The Ohio Bureau of Workers' Compensation (BWC) fund provides coverage for workplace injuries to two-thirds of its state's workforce and has $22 billion in funds to back it up. In April 2005 this then little-known organization reported investment returns that seemingly made it a star of the financial world - 16.5% per year in a decade when the S&P 500 had earned only 10.6% annually.

Later that year, however, those returns came under suspicion when the BWC burst into the headlines as the focus of a massive investment fraud. It involved unconventional investments

Pay To Play: A Class Action Connection?

Draining The Public-Pension Swamp

Gilt-Edged Pensions

that had been managed by people closely connected to financial backers of the Ohio Republican Party. Have you ever heard of a state investment fund investing in gold coins or Beanie Babies? This one did.

Upon further review, it turned out that the BWC's reported investment returns were fictitious. "We are unable to establish any basis whatsoever for the 16.5% figure," an outside performance review concluded. The fund had actually earned 7.3% annually - less than half of what it had previously claimed. (Pension plans certainly have their drawbacks. Read about the love-hate relationship employees have to these vehicles in Pension Plans: Pain Or Pleasure?)
In other words, the largest state-operated workers comp fund in the country had massively misrepresented its performance. Subsequent revelations showed that sloppy mathematical calculations weren't the problem. There had been a deliberate, concerted effort involving BWC's investment staff and vendors to inflate the performance.

If a Securities and Exchange Commission-registered money manager had committed similar fraud, it would have been shut down. But governmental investment funds, including hundreds of public pension plans, are generally not subject to SEC regulation. This brings into question not only their overall performance claims but also those of the outside managers they hire. Given that such outsiders are often paid based on the returns they report, and thus have a huge incentive to cook the books, I suspect that many of the numbers issued by public pension funds are wrong. What's more, in my experience, many public funds fail to submit their reported rates of return to the sorts of audits and verification money managers in the private sector regard as mandatory. It's just too politically fraught. I call this politicization of the investment process.

For a look at just how averse outsiders can be to reporting bad numbers, see the Alaska Retirement Management Board. In 2007 the state agency filed suit against Mercer, a unit of MMC). Mercer, the agency contends, made multiple errors as the state's actuarial consultant when it estimated the amounts that two of the state's retirement plans needed to set aside for health care and pension benefits. The agency is seeking damages of $2.8 billion. Now it seems the financial health of these systems is far different from what investors were told, perhaps dire. Liabilities were grossly understated. Again, if an SEC-registered money manager had committed these errors, they'd be held accountable.

Further evidence of shenanigans is coming to light at two of the nation's largest public pension funds - the New York State Common Retirement Fund and the California Public Employees' Retirement Fund (Calpers). In New York, Attorney General Andrew Cuomo has a criminal investigation underway into illegal bribes involving middlemen who were paid for attracting business to private money managers.

In California, disclosures are uncovering evidence that money has been doled out for years to politically favored investment firms. It's not much of a stretch to assume firms that would bribe public officials to gain business might have a cavalier attitude toward reporting the investment returns on which their pay is often based.

Wednesday Calpers disclosed massive underperformance, which amounts to approximately $20 billion. Remarkably this is precisely the California budget deficit the "Governator" is looking for Washington to help with. Not surprising, real estate investments, which have been the subject of pay-to-play investigations, have plunged 47.5% - more than triple the loss in the relevant index. Kick-backs do result in substantial, quantifiable harm.

In conclusion, the investment-performance-related information public funds disseminate is rarely reliable and highly susceptible to manipulation for political and financial reasons. The result is that stakeholders are misled regarding the performance of the assets and liabilities of these systems. There is no effective regulatory scheme to attack these abuses since these funds are, at best, subject only to patchworks of state regulation and often to no regulation addressing specific investment practices.

When trillions of dollars in public fund assets are invested in schemes that are unreliably accounted for, that tainted performance information harms all marketplace participants who rely upon the hyped returns. Taxpayers and other stakeholders who are liable for filling in any holes that later arise in these funds are in for more nasty surprises.

Related Articles
  1. Savings

    What Your Credit Score Means for Your Love Life

    Wondering if your significant other wants to commit and is reliable? The Fed might have the answer.
  2. Your Clients

    Tips for Making Your Nest Egg Last Longer

    If you’re trying to figure out how to make your hard-earned nest egg last, there’s one piece of advice that stands above the rest.
  3. Investing

    3 Healthy Financial Habits for 2016

    ”Winning” investors don't just set it and forget it. They consistently take steps to adapt their investment plan in the face of changing markets.
  4. Investing

    How to Ballast a Portfolio with Bonds

    If January and early February performance is any guide, there’s a new normal in financial markets today: Heightened volatility.
  5. Retirement

    Early Out: A Realistic Plan to Retire Younger

    If you want to retire ahead of schedule, it'll take some extra planning.
  6. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Which Fund Share Class is Best for Retirement?

    Mutual funds are a popular investment for retirement. Here's how to choose the best share class when investing in them.
  7. Retirement

    6 Robo-Advisors That Require Little to Start

    There are many well-regarded robo-advisor options that come with minimum investment amounts. Here are snapshots of a handful of them.
  8. Retirement

    Smart Ways to Tap Your Retirement Portfolio

    A rundown of strategies, from what to liquidate first to how much to withdraw, along with their tax consquences.
  9. Your Clients

    How to Construct an Annual Review for Clients

    One of the best things that advisors can provide to clients is an annual review of their financial situation. Here are some guidelines.
  10. Retirement

    Roth IRAs Tutorial

    This comprehensive guide goes through what a Roth IRA is and how to set one up, contribute to it and withdraw from it.
RELATED FAQS
  1. Am I losing the right to collect spousal Social Security benefits before I collect ...

    The short answer is yes, if you haven't reached age 62 by December 31, 2015. The Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 disrupted ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Where else can I save for retirement after I max out my Roth IRA?

    With uncertainty about the sustainability of Social Security benefits for future retirees, a lot of responsibility for saving ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. When can catch-up contributions start?

    Most qualified retirement plans such as 401(k), 403(b) and SIMPLE 401(k) plans, as well as individual retirement accounts ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Are 401(k) contributions tax deductible?

    All contributions to qualified retirement plans such as 401(k)s reduce taxable income, which lowers the total taxes owed. ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. Are 401(k) rollovers taxable?

    401(k) rollovers are generally not taxable as long as the money goes into another qualifying plan, an individual retirement ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. Are catch-up contributions included in the 415 limit?

    Unlike regular employee deferrals, catch-up contributions are not included in the 415 limit. While there is an annual limit ... Read Full Answer >>
Trading Center