Individuals seeking employment in the financial services industry have a wide array of job choices and employers to choose from. Many firms in the industry qualify as either a broker-dealer or big bank. Below is an overview of what each one has to offer to employees and the different opportunities available with each.

Broker-Dealer Employment
To work for a broker-dealer basically means working for any firm in the business of buying and selling securities. The broker-dealer distinction refers to the fact that the firm will generally operate as either a broker or a dealer, depending on the transaction. The technical Investopedia definition explains that a broker is only an agent who executes orders on behalf of clients, whereas a dealer acts as a principal and trades for his or her own account. Because most brokerages, also known as wire houses, act as both brokers and principals, the term broker-dealer is commonly used to describe the combined responsibilities.

Firms that have significant broker-dealer operations include the giant bulge-bracket firms, such as Goldman Sachs and Morgan Stanley, and second-tier firms, such as Raymond James Financial. The benefits of working for these firms shows through during market upswings. In other words, their profits roll in when stock market trading activity is high and frequent. Prior to the financial crisis, many of the leading broker-dealers easily reported double-digit return on equity (ROE) ratios or return on book value; many ROEs exceeded 20% prior to the crisis hitting. This is a primary profitability metric when determining if financial firms are doing well.

Of course, the flips side is these firms don't do nearly as well during a bear market. The current market environment illustrates the difficulty these firms are having. Stock trading activity is depressed and there are less companies going public through initial public offerings, which use broker-dealers to distribute the stock issued during an IPO. When profit margins suffer, there is less to go around to employees in the form of new jobs and bonuses to existing workers.

Working for a Big Bank
Working at a big bank has traditionally been thought of as securing a very stable, predictable living. Returning again to ROE as a financial measure, the industry average ROE is currently around 12%, and the best-run banks, such as U.S. Bancorp, currently boast five-year average ROE levels closer to 15%. From an employee perspective, steady profits mean job stability and predictable paychecks. The upside isn't as great during boom times as can occur at broker-dealers, but many employees are willing to make the tradeoff for a job they can count on.

Again, the financial crisis eliminated the security of a big banking job at many firms. Washington Mutual and Wachovia were snapped up by JPMorgan Chase and Wells Fargo, with both moves resulting in workforce reductions and the loss of many years of retirement funds that were invested in company stock. But again, there are still a handful of well-run banks, such as U.S. Bancorp, JPMorgan and Wells Fargo, that are able to offer steady, if unexciting job prospects. It is important to note that large banks also offer some generous benefit and vacation packages, such as up to four weeks for employees that remain gainfully employed at the same bank for three or more consecutive years.

A More Direct Comparison
Working for a broker-dealer definitely carries more upside in terms of the potential for a higher salary; however, this risk has grown only more apparent in recent years. A recent article in an Investment News periodical stated that "all the wire houses have been pushing their advisers to pursue more profitable high-net-worth clients" and cited one in particular that was making it very clear that brokers who don't meet their numbers could be sent packing for another firm. In other words, brokers who perform or are simply lucky enough to have connections to bring in new business or make steady investment trades, do quite well in this environment. Others who aren't as adept at selling or bringing in new clients can easily lose their jobs.

Working for a big bank definitely offers sales as a possibility, but a bank has many more functions than simply helping facilitate trades or bring in clients who are able to help facilitate trading activity. They have tellers, loan officers, back office support staff, asset managers, trust officers, portfolio managers and just about any financial services function imaginable. Combined with the more visible career stability offered by better-run banks, a big bank is going to offer much more in terms of job flexibility beyond what a broker-dealer is willing to offer.

The Bottom Line
As with any job, individual preferences and skill sets will primarily determine if an individual is better suited working for a broker-dealer or a bank. Those seeking to strike it rich may be best off trying their luck at a broker, and the ideal timing would be during a bull market. Those with a more general interest in financial services should be able to find an opportunity at a big bank, and steady employment, if they play their cards right.

Related Articles
  1. Professionals

    Tips on Building a Resume for a Private Equity Job

    Trying to land a job in the coveted private equity sector? Ensure your resume meets the stringent PE job requirements with these important tips.
  2. Personal Finance

    A Day in the Life of an Equity Research Analyst

    What does an equity research analyst do on an everyday basis?
  3. Investing

    Career Choice: Bulge Bracket Vs. Boutique Bank

    Bulge bracket banks offer higher salaries and prestige. But boutique banks are rapidly gaining market share and may offer better work/life balance and job security.
  4. Personal Finance

    Careers: Equity Research Vs. Investment Banking

    Equity research is sometimes viewed as the unglamorous, lower-paid cousin to investment banking. In this article, we compare the two careers.
  5. Investing

    7 Reasons You Will Make a Good Investment Banker

    Many seek at the door of investment banking, but few can enter. Possessing these seven traits will help you land a job and succeed in investment banking.
  6. Investing

    7 Reasons Investment Banking Is Not for You

    Even if you possess the education, experience and enthusiasm to land a coveted investment banking gig, here are seven reasons to find another career.
  7. Personal Finance

    The 10 Must Watch Movies For Finance Professionals

    Finance makes for great cinema; here are 10 of the best offerings by Hollywood on the subject.
  8. Professionals

    Career Advice: Management Consulting Vs. Investment Banking

    Compare the career opportunities available in management consulting and investment banking. Learn about salaries, skills needed and work-life balance.
  9. Professionals

    Career Advice: Management Consulting Vs. Law

    Compare the career opportunities between management and law using such criteria as skills needed, starting salary and work-life balance.
  10. Professionals

    Career Advice: Management Consulting Vs. Private Equity

    Compare the career paths of management consulting and private equity, using criteria such as skills needed, starting salary and work-life balance.
  1. Investment Banker

    Someone working at an institution raising capital for companies, ...
  2. Advanced Diploma In Insurance

    A qualification earned by insurance professionals and conferred ...
  3. Associate In Personal Insurance ...

    A designation earned by professionals looking for training in ...
  4. Associate In Reinsurance (ARe)

    A designation earned by insurance professionals looking for reinsurance ...
  5. Associate In Surplus Lines Insurance ...

    A designation earned by insurance professionals involved with ...
  6. Associate In Fidelity And Surety ...

    A designation earned by bond producers, bond underwriters, and ...
  1. How can an investment banker switch to a career in corporate finance?

    It's pretty easy for an investment banker to switch to a career in corporate finance. The career skills are easily transferable, ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What are the best MBA programs for corporate finance?

    Opinions vary based on which publications you consult, but the best MBA programs for a career in corporate finance are at ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. How stressful is the typical corporate finance job?

    In the financial industry, corporate finance jobs are often contrasted with investment banking jobs. The traditional view ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. What should I study in school to prepare for a career in corporate finance?

    Depending on which area you want to specialize in, corporate finance can be one of the most competitive fields in business. ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What are the differences between a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) and a Certified ...

    The differences between a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) and a Certified Financial Planner (CFP) are many, but comes down ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What types of positions might a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) hold?

    The types of positions that a Chartered Financial Analyst (CFA) is likely to hold include any position that deals with large ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center

You are using adblocking software

Want access to all of Investopedia? Add us to your “whitelist”
so you'll never miss a feature!