It's not as if you have extra money to give away. You have debt to pay off, kids who will go to college and retirement accounts that need funding. You do not have money lying around to throw away. When you give to a charity, you need to know that the money you really can't afford to give up is ultimately making it to somebody who really needs it. This is not being unreasonable. Like others recently surveyed, you might agree with up to 23 cents of every dollar you donate going to administrative costs, but anything above that is a non-starter. This is when your inner conspiracy theorist kicks in. You wonder: "How is my money being used, anyway?"

You go online only to find out that the money you could have put into your child's college fund helps pay the CEO far more money than you make in a year. You are outraged! However, should you be? Some experts caution against judging a charity by its numbers alone.

The Numbers Might Be a Lie
Administrative costs expressed as a percentage of the fair market value of donated items can be terribly (sometimes unintentionally) misleading. A story that appeared on The Huffington Post provides a great example of how these figures can be deceptive. The Super Bowl has a winning and losing team, but shirts, hats, and other paraphernalia are made ahead of time for both teams of potential Super Bowl Champions. Companies and organizations donate the "We won the Super Bowl!" swag for the losing team to charities that ship it overseas.

In this case, World Vision reported paying $1.82 per shirt in administrative costs to get the shirts into the hands of those in developing nations that needed clothing. The NFL valued the shirts at $20 each. A little division shows that the administrative costs come in at 8.3%, according the report. However, the fair market value of these shirts is supposed to be based on what somebody would pay for it.

Would you pay $20 for a shirt that says the team that actually lost the Super Bowl, won it? If sold in the U.S., the shirt would likely be in a bargain bin for considerably less than $20. So maybe the fair market value is actually $5? If that's the case, the administrative costs are actually 26%. Did World Vision have administrative costs of 8.3% or 26%? If you choose to donate based solely on reported administrative costs, be aware that those numbers can vary widely.

Think Like a Business
Charities know that there are well-meaning websites that try to protect people from charities that are doing little good for the cause they claim to support. They know that the headline number is the administrative costs and most people will not dig into the charity to see if higher administrative costs are justified. According to a 2001 survey from the Better Business Bureau, 79% of participants said they want to know what percentage of their money went to the cause. For that reason, many charities try to run their operations spending as little on administration costs as possible.

But is that really what you want from a charity? Do you go to the cheapest doctor or an unscrupulous lawyer? Do you expect that the cheapest restaurant will have higher-quality food than the more expensive one down the road? This, according to some experts, is the problem with judging a charity solely by its administrative costs.

A blog featured on The Harvard Business Review points out that charities that try to spend less on administrative expenses tend to have inferior programs. Charities are not immune to the same forces that challenge for-profit businesses. Spending more to get a more talented and experienced charity CEO as well as staff members with better skills will likely produce more donations and make a larger scale difference than trying to run leaner, argues the report. Hiring better people makes for better results.

Volunteers are well meaning but may lack the expertise to be truly effective. A article went so far as to say that when people throw their money behind charities solely based on low administrative costs, they are encouraging that charity to cut corners.

The Bottom Line
You should not ignore administrative costs. There are certainly bad charities that do not deserve your time or money. But looking solely at one metric, one that is calculated using subject measures, is not the way to evaluate a charity. If you don't know who or what to believe, keep your money local. Donate directly to families or causes that you know are truly in need. Donate with food, clothes or even your time. Maybe a divorced mother desperately needs her home or car repaired. You do not have to give to charitable organizations in order to be charitable. It is your money; donate it in a way that makes you feel empowered.

Related Articles
  1. Economics

    Explaining Endowment Funds

    An endowment fund is money set aside to earn revenue to fund some type of charitable activity.
  2. Taxes

    5 Warning Signs a Charity Is a Scam

    Giving to charities and helping those in need is admirable. Here's how to ensure your good intentions and donations aren't siphoned off by scammers.
  3. Personal Finance

    Top Tips for Helping Clients Sustain Wealth

    High-net-worth individuals face a number of potential challenges when passing wealth down, but it is possible to build generational wealth.
  4. Taxes

    Tips on Charitable Contributions: Limits and Taxes

    An overview of the limits and tax deductions of charitable donations.
  5. Personal Finance

    Free Community College: How Would It Work?

    Semi-timely article on how a free community would work on the proposal provided by Obama not to charge on free community colleges
  6. Investing What It Is and How It Works

    Basic Internet access remains out of reach for many in developing nations. aims to bring basic Internet access to these countries.
  7. Taxes

    Top Fund-Raising Strategies For Nonprofits

    Top fund-raising strategies for nonprofit organizations
  8. Taxes

    The Top Nonprofit Organizations

    Did you know basketball and volleyball were invented by instructors at a charity?
  9. Personal Finance

    How To Start Your Own Private Foundation

    Private foundations can be time consuming and expensive to set up and operate.
  10. Home & Auto

    Using Life Insurance To Make Charitable Donations

    Your life insurance policy can be a great tool for charitable giving. Find out how.
  1. Endowment

    A financial asset donation made to a non-profit group or institution ...
  2. Directors And Officers Liability ...

    Directors and officers liability insurance covers you if you're ...
  3. National Motor Freight Traffic ...

    A nonprofit organization representing interstate, intrastate, ...
  4. Guarantee Company

    A form of corporation designed to protect members from liability, ...
  5. Economist Intelligence Unit - EIU

    An organization that provides forecasting and advisory services ...
  6. Investment Counsel Association ...

    A non-profit organization whose members work in the investment ...
  1. How does revenue recognition differ between profit and non-profit companies?

    Under the generally accepted accounting principles, or GAAP, for-profit companies recognize revenue as it is earned through ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What kind of philanthropy did Nathan Rothschild do?

    Nathan Rothschild contributed to many areas of philanthropy in the Jewish community. His family later expanded these charitable ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What's the largest charitable donation Warren Buffett ever made?

    The most significant charitable donation Warren Buffett ever made is the $37 billion pledge to the Bill and Melinda Gates ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Can I donate stock to charity?

    Giving stock, instead of cash, as a donation can greatly benefit both parties. You will find that most charities, hospitals, ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. Does the federal government fund any NGOs? Which ones?

    A non-governmental organization (NGO) is a non-profit, citizen-based group that functions independently of government. NGOs ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. How do NGOs get funding?

    A non-governmental organization (NGO) is a non-profit, citizen-based group that functions independently of government. NGOs ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center

You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!