similarities to ...
  2. Backdoor Roth IRA

    A method that taxpayers can use to place retirement savings in ...
  3. Ordering Rules

    The order in which Roth IRA assets are distributed. Assets are ...
  4. Roth IRA Conversion

    A reportable movement of assets from a Traditional, SEP or SIMPLE ...
  5. Recharacterization

    The treatment of a contribution as being made to another type ...
  6. Individual Retirement Account - IRA

    An investing tool used by individuals to earn and earmark funds ...
Trading Center