Corporate Finance - Advantages and Disadvantages of the NPV and IRR Methods

While useful NPV and IRR methods are useful methods for determining whether to accept a project, both have their advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages:

  • With the NPV method, the advantage is that it is a direct measure of the dollar contribution to the stockholders.
  • With the IRR method, the advantage is that it shows the return on the original money invested.
Disadvantages:
  • With the NPV method, the disadvantage is that the project size is not measured.
  • With the IRR method, the disadvantage is that, at times, it can give you conflicting answers when compared to NPV for mutually exclusive projects. The 'multiple IRR problem' can also be an issue, as discussed below.
 
The Multiple IRR Problem
A multiple IRR problem occurs when cash flows during the project lifetime is negative (i.e. the project operates at a loss or the company needs to contribute more capital).

This is known as a "non-normal cash flow", and such cash flows will give multiple IRRs.

Why Do NPV and IRR Methods Produce Conflicting Rankings?
When a project is an independent project, meaning the decision to invest in a project is independent of any other projects, both the NPV and IRR will always give the same result, either rejecting or accepting a project.

While NPV and IRR are useful metrics for analyzing mutually exclusive projects - that is, when the decision must be one project or another - these metrics do not always point you in the same direction. This is a result of the timing of cash flows for each project. In addition, conflicting results may simply occur because of the project sizes.

Look Out!
The timing of cash flows as well as project sizes can produce conflicting results in the NPV and IRR methods.

Example: NPV and IRR Analysis
Assume once again that Newco needs to purchase a new machine for its manufacturing plant. Newco has narrowed it down to two machines that meet its criteria (Machine A and Machine B), and now it has to choose one of the machines to purchase. Further, Newco has assumed the following analysis on which to base its decision:

Figure 11.6: Potential Machines for Newco

 

Answer:
We first determine the NPV for each machine as follows:

NPVA = ($5,000) + $2,768 + $2.553 = $321

NPVB = ($10,000) + $5,350 + $5,106 = $456

According to the NPV analysis alone, Machine B is the most appropriate choice for Newco to purchase.

The next step is to determine the IRR for each machine using our financial calculator. The IRR for Machine A is equal to 13%, whereas the IRR for Machine B is equal to 11%.

According to the IRR analysis alone, Machine A is the most appropriate choice for Newco to purchase.

The NPV and IRR analysis for these two projects give us conflicting results. This is most likely due to the timing of the cash flows for each project as well as the size differential between the two projects.

The Post-Audit's Role
The post-audit process in the capital-budgeting process is quite important. In the post-audit process, an analyst examines a company's capital-budgeting decisions to see how the actual results from the projects compare to the results the company estimated. The post-audit process gives the company a sense of not only how the projects are performing, but also how good its inputs were.

If a project's actual results differed significantly in a negative direction, the post-audit process will help the company learn where it went wrong with respect to inputs so that the same mistake will not be made when analyzing future projects.

Applying NPV Analysis to Project Decisions


Related Articles
  1. Term

    Internal Rate of Return Formula for Excel

    The internal rate of return, or IRR, is a popular metric businesses use to measure a project’s return on investment.
  2. Investing Basics

    Capital Budgeting: The Capital Budgeting Process At Work

    This tutorial will conclude with some basic, yet illustrative examples of the capital budgeting process at work. Example 1: Payback PeriodAssume that two gas stations are for sale with the following ...
  3. Fundamental Analysis

    Return on Investment (ROI) Vs. Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

    Read about the similarities and differences between an investment's internal rate of return (IRR) and its return on investment (ROI).
  4. Insurance

    How to Compare Permanent Life Insurance Policies

    How you can use the internal rate of return to compare and purchase a permanent life insurance policy.
  5. Economics

    Modified Internal Rate of Return (MIRR)

    Modified internal rate of return (MIRR) is a variant of the more traditional internal rate of return calculation.
  6. Stock Analysis

    The Worry-Free Options Strategy With A Perfect Record

    The S&P 500 has been on fire in 2013 -- up an impressive 30%.But the question I'm getting the most from readers right now is, "Is the market about to correct?" It's not hard to see why. The ...
  7. Professionals

    Project Manager: Career Path & Qualifications

    Learn more about what project managers job, the qualifications necessary for the position and the most common careers for these professionals.
  8. Professionals

    10 Ways to Improve Cash Flow in Construction

    Improving cash flow in construction requires some sector-specific strategies.
  9. Investing Basics

    Capital Budgeting: Evaluating The Desirability Of An Investment

    In sum, the capital budgeting process is the tool by which a company administers its investment opportunities in additional fixed assets by evaluating the cash inflows and outflows of such opportunities. ...
  10. Professionals

    Common Interview Questions for Project Managers

    Discover the basic skills needed for a position as a project manager along with common interview questions used in applying for such a position.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Internal Rate Of Return - IRR

    A metric used in capital budgeting measuring the profitability ...
  2. IRR

    The currency abbreviation or currency symbol for the Iranian ...
  3. IRR Rule

    A measure for evaluating whether to proceed with a project or ...
  4. Net Present Value - NPV

    Net Present Value (NPV) is the difference between the present ...
  5. Pooled Internal Rate Of Return ...

    A method of calculating the overall internal rate of return (IRR) ...
  6. Annuity Method Of Depreciation

    A method of depreciation centered around cost recovery and a ...
RELATED FAQS
  1. Which is a better measure for capital budgeting, IRR or NPV?

    In capital budgeting, there are a number of different approaches that can be used to evaluate any given project, and each ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the formula for calculating internal rate of return (IRR) in Excel?

    Understand how to calculate the internal rate of return (IRR) using Excel and how this metric is used to determine anticipated ... Read Answer >>
  3. How much debt is too much when calculating capital budgeting?

    Learn how companies determine how much debt is acceptable when funding a new project by using the net present value to estimate ... Read Answer >>
  4. How do you use discounted cash flow to calculate a capital budget?

    Learn how discounted cash flows are used in creating capital budgets as a part of the net present value and internal rate ... Read Answer >>
  5. What is the relationship between the hurdle rate (MARR) and the Internal Rate of ...

    Find out how companies and managers use hurdle rate, or MARR, and internal rate of return, or IRR, to evaluate projects and ... Read Answer >>
  6. Why is the Modified Internal Rate Of Return (MIRR) preferable to the regular internal ...

    See why the modified internal rate of return is often a superior metric to the classic internal rate of return for assessing ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Goldilocks Economy

    An economy that is not so hot that it causes inflation, and not so cold that it causes a recession. This term is used to ...
  2. White Squire

    Very similar to a "white knight", but instead of purchasing a majority interest, the squire purchases a lesser interest in ...
  3. MACD Technical Indicator

    Moving Average Convergence Divergence (or MACD) is a trend-following momentum indicator that shows the relationship between ...
  4. Over-The-Counter - OTC

    Over-The-Counter (or OTC) is a security traded in some context other than on a formal exchange such as the NYSE, TSX, AMEX, ...
  5. Quarter - Q1, Q2, Q3, Q4

    A three-month period on a financial calendar that acts as a basis for the reporting of earnings and the paying of dividends.
  6. Weighted Average Cost Of Capital - WACC

    Weighted average cost of capital (WACC) is a calculation of a firm's cost of capital in which each category of capital is ...
Trading Center