Once a month, I meet up with some smart people in my neighborhood to drink coffee and try to stave off mental decline by talking about hard financial topics: macroeconomics, taxation and sometimes even something useful, like investing. It's like Facebook chat, only you can smell the other participants.
At our last meeting, the topic was active vs. passive investing. Before we could get into that debate, however, we had to define our terms. I was arguing the passive investing side, which meant I had to come up with a definition of passive investing. This proved to be a lot trickier than I thought, and more fun.
I'm not going to get into the passive vs. active debate in this column. I just want to see if I can figure out what we're talking about before I wade into that debate in the near future.
"What is passive investing?" may seem like an arcane question that nobody but latte-fueled intellectuals should care about. On the contrary, pal: if you're saving money for the future, deciding whether to take an active or passive approach is among the most important decisions you'll make.
Active investing, as I define it, means trying to beat the market over a particular time period using one or both of the following strategies:
Security selection. This is a fancy term for buying the right stocks (or bonds, or funds, or any other asset) and avoiding the wrong ones. It means having the foresight to buy Apple in the pre-iPod days and not to buy Netflix on the day after its IPO.
Market timing. Markets gyrate. If you can correctly predict those gyrations ahead of time, you can make a lot of money - or avoid losing it.
Passive investing means doing neither of those things. It means diversifying as much as possible by buying broad market index funds. It means owning the next Apple, but also the next Groupon. And it means not trying to time the market. That means staying in when stocks take a dive five days - or months, or years - in a row.
Passive investing also means making portfolio decisions based on personal circumstances, not on headlines or research.
With that definition in mind, let's cook up a couple of hypothetical investors and see who's passive and who's active. (Aren't these terms a little judgmental, by the way? That's why MintLife columnist Dan Solin likes to refer to passive investing as "smart investing.") This is my column, so I get to be the judge and jury. We'll start out easy.
Alice owns a bunch of individual stocks and bonds and trades them regularly.
Bob owns no individual stocks or bonds, only low-cost ETFs, but he trades them regularly in response to perceived market trends.
Charlie buys mutual funds, holds them and never trades. However, his mutual funds are actively managed, so the fund manager may be trading stocks within Charlie's funds.
Donna buys diversified index funds or ETFs, holds them and never trades.
Rick Ferri, in his book "The Power of Passive Investing," puts these four investors into a handy chart, which I'm going to simplify and reproduce here.
|Uses actively managed funds or individual stocks||Uses index funds or ETFs|
As you can see, only Donna meets Ferri's (and my) definition of passive investing.
The Hard Cases
Now, let's ask some tougher questions.
Emily owns only index funds and ETFs, but she has decided on a 50% stock/50% bond portfolio.
Verdict: Not enough information.
If Emily has chosen a 50/50 portfolio because it's in line with her risk tolerance, she's passive. If she believes this portfolio looks like a winner for the moment, but intends to change it later when stocks look like a better bet, she's active.
Frank owns only index funds and ETFs in a 50/50 stock/bond portfolio, but he trades once a year or more to bring his portfolio back in line with its original allocation. That is, if bonds go up and stocks go down, he sells off some bonds to buy more stocks until he's back to 50/50. This is called rebalancing.
Rebalancing is about keeping your portfolio risk under control; it's not about trying to time the market.
Gene used to have a portfolio of 75% stocks/25% bonds. Recently he received an inheritance. He checked his retirement savings calculator and found that with the new infusion of cash, he could take less stock market risk and still have an excellent chance of reaching his savings goal, so he switched his allocation to 50/50.
Gene is changing his portfolio based on a change in his circumstances, not anything to do with market trends.
Hailey is a buy/hold/rebalance type like Frank. A couple of years ago, however, during the financial crisis, she noticed that prices on certain bonds had plummeted. She took the opportunity to buy some highly-rated bonds at bargain prices and permanently reduced her allocation to stocks.
I'm not sure. It smells like market timing, but is it?
Get Your Team Alice T-Shirts Here
Alice, our pure active investor, works hard at investing. She is up on the latest IPOs, valuations, interest rates and market trends. She has a whole folder of investing apps on her phone.
Meanwhile, Frank, our passive buy/hold/rebalance guy, doesn't know anything about any of that stuff, and he spends a few minutes a year managing his portfolio.
You can probably guess whose team I'm on, but let's talk about you: are you an Alice or a Frank, or someone else from our cast of characters? And why?
Investing BasicsBuying below the margin of safety minimizes the risk to the investor.
Mutual Funds & ETFsObtain information about an ETF offerings that provides leveraged exposure to the biotechnology industry, the ProShares UltraPro Nasdaq Biotech Fund.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn about the iShares MSCI Europe Financials fund, which invests in numerous European financial industries, such as banks, insurance and real estate.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn about the SPDR S&P Insurance exchange-traded fund, which follows the S&P Insurance Select Industry Index by investing in equities of U.S. insurers.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn about the SPDR S&P Emerging Markets Small Cap exchange-traded fund, which invests in small-cap firms traded at the emerging equity markets.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn about the physical platinum ETF. Platinum embarked on a bull market from 2001 to 2011, climbing to record prices along with other precious metals.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn about the iShares MSCI Turkey exchange-traded fund, which invests in a wide variety of companies' equities traded on Turkish exchanges.
Mutual Funds & ETFsFind out about the PowerShares S&P 500 Downside Hedged ETF, and learn detailed information about characteristics, suitability and recommendations of it.
Mutual Funds & ETFsFind out about the Guggenheim Enhanced Short Duration ETF, and learn detailed information about this fund that focuses on fixed-income securities.
Mutual Funds & ETFsLearn about the iShares U.S. Oil & Gas Exploration & Production ETF, which provides an efficient way to invest in the exploration and production sector.
The value of an asset less the value of all liabilities on that ...
A security that tracks an index, a commodity or a basket of assets ...
A securities license entitling the holder to register as a limited ...
Earnings an individual derives from a rental property, limited ...
The Compound Annual Growth Rate (CAGR) is the mean annual growth ...
A performance measure used to evaluate the efficiency of an investment ...
If an investment fund has a high turnover ratio, it indicates it replaces most or all of its holdings over a one-year period. ... Read Full Answer >>
The rise of index trading may increase the overall vulnerability of the stock market due to increased correlations between ... Read Full Answer >>
Asset management utilizes two main investment strategies that can be used to generate returns: active asset management and ... Read Full Answer >>
The percentage of a diversified investment portfolio that should consist of large-cap stocks depends on an individual investor's ... Read Full Answer >>
Wash trading, the intentional practice of manipulating a stock's activity level to deceive other investors, is not a legal ... Read Full Answer >>
An investor should include an allocation to the telecommunications sector in his portfolio, because telecom offers an investor ... Read Full Answer >>