Ethics and Standards - Standard IV-C: Responsibilities Of Supervisors

Members and Candidates must make reasonable efforts to detect and prevent violations of applicable laws, rules, regulations, and the Code and Standards by anyone subject to their supervision or authority.

Reasoning behind Standard IV-C
An ethical violation reflects not only on the conduct of that employee, but on the ability (or inability) of that person's supervisor to control or influence this conduct in an ethical manner. In a number of situations, a violation of some law, rule or regulation takes place purely due to the fact that the employee who was guilty of the conduct did not know any better and was not adequately guided by the supervisor. In other words, this employee would've likely not made the violation had he or she been fully aware that it was a violation.

Supervisors can play a crucial role in terms of taking the authority and responsibility to positively influence the behavior and conduct of those below them on the company chart. If a supervisor is a CFA Member or Candidate, this Standard takes this responsibility a step further and requires those with supervisory responsibilities to take specific preventative actions in the course of guiding the conduct of others.

Key Points to Remember about Standard IV-C

1.The responsibility to guide employee conduct in an ethical manner is that of the CFA Member or Candidate who assumes that supervisory role, and the Standard holds whether or not the supervised employees are CFA Institute members, CFA charterholders or candidates in the CFA program. The Code and Standards are not something that we as CFA charterholders follow but don't expect others to abide by; rather, they are a minimum standard to which we hold ourselves and which we wish to spread to those around us. Standard IV-C uses the authority we have to impress these ideals on others, even if these people are not specifically bound by the Code and Standards.

2."Reasonable supervision" is determined by the situation, typically as a function of the number of employees supervised and the specific jobs being done. For example, an individual who oversees a large equity-trading operation with hundreds of employees will need to pay particular attention to procedure, given the large number of employees and the scrutiny (and potential for insider dealings and other malfeasance) found when trading securities. A person in this role cannot possibly keep track of every individual every minute of the day, which is why a supervisor is permitted to rely upon reasonable procedures. By contrast, someone who supervises just one person, or a handful of people, is likely to be capable of personally evaluating every individual's conduct, and if the jobs are of a less sensitive nature (e.g. administrative help around the office), where violations are simply less likely to occur, then the reasonable procedures and controls on which one can rely may be relatively simple and straightforward. Each case will have its unique procedures.

3.In cases where a law, rule or regulation is violated, it does not necessarily indicate that the supervisor violated Standard IV-C. However, when rules are broken, it is likely that the rules and procedures will be scrutinized, and it could mean that established rules are inadequate.

4.Merely enacting procedures does not necessarily discharge a supervisor of a potential violation of this Standard. For example, if a supervisor assembles a compliance manual just to satisfy the regulators, but then looks the other way while subordinates plagiarize or engage in insider trading, we would say that the supervisor's controls were insufficient for the case and he or she violated the Standard.

5.If a Member or Candidate finds a compliance system to be inadequate and prone to violations, but is unable to take corrective action, he or she must decline supervisory responsibility, in writing, until improved procedures are enacted. Members and Candidates are responsible for themselves and for subordinates on the company chart, and they are not permitted to ignore this Standard simply because "That's the way they did things there".

Applying Standard IV-C

  • Take extra care when designing procedures that could be misconstrued as a conflict of interest. As has been outlined previously, the mere appearance of impropriety must be addressed with increased sensitivity. For example, if a supervisor is charged with upholding securities laws at a brokerage, and he or she is compensated based on trading volume, it is possible that he or she could be accused of not adequately investigating (and potentially halting) certain trading patterns simply because doing so would decrease his or her compensation
  • It is the supervisor's responsibility to ensure that investment recommendations, reports and other products of a research effort are fully compliant with the Code and Standards. For example, when a supervisor passes along a report without an adequate review and that report contains misstatements, is plagiarized or uses material nonpublic information (or violates any other Standard), it is a violation for both the supervisor and the employee - particularly if the report is the basis for investment action.
  • A violation under a supervisor's watch isn't a violation per se, but the subsequent process for handling a potential violation can by itself violate Standard IV-C. As an example, if a subordinate employee is suspected of unfair dealings that may favor wealthy clients, and the supervisor brings the matter to the attention of the employee, the supervisor may not be doing enough by simply taking the employee's testimony that "it won't happen again". Even reporting the violation up the chain of command is not likely to be enough. So long as the matter is under investigation, additional actions must be taken (e.g. extra monitoring, limiting that employee's activities, suspending certain responsibilities) as a preferred course of action.

