A:

In theory, stimulus checks are intended to increase the amount of capital in the economy. By giving back tax dollars in the form of a stimulus check, governments hope that consumers will make purchases that will in turn provide business the capital they need to keep functioning. Even if the check is put in the bank, the logic goes, then the bank will have more deposited capital and will be able to lend more freely to businesses and individuals.

However, there are some problems with this theory. Banks may need to deleverage and will choose to hold on to deposited capital rather than loosen lending, as they have during credit crises. Similarly, companies may choose to hold onto profits to form a war chest in anticipation of an economic downturn rather than increase production and hire more workers. And lastly, the people getting the checks may also choose to use them against debt or hold them in guaranteed government securities, stimulating nothing, but improving their personal situation. In short, all parties will look to their own self-interests over that of the economy.

That doesn't mean that the principle of stimulus checks is completely without value. If, instead of a temporary measure in a single check, permanent tax cuts at corporate and individual levels allowed both parties to keep more of their earned income, there is a good chance that the flow of capital would eventually increase. The long-term cut would mean that all the players in the economy could recapitalize, that is eliminate debts and increase savings, on ongoing basis. A stimulus check tries to reduce this long-term treatment down to a quick shot-in-the-arm and consequently has the potential to fail from a long run perspective.

For more, see How do government-issued stimulus checks affect the economy? and Do Tax Cuts Stimulate The Economy?

RELATED FAQS
  1. How do government-issued stimulus checks affect the economy?

    Stimulus checks are payments given to individuals by the government based on taxes paid in the previous year. The hope is ... Read Answer >>
  2. Could I deposit a check I received from Edward Jones, cancelling my IRA account, ...

    I had a SIMPLE Individual Retirement Account through Edward Jones while working for M. Potteiger, Inc. I stopped working ... Read Answer >>
  3. How do you calculate payback period using Excel?

    Understand the various fees that can be assessed on a personal or business checking account, and learn methods to avoid being ... Read Answer >>
  4. Where does stimulus economics come from?

    Depending on which type of economist you talk to, stimulus economics originated from the ideas of either a book published ... Read Answer >>
  5. How does bouncing a check affect my credit score?

    Learn the many indirect effects on your credit score when you bounce a check. Read Answer >>
  6. How does total capital investment influence economic growth?

    Discover the basic relationship between capital investment and economic growth, and why improving the capital structure increases ... Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Investing

    Banking: Check-Writing 101

    By Amy FontinelleThe ability to write checks from your checking account allows you to pay bills or send money to relatives more securely than using cash and less expensively than using a cashier's ...
  2. Trading

    Global Bailout: Did The U.K. Do Enough?

    The stimulus packages through the recession varied from country to country. Only time will tell who weathered the storm best.
  3. Markets

    Have Stocks Seen the Bottom Yet?

    The market has been turbulent as of late. But have stocks hit bottom?
  4. Personal Finance

    What is a Cashier’s Check?

    A cashier’s check is a check written on a financial institution’s funds.
  5. Personal Finance

    What is a Bounced Check?

    Bounced check is a slang term to describe a check that cannot be processed because its writer has insufficient funds.
  6. Investing

    Why I'm Following Buffett Into This Beaten-Down Market

    As an economist for the state of Iowa, I learned that economic stimulus can affect growth -- but only if given time to work. Of course, patience is not something investors or the markets are ...
  7. Trading

    Banking: Managing Your Checking Account

    By Amy FontinelleBecause your checking account is the nexus of all your banking activity - the main place that your money flows in and out of - you'll need to do a few things to keep an eye on ...
  8. Personal Finance

    2015's Top Checking Account Promotions

    Open a checking account in 2015 and the bank could give you a cash bonus. Check out these top offers.
  9. Markets

    Demystification Of Bank Accounts

    Find out which type of account suits your specific needs.
  10. Retirement

    How To Do a Background Check on Prospective Employees

    Discover why background checks can be extremely costly, tips for small businesses conducting checks on a budget and if professional checks can be avoided.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Stimulus Check

    A check sent to a taxpayer by the U.S. government. Stimulus checks ...
  2. Economic Stimulus

    Attempts by governments or government agencies to financially ...
  3. Check Hold

    Denotes a period of time equal to the maximum number of days ...
  4. Crossed Check

    Any check that is crossed with two parallel lines, either across ...
  5. Stimulus Package

    A package of economic measures put together by the government ...
  6. Negative Float

    The period of time between when a bank customer writes a check ...
Trading Center