I overcontributed to my Roth, then lost half of this money to the market. Does the 6% penalty apply to my original contribution, or only what's left of it?

By Denise Appleby AAA
A:

It depends. If the excess contribution is removed from your Roth IRA by your tax-filing deadline plus any extensions, along with any net attributable income (NIA), the 6% excise tax does not apply. If the excess contribution is not removed by the deadline, you owe the IRS a 6% excise tax for every year the amount remains in your Roth IRA as an excess contribution. An exception applies if the market value of your Roth IRA for the previous year-end is less than the excess contribution. Under this exception, the 6% excise tax would apply to the market value of your Roth IRA for the previous year-end, instead of to the contribution amount.

Note: Bear in mind that excess contributions that remain in your Roth IRA gets applied as a Roth IRA contribution for the following year, and continues until the excess is used up.

When you overcontribute to your Roth, the 6% penalty applies on the amount contributed, regardless of its current value. For example, if an excess contribution of $5,000 was made and the market value declined to $2,500 by the end of the year, the 6% penalty would still apply to the $5,000. The loss of market value does not change the rules. That may seem unfair, but look at it another way: if the original amount had grown to $10,000, the penalty would still only apply to the $5,000.

To learn more, read Correcting Ineligible IRA Contributions - Part 1, Part 2 and Part 3.

This question was answered by Denise Appleby.

RELATED FAQS

  1. Does it make sense to convert a Traditional IRA to a Roth when the market’s down?

    If your modified adjusted gross income (MAGI) is $100,000 or less and you are not married filing separately, you may initiate ...
  2. Can I roll a Traditional IRA into a 529 college account for my grandchild?

    A 529 plan, also known as a "qualified tuition program", is an investment vehicle that allows individuals to save for education ...
  3. Can I still set up an SEP if one of my employees refuses to participate?

    You can establish the SEP IRA, even if the employee refuses to participant. However, you would need to establish an IRA for ...
  4. I want to close my IRA account. What percentage will I lose to tax?

    You can move the amount by means of a trustee-to-trustee transfer to another IRA, or roll over the amount to your 401(k). ...
RELATED TERMS
  1. Gold IRA

    Definition of Gold IRA
  2. Eligible Transfer

    An IRS-allowed movement of assets into or out of an individual ...
  3. Death Master File (DMF)

    Also known as Social Security Death Index. A list of people whose ...
  4. Leveraged Benefits

    The use – by a business owner or professional practitioner – ...
  5. Peri-Retirement

    A term for the period of time leading up to actual retirement. ...
  6. MyRA

    A new tax-advantaged retirement account that President Barack ...
comments powered by Disqus
Related Articles
  1. Impact Of Continuing To Work In Retirement ...
    Retirement

    Impact Of Continuing To Work In Retirement ...

  2. Independent 401(K): A Top Retirement ...
    Retirement

    Independent 401(K): A Top Retirement ...

  3. After-Tax Balance Rules For Retirement ...
    Taxes

    After-Tax Balance Rules For Retirement ...

  4. Guide To 401(k) And IRA Rollovers
    Retirement

    Guide To 401(k) And IRA Rollovers

  5. Should You Convert Your IRA?
    Retirement

    Should You Convert Your IRA?

Trading Center