Not all bad news is created equal. Patient and savvy long-term investors can leverage short-term setbacks into long-term winnings by realizing that the most likely outcome of a so-called disaster is not nearly as bad as the market assumes. However, some kinds of bad news are so toxic that prudent investors simply stay away entirely. How then should investors separate the "bad news in wolf's clothing" from the real bad news? Here are five key factors that may indicate when bad PR is too serious to ignore.

IN PICTURES: 8 Signs Of A Doomed Stock

  1. When the Company Causes Death
    When a company's missteps result in actual deaths, there is a virtually inevitable spiral of events - none of which are positive. Not only will the news likely be full of warnings about the dangerous product/service, but follow-up stories detailing the aftermath and fallout will keep the mistake (and its perpetrators) in people's consciousness. Afterwards, there are expensive lawsuits and settlements, recovery and mitigation efforts, and press campaigns designed to make consumers forget about the incident.
    Indevus Pharmaceuticals (known at the time as Interneuron) thought it had a blockbuster with the weight-loss drug Redux - that was until severe side-effects led to numerous product liability suits and the FDA ordered withdrawal from the market. All told, Wyeth, which licensed the drug from Indevus, paid out more than $20 billion in legal settlements to those who took Redux or Pondimin (another Wyeth weight loss drug), while revenue of the two drugs topped out at about $300 million in 1996.

    In comparison, Toyota (NYSE:TM) is almost certainly going to survive its fatal accelerator debacle. Although Reuters reported that Safety Research and Strategies, a Massachusetts-based consultancy, had counted more than 2,000 incidents of apparent unintended acceleration in Toyota vehicles since 1999, including 815 crashes and 19 deaths as of February 2010, the recall itself is likely to cost Toyota about $2 billion (versus a market capitalization of over $110 billion). Analysts expect that sales will rebound by 2012. (Learn more in Recall Recoil: Will Toyota Recover?)

    What separates the survivors from the doomed? In most cases, it is a question of size - if a company is big enough, or the misstep is small enough, it can ultimately wait for consumers to forgive and forget.

  2. When the CEO Bails
    While many decry the "key man fallacy" and claim that most companies could continue on just fine without their current high-priced CEOs, clearly that is not always the case. Take Steve Jobs for example. The founder and CEO of Apple (Nasdaq:AAPL) is often heralded as a key component of the company's success. Although Apple's stock did nearly triple while Steve Jobs was away from his post between 1985 and 1996, that was a robust time for the market and Apple's less-than-200% appreciation trailed the 300% gain in the S&P 500 and the roughly 350% gain in the Nasdaq.
    However, many investors and industry experts attribute much of Apple's early and recent success to its charismatic and hard-driving CEO. (What can you learn from him? Find out in Hype It Like Steve Jobs.)

    In some cases, these leaders truly are visionaries with unique perspectives on product design and/or marketing. In other cases, they may simply have an unusual grasp on corporate culture. Whatever the case, be wary when successful, long-tenured CEOs pack up their office, particularly when they also happen to be the company's founder.

  3. When Valuable Assets Are Lost
    If a company loses essential operating assets, recovery can be a very difficult process. For example, since Venezuelan President Hugo Chavez took power in 2008, his socialist government has nationalized many companies and taken possession of their assets. According to a July 2 Reuters report, companies in the energy, mining, cement and power sectors are involved in arbitration cases against Venezuela's state-run oil company PDVSA. The companies are seeking compensation for assets that were nationalized, with claims running into the billions of dollars.
    Likewise, mining and energy companies often face shady dealings with governments in the developing world. Canadian mining company First Quantum (OTCBB:FQVLF), for instance, wrangled with the Democratic Republic of the Congo for years until it finally suspended its operations in that country in August when the government said it had taken over the mine's titles, according to the Canadian Press.

    Although the company has stated that the loss of income from the mine won't affect projects in other countries, the company invested more than $200 million in the mine, and several Canadian analysts felt it would impact earnings estimates in 2010 and 2011.

  4. When New Laws Target the Company
    If the government decides your company has got to go, it is a good idea to get out of the way. For example, telemarketing still exists, but it is only a shadow of what it was before the "Do Not Call" law of 2003. Likewise, America's failed experiment in prohibition in the early 20th century may not have killed the likes of Anheuser-Busch, now part of Inbev (NYSE:BUD), or Coors, now part of Molson Coors (NYSE:TAP), but many brewers did go bankrupt. (Learn more in Beer Nation.)
    There is certainly money to be made in some kinds of "sin stocks" or "nuisance industries", but investors in industries like payday lending should be careful - once the government decides your industry is a threat to the public good, there is rarely a happy ending to the story.

