Lying somewhere between meme and cliché is the idea that when the going gets tough, the smart buy gold. Gold has had a special hold on the minds of many investors for centuries, if not millennia, offering the promise of being the one asset that will never go to zero, and the one medium of exchange that other people will always accept in trade. While these notions are basically true, investors would do well to consider just how much disaster they can really hedge by buying gold.
TUTORIAL: Commodities: Gold

Forget Inflation
Whenever it is time to debate the merits of gold, it is only a matter of time before someone mentions the iffy correlation between gold and inflation. The history of gold versus inflation looks a lot like a bungee cord - years and years go by and nothing seems to be happening, until there's a point of release and the price of gold rockets up.

For instance, it took 28 years for the prior peak price in gold to be re-attained. Gold spent most of the '80s and '90s declining even though inflation was technically continuing to increase. Likewise, there is now the growing belief that gold's current price is already pricing in decades of inflation to come (suggesting that the price of gold would be flat or down).

To be fair, this argument has a few flaws. First, the CPI is the most common inflation proxy used in comparison to gold and it has some significant flaws. Also, it is not constructed to be a forward-looking indicator. Second, the end of the gold standard 1971 is an important detail - it reduces the amount of truly comparable data available and makes post-1971 conclusions somewhat risky as there have been really just two major economic panics in that time. (For related reading, see Gold: The Other Currency.)

How Valuable Is It in a Real Disaster?
Take the fears of the most extreme gold bugs all the way to "10" and the virtues of gold do not really hold up very well. First of all, one of the reasons to buy gold is that it has "real value" in a time when paper money could be rendered worthless, but how many people out there are capable of assaying gold? Gold has been debased and counterfeited for millennia and fake gold is not worth much more than defaulted paper money.

Investors should also remember that governments around the world have seized the gold of their citizens in times of crisis. Those who think that it couldn't happen in the U.S. or it would be over their dead bodies should refer to Gold Reserve Act of 1934 - the act that gave the U.S. government the power to seize gold at a value determined by the people doing the seizing. (For related reading, see What Was The Gold Reserve Act?)

To be even more catty, gold has a few major problems when it comes to real crisis - it is heavy, it cannot be eaten, it cannot be worn and it cannot be used as shelter. As far as using it as a medium of exchange once the government - and law and order - has collapsed doesn't work. If the government collapses and there's widespread chaos, gold is not going to be worth much absent the willpower and hardware to defend it. In other words, if I have a gun and you have gold, I'll soon have my gun and your gold. The value of gold to the regular person in a situation of total disaster is very much uncertain - the idea of people calmly going about their business and buying goods and services with gold coins presumes quite a bit of order and infrastructure staying in place.

What Gold Is Good For
Just because gold is not a perfect inflation hedge, nor an insurance policy against disaster, does not mean that it has no value and no use. Gold has inherent value in that it does not simultaneously represent one party's asset and another's liability. It also happens to be an excellent trade on fear. While gold's movements are very unpredictable over short periods of time, outperformance seems to correlate strongly with people feeling bad or nervous about economic and political conditions in their country.

It may not be widely remembered now, but in addition to major inflation issues in the late 1970s and early 1980s, there was quite a lot of fear about the state of the U.S., the quality of its leadership and competitiveness, and whether the country could continue to pay it bills. If that sounds familiar, it's no coincidence. Then as now, people did not have confidence in the U.S. government and could not envision how the U.S. would stay globally competitive. Consequently, many people dumped stocks and bonds in favor of gold. Gold set record prices that have only recently been surmounted.

Banks can fail and governments can run the printing presses all day and night, but there is only so much gold in the world. That is a powerful security blanket to hold onto while waiting for the next economic turnaround and the next technological revolution.

The Bottom Line
For investors who understand the psychology of the fear trade, and who can appreciate that gold is one of the only financial assets that becomes more attractive as people feel worse about the economy, gold is a great investment vehicle. For investors who believe that gold is a no-brainer hedge against inflation or proof that they can survive the collapse of Western Civilization, gold is a pretty lousy instrument.

