Two of the biggest book retailers in the U.S., Amazon and Barnes and Noble, both offer electronic textbook rentals. The service doesn't always offer cost savings compared to purchasing a traditional textbook, but it does offer convenience. If you're not sure where to shop, consider how the two companies compare on pricing, rental terms, portability and other factors.
TUTORIAL: Education Savings Account: Introduction
Amazon advertises that students can save up to 80% off the list price of printed textbooks with Kindle Textbook Rental. Barnes and Noble states that students can save up to 60% with e-textbooks compared to the cost of buying a new textbook.
Which retailer is cheaper really depends on an individual student's needs, including book title, book edition and rental length. The two vendors offer different titles in electronic format, so students won't be able to price shop on every book they need. Some titles are only available in print no matter where students shop. One retailer may have only the most recent edition as an e-textbook, and another may have only a previous edition.
If both vendors carry the same edition of the same e-textbook, rental length can be the deciding factor when it comes to price. (For related reading, see 5 Alternatives To Expensive Textbooks.)
With Amazon, students can rent a book for as little as 30 days to as many as 360 days. This feature means that students in universities that operate on quarter systems don't have to pay to rent a book for an entire semester. It also means that students don't have to rent a book for an entire semester if a class only uses a book for part of a term. Students can extend a rental by as little as one day at any time. They can also purchase the book with a credit for the amount already paid for the rental as long as the rental is still active.
Whereas Amazon consumers have flexibility in determining the length of their book rentals, Barnes and Noble appears to offer only one fixed rental length, which varies by book. Rental periods do not appear to be extendable. The option to rent an e-textbook for a short period can offer substantial savings. Absent this option, the convenience of having a textbook in electronic form may be worth the premium to some students.
Like its other Kindle books, Amazon offers free samples of any textbook available in electronic form. Samples can be read on a Kindle or computer. Amazon does not offer a free trial, but rental books can be returned for a full refund within seven days. At Barnes and Noble, some titles come with a free seven-day trial, and all titles are refundable if they have not yet been downloaded. Titles that the student has already downloaded are refundable within seven days.
Electronic textbooks free up much-needed storage space in cramped dorm rooms and relieve students of the physical burdens of carrying textbooks, which can strain backs and necks.
Amazon's rental price grants students the ability to read an electronic textbook on a variety of devices, including computers, e-readers and mobile devices (the reading apps are free). The ability to read a textbook anytime and anywhere makes it easy to take advantage of time that would otherwise be wasted. Waiting for the bus? Study a few pages of your textbook on your phone.
Unlike Amazon's e-textbooks, Barnes and Noble's e-textbooks can only be read on computers. The free software required to read the books is called NOOKstudy, but the books cannot be viewed on the NOOK e-reader. An exception is books that might be required for a class but aren't textbooks, such as novels for an English literature class.
Both companies include free study aides with their book-reading software. Barnes and Noble's NOOKstudy software allows students to digitally highlight and make notes in textbooks as well as tag important content and search. Amazon offers similar features and lets students retain their highlights and notes even after the rental period expires. Barnes and Noble does not.
The Bottom Line
There are substantial differences between Amazon and Barnes and Noble in terms of e-textbook rental features and pricing. Amazon appears to have an edge when it comes to portability, study aides and rental length (and therefore price, in some cases), making it a possible leader in this market. Money-wise students should check both options before renting any given e-textbook. (For related reading, see 7 Money-Saving Resources For College Students.)
For more on this subject, read Do e-Textbooks Help Students Save Money?
TaxesLearn about the differences between sales taxes and Internet sales taxes, and the goods and services that typically incur each type of tax.
EntrepreneurshipLearn about how the Marketplace Fairness Act may impact small business owners should it pass in the House and what the act requires from business owners.
SavingsIf you're an aficionado of artisanal brews (or would like to be), a beer club can be a palate-pleasing, albeit pricey, way to expand your hops horizon.
Investing BasicsFind out how a national Internet sales tax could affect interstate commerce, and why some bigger online retailers are lobbying for such a tax.
Stock AnalysisIs DKS a bargain here?
Stock AnalysisUrban Outfitters just made a bold move. Will it pay off?
Stock AnalysisWill TripAdvisor's downside risk outweigh upside potential in 2016? It's most recent SEC filing offers some strong clues.
Stock AnalysisWalmart is enjoying a short-term rally. Is it sustainable? Is Amazon still a better bet?
SavingsSome points to consider, before committing to a membership for yourself – or as a gift. The right club can also help you save money over the holidays.
Personal FinanceWalmart and Target both revealed multi-year plans to grow their businesses. Which of these two retailers is the biggest threat to Amazon?
You can only purchase NetSpend reload packs at Giant Eagle, Albertsons, Roundy's and Pathmark supermarkets. NetSpend cards ... Read Full Answer >>
QVC, an American TV network, is registered with states to collect sales or use tax on taxable items. QVC is also required ... Read Full Answer >>
Foreign visitors to Walmart locations in the United States can use their credit cards issued by banks outside of the U.S. ... Read Full Answer >>
QVC, Inc., is a wholly owned subsidiary of Liberty Interactive Corporation. It is attributed to the QVC Group tracking stock, ... Read Full Answer >>
In microeconomics, utility represents a way to relate the amount of goods consumed to the amount of happiness or satisfaction ... Read Full Answer >>
Electronic retail is one of the fastest growing segments of the economy. Every year, more people are choosing to purchase ... Read Full Answer >>