  5. When a Product Is Universally Panned
    If customers really don't like your product, you are in trouble. The Sharper Image had muddled along for years by selling quirky gadgets, but a very public row with Consumer Reports over an air purifier that began in 2002 seemed to mark the beginning of the end. When Consumer Reports reviewed a number of air purifiers and gave the Ionic Breeze Quadra model produced by The Sharper Image a failing grade for air purification. The Sharper Image unsuccessfully sued Consumer Reports for defaming its product, and when Consumer Reports reviewed The Sharper Image's products again in 2004, it stated that the purifiers could be dangerous to consumers' health because they produced trace levels of ozone.
    The Sharper Image ultimately went into bankruptcy in 2008 as a result of declining same-store sales which is believed to have been aggravated by the bad publicity the company's received over its air purifiers.

    On the other hand, Toshiba's (OTCBB:TOSBF) HD-DVD product, a now-defunct disc format for high-definition video, cost the company billions in unrecoverable R&D and shutdown expenses, to say nothing of losing the chance at leadership in the high-definition DVD market. Unfortunately, the format lost out to Sony's Blu-ray technology. (Find out more in 6 Reasons Why Products Fail.)

    Despite this, Toshiba still stands as a major consumer electronics company. This is partly because large companies like Toshiba can afford to lose sales and fix the damage. For a smaller company with a limited number of products, the risk is high and investors need to be ever-vigilant to signs of trouble.

The Bottom Line
There are plenty of situations where investors can profit by taking a long-term view of short-term bad news. An overreaction to an earnings miss or a product launch delay can take much more out of a stock than it takes out of a company's real operating value. In other cases, investors would do well to steer clear of bad news. After all, with thousands of stocks to choose from, there is no point in sticking with a company that has a fatal flaw.

Catch up on your financial news; read Water Cooler Finance: The Ups And Downs Of A Double-Dip Recession.

Related Articles
  1. Professionals

    8 Justifications For Sky-high CEO Salaries

    Why are CEO salaries so astronomically high? There may be more to the story than you think.
  2. Stock Analysis

    Drugmaker Extraordinaire: How Eli Lilly Grows

    Drugs mean big profits in America. Here's how the country's oldest pharmaceutical firm keeps its toehold in the market.
  3. Professionals

    Are Stock Buybacks Always Good for Shareholders?

    Stock buyback programs aren't always done with the interests of shareholders in mind. It's important to try to understand the motivation behind such moves.
  4. Economics

    Understanding Management by Objectives

    Management by objectives is a process in which a manager and an employee agree on specific performance goals and then develop a plan to reach those goals.
  5. Entrepreneurship

    Why Companies Need Risk Management

    Implementing risk management strategies can save an entire organization from failure. Is yours up to snuff?
  6. Investing

    Has Nepotism Ever Worked?

    It may very well be that hiring a relative is the right course of action for you. But before you do, carefully consider how hiring family could hurt your business.
  7. Investing

    What Can A Conference Call Tell About Trends?

    Messages in a company conference call can be easily misconstrued. But there is a way to cut through the talking points to get to the real substance.
  8. Investing

    Why These Industries Are Prone To Corruption

    Corruption is like life in that it exists pretty much everywhere the conditions are favorable.
  9. Economics

    Costco's Future Is Abroad

    Costco is a hot topic and stock market darling. Despite its slight loss since the beginning of the year, the stock is still up 15% year over year. What makes Costco so appealing to investors?
  10. Fundamental Analysis

    Zappos.com & Holacracy, Will It Work?

    Zappos amounts to the most expansive corporate implementation of Holacracy. Why did they do it?
RELATED TERMS
  1. Corporate Culture

    The beliefs and behaviors that determine how a company's employees ...
  2. Organizational Behavior - OB

    Organizational Behavior (OB) is the study of the way people interact ...
  3. Holacracy

    A holacracy is a system of governance where members of a team ...
  4. Cash Bonus

    A lump sum of money awarded to an employee, either occasionally ...
  5. Strategic Management

    The management of an organization’s resources in order to achieve ...
  6. Performance Management

    The management of employees, departments, and organizations to ...
RELATED FAQS
  1. How do you conduct effective social responsibility training?

    One way to provide employees with effective social responsibility training is to base training sessions on resources offered ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Why is social responsibility important to a business?

    Social responsibility is important to a business because it demonstrates to both consumers and the media that the company ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. How important are business ethics in running a profitable business?

    A number of factors play a part in making a business profitable, including expert management teams, dedicated and productive ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What advice does Howard Schultz offer would-be business moguls?

    Starbucks CEO, billionaire and former sports tycoon Howard Schultz has several pieces of advice for would-be moguls and, ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. How does brand image and marketing affect market share?

    A company's marketing efforts have a direct impact on sales and market share, but they are not the only factors that influence ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is Tim Cook's managerial style?

    Tim Cook's managerial style could be broadly defined as democratic. Rather than standing in complete contrast to former Apple ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center
×

You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!