It's an early winter ritual, right up there with changing to snow tires and cursing your parents for not choosing somewhere warmer to live. The endless college football debate: why does the sport have such an illogical and confusing postseason? Why not a playoff? Like most real-world scenarios that seem to make little sense on the surface, the explanation has lots to do with money. (For related reading, see How Much Revenue Do College Sports Produce?)

TUTORIAL: Personal Income Tax Guide

Major college football - formally known as National Collegiate Athletic Association Division I, Football Bowl Subdivision - is played by 120 schools across the United States. The schools range from the legendary (Notre Dame, Michigan) to the perpetually competitive (Oklahoma, Boise State) to the also-ran (Florida Atlantic, Nevada-Las Vegas), with corresponding levels of prestige. The more prestigious the school, the greater the capacity for its football team to generate revenue. At the end of each season, the consensus two best teams of the 120 meet in the Allstate Bowl Championship Series championship game and enjoy an $18 million payday. As for the remaining 118, just about any team with a winning record and a booster community will collect a check for playing in a postseason bowl game that will have no bearing on the championship. That check can easily turn a school's red season into a black one.

Decades ago, a handful of elite teams would close out their seasons by meeting in bowl games at warm-weather, neutral, permanent sites. First there were four bowls – the Rose, Orange, Sugar and Cotton. Then came the Sun. Then the Fiesta. Today there are 35, each with a corporate sponsor, and the high-school letterman who dreams of one day playing in the Meineke Car Care Bowl of Texas or the San Diego County Credit Union Poinsettia Bowl is not being honest with himself.

Each bowl pays its combatants a flat fee, which derives from the substantial ticket handle and TV ad revenue that the bowl's organizers hope to generate. The Rose Bowl, played in its mammoth 92,542-capacity namesake since the First World War, promises its participants $17 million. The other longstanding bowls pay similar amounts, while the minor bowls pay anywhere from $500,000 to $4.25 million.

Best of the Best
Logic would dictate that like almost every other sport in existence, major college football choose its champion by qualifying the best available teams, then having them play each other until one remains standing. Under such a system, there wouldn't be any point to, nor place for, a Valero Alamo Bowl between 12th-ranked Baylor and unranked Washington. With so many schools, and the sport's brutal nature demanding that players rest for a week or so after each game, it'd be cumbersome to create a playoff system. Cumbersome, but possible. College football's second tier (officially styled "NCAA Division I, Football Championship Subdivision") has such a system, whittling its 125 member schools into a single-elimination field of 20 and, ultimately, one undisputed champion.

Few people pay to watch FCS football, as contrasted with FBS football, where many of the elite schools vastly outdraw their NFL counterparts. Notre Dame receives around $9 million annually just for having its home games televised nationally, while Brigham Young receives between $1 million and $2 million per game for a similar TV package. Meanwhile, newly crowned FCS champion North Dakota State doesn't even televise all of its games. (For additional reading, see Top 4 TV Sports Deals Of 2011.)

Thirty-five bowls means that 70 of 120 teams can each claim they had a successful season, from Alabama all the way down to Utah State. A playoff system would make it harder for any program to justify a fair-to-mediocre season to potential recruits. "2011 Beef 'O' Brady's Bowl champions" sounds more impressive, however faintly, than either "eliminated in the second round of the playoffs" or "didn't come close to qualifying."

Current Configuration
Under the current configuration, in which the BCS championship game participants split $18 million, corporate sponsors and TV networks salivate at the prospect of being part of the festivities. Sponsors would be less inclined to offer generous amounts for generic playoff games devoid of pageantry. "The Outback Steakhouse Northeast Region Semifinal" doesn't have the same ring to it.

For many schools, a major bowl payout can be the biggest financial windfall of the year. Few incentives are as powerful as a check with six or seven zeroes on it, especially when the school collecting it doesn't even have to go through the logistical chore of hosting the game itself. Even if the school has to share the money with other teams in its conference, playing in a major bowl is still more than worthwhile.

What about the minor bowls, which typically attract either smaller schools having good seasons or notable schools having disappointing ones? Well, there's a reason those games are largely played in the Sun Belt and not the Upper Midwest. Bowl administrators can reward school executives with free trips. The school executives can bring the boosters and hangers-on along. The games might barely break even for the participating schools' athletic departments, but college football's higher-ups aren't the first people to have discovered the benefits of enjoying the revenue for themselves while spreading the expenses out among other parties.

