The taxability of disability income benefits is a pretty simple concept to master if you pay particular attention to "who pays the premiums".

When disability benefits are received for an employer-provided disability policy, these benefits are generally included as taxable income to the recipient. If the disability benefits are received from a policy where the individual made the premium payments, then the benefits are excluded from taxable income. Some hybrid disability policies exist; whereas, part is provided by the employer and the other part by the individual- in this case benefits will be includible in income to the extent of the employer pro rata share of premiums.

Structure of Disability Contract Tax Consequence of Premium Tax Consequence of Benefits Paid

Type A:
Individually Owned
Employer pays premiums
Tax Deductible by Employer Taxable to Individual

Type B:
Individually Owned
Individual pays premiums
Non-Deductible by Individual Tax Exempt to Individual

Practice Question:
Jim has a salary of $70,000 with Widget Corporation (S Corporation) which puts him in the 25% tax bracket. His employer gives Jim a bonus in the form of the cost of disability insurance (premium $4,000) which is added to Jim's W-2. If Jim becomes totally disabled, he is entitled to 60% of his salary in disability benefits. What is Jim's after-tax monthly disability benefit if he is in the 15% tax bracket during his disability?

A. $2,625
B. $2,975
C. $3,000
D. $3,500

Answer: D
Jim's employer pays Jim a bonus of $4,000 which is applied directly to disability premiums on an individual disability policy for Jim. Jim's W-2 income will reflect $74,000. Therefore, Jim will pay tax on the premium payments and is considered the premium payer and therefore will not be taxed on the monthly disability benefits. He would receive $3,500 per month tax-free ($70,000 x 60% divided by 12 months).
Introduction to Long Term Care

Related Articles
  1. Financial Advisor

    How to Help Clients Who Have Become Disabled

    Disability can strike a client any time. Advisors should make sure clients are adequately insured against this risk and know what benefits are available.
  2. Managing Wealth

    Tips for Insuring Your Salary

    Those with high incomes really can’t afford to be without disability insurance. Here's why.
  3. Financial Advisor

    Disability and Business Overhead Coverage for the Self-Employed

    What every small business owner or professional needs to know about individual and business overhead disability income insurance plans.
  4. Insurance

    Protecting Your Income With Disability Insurance

    For a high-earning professional, income protection is essential. Here's what to look for in a disability insurance policy.
  5. Retirement

    Do You Qualify for Social Security Disability?

    When it comes to qualifying for Social Security Disability Insurance, you either do or you don’t. Here's how to find out if you do and how to apply.
  6. Financial Advisor

    How to Manage SS Disability & Retirement Benefits

    Advisors with clients who receive disability benefits can carve out a profitable niche by helping them integrate this income into a financial plan.
  7. Retirement

    Social Security Disability Benefits vs. Retirement Benefits

    Here's how to know if you should file for Social Security retirement vs. disability benefits.
  8. Taxes

    The New Tax-Free Savings Accounts For the Disabled

    Due to the Achieving a Better Life Experience (ABLE) Act, many people with disabilities will have an easier time financing their lives, starting in 2016.
  9. Financial Advisor

    Top 3 Financial Steps to Take on Disability

    Going on disability can be a stressful time financially. Here are 3 steps to take on disability to help protect against significant financial blowback.
Frequently Asked Questions
  1. I'm about to retire. If I pay off my mortgage with after-tax money I have saved, I can save 6.5%. Should I do this?

    Only you and your financial advisor, family, accountant, etc. can answer the "should I?" question because there are many ...
  2. My wife and I both converted our Traditional IRAs to Roth IRAs over a decade ago and have invested the maximum allowed each year since. We're buying our first home soon. Do we both qualify for one-time, tax-free, $10,000 distributions?

    You and your spouse each qualify for a penalty-free distribution of up to $10,000 for the purchase, acquisition or construction ...
  3. Is a Thrift Savings Plan (TSP) a qualified retirement plan?

    Take advantage of the government's retirement plan for employees with the Thrift Savings Plan. As with a 401(k), contributions ...
  4. Who manages the assets in a Roth 401(k) account?

    Learn how to personally manage the assets in your Roth 401(k) plan and determine the best options available to help meet ...
Trading Center