Like any other financial asset, gold is worth most when there is an orderly market of willing buyers and sellers. Disasters are infamous for being decidedly disorderly and, as political collapses in recent decades have shown all too well, the rule of the gun is more common than the rule of the gold when the center no longer holds.

There are plenty of reasons to be skeptical and disillusioned with western governments today, and it is all but certain that there is a day of reckoning to come as debts, unfunded obligations, overextended money supplies and insufficient tax bases all come home to roost. Investors should ask how much the current situation already resembles the early 1980s. While fear is an incredibly powerful short-term market force, it, like gold bubbles, does not last forever. (Think the value of gold is unshakable? For more, see The Gold Standard Revisited.)

Related Articles
  1. Options & Futures

    Why Gold Is No Longer the Currency King

    Although a gold standard seems like a good idea, looking at its role in U.S. history reveals that it may not be the beacon of stability that it claims.
  2. Bonds & Fixed Income

    Credit Default Swaps: An Introduction

    This derivative can help manage portfolio risk, but it isn't a simple vehicle.
  3. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Five ETFs for Contrarian Investors

    Here are five ETF ideas that can be used by the contrarian investor.
  4. Chart Advisor

    Global Weakness Evident By These 3 Commodity Charts

    Weakness in the metals shown on the charts of these three ETFs suggest that the bears are in control of the momentum. We'll take a look to see if there is a reversal in sight.
  5. Investing

    Why is Gold a Counter Cyclical Asset?

    Gold is widely considered a safe haven during market turbulence. History has proven gold performs counter cyclically to the state of the U.S. economy.
  6. Investing Basics

    Hedging for Beginners: A Guide

    People hedge as insurance against market volatility. Anyone can do it; here's a primer.
  7. Stock Analysis

    Is Now the Right Time to Buy Gold Mining Stocks?

    Examine the current case for buying gold stocks, and learn the reasons why gold and mining stocks may be set to begin a new rally in the near future.
  8. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Top 3 Inflation Protected Bond Mutual Funds

    Learn about the characteristics and suitability of the top inflation-protected bond mutual funds, and how investors can use these funds to their advantage.
  9. Investing

    How To Build a Currency Hedged Strategy?

    We are still unsure of how to implement a currency hedge strategy based on the dollar's movement. So let’s focus on what’s easier to measure: time horizon.
  10. Investing Basics

    Learn How To Trade Gold In 4 Steps

    Trading spot gold or gold futures, equities and options isn’t hard to learn, but the activity requires skill sets unique to these markets.
  1. Why do companies enter into futures contracts?

    Different types of companies may enter into futures contracts for different purposes. The most common reason is to hedge ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. How can I hedge my portfolio to protect from a decline in the food and beverage sector?

    The food and beverage sector exhibits greater volatility than the broader market and tends to suffer larger-than-average ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. What techniques are most useful for hedging exposure to the insurance sector?

    Investing style determines the best hedging techniques for the insurance sector. This sector comprises three segments, two ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. How can I hedge my portfolio to protect from a decline in the retail sector?

    The retail sector provides growth investors with a great opportunity for better-than-average gains during periods of market ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What techniques are most useful for hedging exposure to the utilities sector?

    Utilities is one of the most stable sectors in the market. As such, its primary appeal to investors is its resistance to ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What techniques are most useful for hedging exposure to the telecommunications sector?

    A couple of option strategies can be used to hedge exposure to the telecommunications sector. Certain option strategies can ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Hot Definitions
  1. Take A Bath

    A slang term referring to the situation of an investor who has experienced a large loss from an investment or speculative ...
  2. Black Friday

    1. A day of stock market catastrophe. Originally, September 24, 1869, was deemed Black Friday. The crash was sparked by gold ...
  3. Turkey

    Slang for an investment that yields disappointing results or turns out worse than expected. Failed business deals, securities ...
  4. Barefoot Pilgrim

    A slang term for an unsophisticated investor who loses all of his or her wealth by trading equities in the stock market. ...
  5. Quick Ratio

    The quick ratio is an indicator of a company’s short-term liquidity. The quick ratio measures a company’s ability to meet ...
  6. Black Tuesday

    October 29, 1929, when the DJIA fell 12% - one of the largest one-day drops in stock market history. More than 16 million ...
Trading Center