When buying a car, it may be better to have a down payment rather than a trade in. A trade in offers convenience to the car buyer, since one can walk into a dealership with a used vehicle and walk out – or rather, drive out – with a brand-new automobile. But this convenience comes at a significant cost, since most buyers are likely to leave cash on the table by receiving less for their trade in than what it is worth. The dealer is likely to offer an even lower price if the trade in is from a car manufacturer that is different from the one the dealership represents.

The preferred course of action would be to sell the car privately before buying a replacement vehicle and using the sale proceeds as a down payment. But arranging for a private sale can be a time consuming and cumbersome process involving a number of steps. These include ensuring that the vehicle is sale worthy and advertising the sale, to making the car available for test drives and ensuring the full sale proceeds are received once the car is sold. The timing also has to be near perfect in a private sale, in order to avoid being without an automobile for an inordinately long time.

When comparing a trade in to a private sale, then, it boils down to how much the convenience factor is worth. Receiving a couple hundred dollars less for a trade in, as opposed to a private sale, may be well worth the hassle involved in the latter, for most people.

Regardless of whether the old car is being traded in or sold privately, the seller should have a good idea of what the vehicle is actually worth before coming up with a good price for it. Over-inflated expectations of the value of the car may result in reasonable offers being turned down, while inaccurately low estimates will hurt the seller's pocketbook. A number of online sites provide estimates for both trade ins and private sales.

In the end, it may be best to arrange a down payment rather than a trade in when buying a car. But if that is not possible and a trade in is the only option, do your research beforehand to obtain an estimate of the value of your vehicle. A few hours of research can save you hundreds – if not thousands – of dollars, by fetching you a better price for your trade in than a dealer's lowball offer.

  1. How much of an automaker's revenue is derived from service?

    Learn more about what sector of the automotive industry profits from the service and maintenance performed on cars, and how ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the importance of residual value in an automobile lease?

    Find out how dealerships assign residual value and why this is an important factor in car leases. Learn about a tactic some ... Read Answer >>
  3. What's the best way to finance a car?

    The best ways to finance an automobile purchase include a hire purchase and self-financing. Read Answer >>
Related Articles
  1. Personal Finance

    7 Mistakes to Avoid When Buying a Used Car

    Understand the benefits of buying a used car. Learn about seven mistakes to avoid before making a used car purchase.
  2. Personal Finance

    Used Car Shopping: How To Avoid A Lemon

    Being prepared before buying will save you thousands in the long run.
  3. Retirement

    Is It Worth Buying a New Car If You're Already Retired?

    You have to consider more than just the purchase price: Insurance, the warranty, resale value and how much you plan to drive are all important factors.
  4. Personal Finance

    5 Ways To Buy A Used Car

    Buying a used car usually takes a little extra effort, but it can save buyers a considerable amount of money.
  5. Managing Wealth

    The Best (and Worst) Times to Buy a Car

    Timing your purchase – along with some attention to the features you need – can save you thousands on your new wheels.
  6. Personal Finance

    Your Car: Fixer-Upper Or Scrap Metal?

    Sometimes buying a new car can be cheaper than shelling out for repairs.
  7. Personal Finance

    10 Steps To Buying A Car (Without Getting Taken For A Ride)

    Ready to buy a new or gently used car? Before you get dazzled by the balloons and the new car smell, follow these ten steps to get the best deal.
  8. Personal Finance

    Options For When You Can No Longer Afford Your Car

    If you have more car than you can afford, here are four ways to deal with this "debt on wheels."
  9. Insurance

    Free Car Payment Insurance: What's The Catch?

    Many dealers are offering payment protection plans on new cars. Are they right for you?
  10. Taxes

    5 Reasons To Buy A New Car

    Even the most frugal drivers have a tipping point. Is it time for a new car?
  1. Selling Out Of Trust

    A term commonly used in the automobile industry to refer to the ...
  2. Gap Insurance

    A type of auto insurance that car owners can buy to protect themselves ...
  3. Cash For Clunkers

    A program that allows car owners to trade in their old, less ...
  4. Buy Here Pay Here

    Used car dealers who also handle vehicle financing for the buyer, ...
  5. Business Automobile Policy - BAP

    An insurance policy that covers a company's use of cars, trucks, ...
  6. Auto Sales

    The major producers of domestic automobiles report sales monthly. ...
Trading Center