How to Comply

Questions regarding procedure on the exam may test Standard IV-C. If it comes up, remember two simple questions that will help in designing an effective compliance program:

1.Which violations in particular are most likely to occur?

2.What rules will best uncover and prevent these violations?

Designating a compliance officer, as well as making a compliance manual available to the organization are effective methods in ensuring the organization has a system of checks and balances. There should be an educational program in place, which continually updates personnel on compliance procedures.

Standard V-A: Diligence And Reasonable Basis


Related Articles
  1. Professionals

    Standard I-D: Misconduct

    CFA Level 1 - Standard I-D: Misconduct
  2. Professionals

    Standard I-A: Knowledge of the Law

    CFA Level 1 - Standard I-A: Knowledge Of The Law
  3. Professionals

    Standard VI-B: Priority Of Transaction

    CFA Level 1 - Standard VI-B: Priority Of Transaction
  4. Professionals

    THE ROLE OF THE PRINCIPAL

    Introduction The foundation of a firm’s supervisory system is its written supervisory manual, also known as the firm’s policy and procedures manual. All members are required to have ...
  5. Professionals

    Standard IV: Duties to Employers, Standard IV-A: Loyalty

    CFA Level 1 - Standard IV-A: Loyalty
  6. Professionals

    A. Introduction: General Supervision

    The foundation of a firm’s supervisory system is its written supervisory manual, also known as the firm’s policy and procedures manual. All members are required to have a policy and ...
  7. Professionals

    A. General Supervision: Introduction

    The foundation of a firm’s supervisory system is its written supervisory manual, also known as the firm’s policy and procedures manual. All members are required to have a policy and ...
  8. Professionals

    Standard I-B: Independence And Objectivity

    CFA Level 1 - Standard I-B: Independence And Objectivity
  9. Professionals

    D. Compliance and the Patriot Act

    The foundation of a firm’s supervisory system is its written supervisory manual, also known as the firm’s policy and procedures manual. All members are required to have a policy and ...
  10. Professionals

    Standard III-B: Fair Dealing

    CFA Level 1 - Standard: III-B: Fair Dealing
RELATED TERMS
  1. Brokerage Supervisor

    A brokerage company employee who appoints, trains and manages ...
  2. Macro Manager

    A boss or supervisor who lets employees do their jobs with minimal ...
  3. Breach Of Contract

    Violation of any of the agreed-upon terms and conditions of a ...
  4. Division Of Enforcement

    The Division of Enforcement is a branch of the U.S. Securities ...
  5. Account Supervisor

    An individual who oversees the handling of corporate client accounts ...
  6. Selling Away

    When a broker solicits you to purchase securities not held or ...
RELATED FAQS
  1. Darth Vader, CFA, will begin a new job next week with a regional brokerage firm ...

    The correct answer is: b) Standard III(A)- Inform Employer of Code and Standards mandates that a covered person inform his ... Read Answer >>
  2. What do I do if I think an accountant is in violation of the Generally Accepted Accounting ...

    Learn where to report financial accounting fraud if you suspect an accountant is in violation of the generally accepted accounting ... Read Answer >>
  3. The maximum fine that can be assessed for a violation of the USA is what amount?

    The maximum fine that can be assessed for a violation of the USA is what amount? a. $3,000b. $5, 000c. $10,000d. $20,000 The ... Read Answer >>
  4. Does technology follow the law of diminishing marginal returns?

    Learn how workers in the technology industry are affected by the law of diminishing marginal returns, and note the ways that ... Read Answer >>
  5. John King, a CFA, resides in Jurisdiction A, where the securities laws and regulations ...

    The correct answer is d. Since the Law of Locality applies, and King performs his business in Jurisdiction B (where securities ... Read Answer >>
  6. Who enforces GAAP?

    Take a deeper look at the private enforcement mechanisms behind the generally accepted accounting principles for American ... Read Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Cost Of Debt

    The effective rate that a company pays on its current debt. This can be measured in either before- or after-tax returns; ...
  2. Yield Curve

    A line that plots the interest rates, at a set point in time, of bonds having equal credit quality, but differing maturity ...
  3. Stop-Limit Order

    An order placed with a broker that combines the features of stop order with those of a limit order. A stop-limit order will ...
  4. Keynesian Economics

    An economic theory of total spending in the economy and its effects on output and inflation. Keynesian economics was developed ...
  5. Society for Worldwide Interbank Financial Telecommunications ...

    A member-owned cooperative that provides safe and secure financial transactions for its members. Established in 1973, the ...
  6. Generally Accepted Accounting Principles - GAAP

    The common set of accounting principles, standards and procedures that companies use to compile their financial statements. ...
Trading Center