The Bottom Line
A major college playoff would make competitive sense, but even in a sport where everyone gets paid except the people performing the labor, a playoff system wouldn't necessarily make financial sense. At least not with regard to the decision-makers' own interests. The current setup might seem capricious and arbitrary, but it isn't. Nor will it be changing anytime soon. (For related reading, see Recession-Proof Sports Leagues.)

Related Articles
  1. Credit & Loans

    What SoFi's Super Bowl Ad Means for Your Next Loan

    Non-bank lender SoFi will air its first TV ad during Super Bowl 50. Here's how it's challenging big banks by providing an alternative approach to loans.
  2. Investing News

    Super Savings for Your Super Bowl Party? Bet on It

    Prices for wings, avocados and TVs are all coming down, which will make your Super Bowl 50 festivities less costly.
  3. Investing News

    Are Super Bowl Ads Worth Their High Cost?

    Are Super Bowl ads worth the investment? A look at the cost and how they're received.
  4. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    The Top 4 Entertainment ETFs for 2016 (PEJ, XLY)

    Learn more about the entertainment sector, the companies that are included and the four ETFs that provide investors with exposure to this industry.
  5. Markets

    Top Investment Banks in the Sports Industry

    Find out why the top investment banks in the sports industry tend to be smaller niche players and are prepared to battle the Wall Street giants for business.
  6. Retirement

    How Pro Athletes Can Choose the Right Advisor

    When it comes to finances, professional athletes can be vulnerable. Here's what they need to look for in a financial advisor.
  7. Investing

    How FanDuel and DraftKings Work

    DraftKings and FanDuel lead the daily fantasy sports industry, supported primarily by advertising, entry fees, media companies and sports leagues.
  8. Personal Wealth & Private Banking

    Five of the Best Yacht Clubs in Seattle

    Seattle doesn’t have a year-round sailing environment, but there are lots of opportunities for boating enthusiasts, from modestly priced to high-end clubs.
  9. Personal Wealth & Private Banking

    Four of Miami's Best Yacht Clubs

    Choices abound in Miami for boating enthusiasts, from high-end, high-priced yachting clubs to no-frill groups that still offer races, cruises and more.
  10. Investing News

    Learn from These Big CEO Blunders

    A ceo can seem to have it all: power, influence and gravitas. But it can all erode — along with a company’s share price — in the wake of a scandal.
RELATED FAQS
  1. Why is Manchester United (MANU) carrying so much debt?

    The takeover of Manchester United by the Glazer family beginning in 2005 saddled the historic club with substantial amounts ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What are Manchester United's (MANU) largest revenue sources?

    Manchester United is one of the most popular U.K. soccer teams. Its principal stadium is Old Trafford, located in the heart ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Does Manchester United (MANU) own Old Trafford stadium?

    Old Trafford Stadium was built for and is currently still owned by Manchester United Football Club (Man Utd.). This means ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What's the biggest sports endorsement deal ever signed?

    According to Forbes, basketball player Derrick Rose holds the largest endorsement deal as of 2014; the deal is for more than ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What are the biggest stadium naming rights deals of all time?

    The top three stadium naming rights deals of all time were all for stadiums hosting New York City teams. The largest was ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is the difference between a mutual fund and money market fund?

    The Herfindahl-Hirschman index can be used to determine competitive balance in sports. Competitive balance is desired in ... Read Full Answer >>
Hot Definitions
  1. Flight To Quality

    The action of investors moving their capital away from riskier investments to the safest possible investment vehicles. This ...
  2. Discouraged Worker

    A person who is eligible for employment and is able to work, but is currently unemployed and has not attempted to find employment ...
  3. Ponzimonium

    After Bernard Madoff's $65 billion Ponzi scheme was revealed, many new (smaller-scale) Ponzi schemers became exposed. Ponzimonium ...
  4. Quarterly Earnings Report

    A quarterly filing made by public companies to report their performance. Included in earnings reports are items such as net ...
  5. Dark Pool Liquidity

    The trading volume created by institutional orders that are unavailable to the public. The bulk of dark pool liquidity is ...
Trading Center