Corporate Finance - Advantages and Disadvantages of the NPV and IRR Methods

While useful NPV and IRR methods are useful methods for determining whether to accept a project, both have their advantages and disadvantages.

Advantages:

  • With the NPV method, the advantage is that it is a direct measure of the dollar contribution to the stockholders.
  • With the IRR method, the advantage is that it shows the return on the original money invested.
Disadvantages:
  • With the NPV method, the disadvantage is that the project size is not measured.
  • With the IRR method, the disadvantage is that, at times, it can give you conflicting answers when compared to NPV for mutually exclusive projects. The 'multiple IRR problem' can also be an issue, as discussed below.
 
The Multiple IRR Problem
A multiple IRR problem occurs when cash flows during the project lifetime is negative (i.e. the project operates at a loss or the company needs to contribute more capital).

This is known as a "non-normal cash flow", and such cash flows will give multiple IRRs.

Why Do NPV and IRR Methods Produce Conflicting Rankings?
When a project is an independent project, meaning the decision to invest in a project is independent of any other projects, both the NPV and IRR will always give the same result, either rejecting or accepting a project.

While NPV and IRR are useful metrics for analyzing mutually exclusive projects - that is, when the decision must be one project or another - these metrics do not always point you in the same direction. This is a result of the timing of cash flows for each project. In addition, conflicting results may simply occur because of the project sizes.

Look Out!
The timing of cash flows as well as project sizes can produce conflicting results in the NPV and IRR methods.

Example: NPV and IRR Analysis
Assume once again that Newco needs to purchase a new machine for its manufacturing plant. Newco has narrowed it down to two machines that meet its criteria (Machine A and Machine B), and now it has to choose one of the machines to purchase. Further, Newco has assumed the following analysis on which to base its decision:

Figure 11.6: Potential Machines for Newco

 

Answer:
We first determine the NPV for each machine as follows:

NPVA = ($5,000) + $2,768 + $2.553 = $321

NPVB = ($10,000) + $5,350 + $5,106 = $456

According to the NPV analysis alone, Machine B is the most appropriate choice for Newco to purchase.

The next step is to determine the IRR for each machine using our financial calculator. The IRR for Machine A is equal to 13%, whereas the IRR for Machine B is equal to 11%.

According to the IRR analysis alone, Machine A is the most appropriate choice for Newco to purchase.

The NPV and IRR analysis for these two projects give us conflicting results. This is most likely due to the timing of the cash flows for each project as well as the size differential between the two projects.

The Post-Audit's Role
The post-audit process in the capital-budgeting process is quite important. In the post-audit process, an analyst examines a company's capital-budgeting decisions to see how the actual results from the projects compare to the results the company estimated. The post-audit process gives the company a sense of not only how the projects are performing, but also how good its inputs were.

If a project's actual results differed significantly in a negative direction, the post-audit process will help the company learn where it went wrong with respect to inputs so that the same mistake will not be made when analyzing future projects.

Applying NPV Analysis to Project Decisions


Related Articles
  1. Professionals

    Advantages And Disadvantages Of NPV and IRR

    Find out how to decide when to use these two methods, and when to avoid them.
  2. Professionals

    Net Present Value (NPV) and the Internal Rate of Return (IRR)

    CFA Level 1 - Net Present Value (NPV) and the Internal Rate of Return (IRR). Learn how to calculate net present value and internal rate of return. Provides samples highlighting the relationship ...
  3. Investing Basics

    Capital Budgeting: Capital Budgeting Decision Tools

    Once projects have been identified, management then begins the financial process of determining whether or not the project should be pursued. The three common capital budgeting decision tools ...
  4. Professionals

    Capital Budgeting

    Capital budgeting is really important when making important business decisions.
  5. Economics

    Capital Budgeting: Which is Better, IRR or NPV?

    Using internal rate of return and net present value for capital budgeting evaluations often end in the same result. But there are times when using NPV to discount cash flows makes more sense.
  6. Professionals

    Introduction To Net Present Value And Internal Rate Of Return

    These valuation methods will help you make investing decisions.
  7. Professionals

    Net Present Value and the Internal Rate of Return

    CFA Level 1 - Discounted Cash Flow Applications - Basics
  8. Professionals

    Internal Rate Of Return

    Find out how to use IRR to analyze capital budgeting projects.
  9. Term

    Internal Rate of Return Formula for Excel

    The internal rate of return, or IRR, is a popular metric businesses use to measure a project’s return on investment.
  10. Professionals

    Comparing Projects With Unequal Lives

    CFA Level 1 - Comparing Projects With Unequal Lives. Learn how comparing projects with unequal lives can offer conflicting NPV and IRR results. Offers two methods to remedy the problem.
RELATED TERMS
  1. Internal Rate Of Return - IRR

    A metric used in capital budgeting measuring the profitability ...
  2. IRR Rule

    A measure for evaluating whether to proceed with a project or ...
  3. Net Present Value - NPV

    Net Present Value (NPV) is the difference between the present ...
  4. Pooled Internal Rate Of Return ...

    A method of calculating the overall internal rate of return (IRR) ...
  5. The Net Internal Rate Of Return ...

    A measure of a portfolio or fund's performance that is equal ...
  6. Modified Internal Rate Of Return ...

    While the internal rate of return (IRR) assumes the cash flows ...
RELATED FAQS
  1. Which is a better measure for capital budgeting, IRR or NPV?

    In capital budgeting, there are a number of different approaches that can be used to evaluate any given project, and each ... Read Answer >>
  2. What is the formula for calculating internal rate of return (IRR) in Excel?

    Understand how to calculate the internal rate of return (IRR) using Excel and how this metric is used to determine anticipated ... Read Answer >>
  3. How much debt is too much when calculating capital budgeting?

    Learn how companies determine how much debt is acceptable when funding a new project by using the net present value to estimate ... Read Answer >>
  4. What's the difference between weighted average cost of capital (WACC) and internal ...

    Both weighted average cost of capital (WACC) and internal rate of return (IRR) are great measures for assessing value, but ... Read Answer >>
  5. How do you use internal rate of return to calculate a capital budget?

    Learn about how the internal rate of return is used in the creation of a capital budget along with net present value and ... Read Answer >>
  6. What is the formula for calculating the internal rate of return (IRR)?

    Learn about the internal rate of return, an important concept in determining the relative attractiveness of different investments. Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Law Of Demand

    A microeconomic law that states that, all other factors being equal, as the price of a good or service increases, consumer ...
  2. Cost Of Debt

    The effective rate that a company pays on its current debt. This can be measured in either before- or after-tax returns; ...
  3. Yield Curve

    A line that plots the interest rates, at a set point in time, of bonds having equal credit quality, but differing maturity ...
  4. Stop-Limit Order

    An order placed with a broker that combines the features of stop order with those of a limit order. A stop-limit order will ...
  5. Keynesian Economics

    An economic theory of total spending in the economy and its effects on output and inflation. Keynesian economics was developed ...
  6. Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunications ...

    A member-owned cooperative that provides safe and secure financial transactions for its members. Established in 1973, the ...
Trading Center