Having recently examined Arch Coal (NYSE:ACI) and Cloud Peak Energy (NYSE:CLD), it's time to examine the largest U.S. coal producer – Peabody Energy (NYSE:BTU). There is a lot to like about Peabody at first glance, as this company has attractive U.S. thermal coal exposure (with minimal Appalachian reserves) and heavily China-leveraged met coal exposure.

On the other hand, Peabody is arguably the most well-respected coal miner out there (and maybe one of the best-regarded natural resource companies overall) and investors and analysts consistently award the stock a higher multiple than its peers. Consequently, while Peabody may the highest-quality coal stock to own today, the upside in these shares to a thermal (and/or met) coal recovery doesn't seem as great as in its rivals.

SEE: A Primer On Coal

Familiar News On U.S. Thermal
As I mentioned with both Arch Coal and Cloud Peak, some investors and analysts have been getting more optimistic about U.S. thermal coal demand. Higher natural gas prices have led some utilities to utilize more coal-fired generation capacity and coal-fired generation is up about 11% over last year. At the same time, utilities are working down their inventories and that is often good for prices.

The question, though, is just how much pricing leverage is really out there. Peabody management has said that they believe utility inventories need to drop below 60 days for prices to really react. While some Western utilities are apparently now in the 60s, the last reported datum point from the EIA indicated that nationwide inventories were in the low 70s (or about 20% higher than the breakpoint).

It's also important to note that there will be gaps and lags between price action and improvement in the reported financials. Peabody already has about 60% or so of anticipated 2014 U.S. thermal production under contract, and at prices pretty similar to 2013 levels. Likewise, Cloud Peak has recently been contracting for 2014 deliveries at prices scarcely better than current costs. There is also the chance that idled capacity (20-30% of thermal capacity is believed to be idle) will come on line again as prices improve, though Peabody management maintains that a lot of this capacity needs maintenance and can't/won't come back quickly (which, incidentally, likely makes watching trends in Joy Global's (NYSE:JOY) reported aftermarket/parts revenue well worth watching).

SEE: The Industry Handbook Tutorial – The Utilities Industry

Met Coal Not Looking So Hot Right Now
It wasn't so long ago that seemingly insatiable demand for steel in China pushed met coal prices to very attractive levels, enticing companies like Peabody, Arch Coal, Teck (NYSE:TCK) and Walter (NYSE:WLT) to expand their met coal holdings. As is so often the case in cyclical commodities, the highs didn't last and now about 30% of the world's met coal supply is being produced at uneconomical prices (according to Peabody management).

Still, not all met coal assets are created equal. While Arch Coal took on a seemingly dangerous amount of debt to acquire high-cost underground Appalachian met coal assets that largely go to the European and U.S. steel markets, Peabody has built its met coal assets around China's steel industry with acquisitions and new greenfield projects in Australia, China, and Mongolia. Given that I think Chinese steel production is likely to outstrip European production (to say nothing of the fact that Peabody's mines could conceivably support demand in South Korea, Japan, and India as well as China), I like Peabody's assets more than Arch Coal's, even if global spot prices are pretty unattractive at present.

Plenty Of Noise Between Now And Then
It won't be a smooth ride for Peabody between here and the next coal boom. Peabody has pretty solid labor relations, but a quick look at the experience of companies in areas like South Africa and Indonesia shows that that sort of situation can change pretty quickly. Likewise, Peabody is a solid producer and capital allocator, but it could take some time for the per-ton margins to really improve.

I think it's worth mentioning that there's still a lot of uncertainty about Peabody's near-term financial performance, as the high/low spread on EBITDA estimates over the next 12 months is greater than one-third. That said, coal stocks generally trade more on coal prices than reported financial results. While it is extremely dangerous to say that prices can't get any worse, I have to think that, on balance, the odds favor improvements in thermal and met coal prices over the next few years.

SEE: Fueling Futures In The Energy Market

The Bottom Line
The problem for investors considering Peabody is that Peabody only gets cheap (relatively speaking) when things get very bad. Peabody doesn't have Arch Coal's liquidity or long-term Appalachia cost issues, nor Cloud Peak's pure exposure to U.S. thermal coal. Then again, investors and analysts seem to be more willing to look past 12-month EBITDA when valuing Peabody's shares.

On a 12-month EBITDA basis, Peabody should probably trade at around $19 to $20. That's higher than today's price, but maybe not enough to compensate investors for the risk and volatility that goes with global coal markets. On the other hand, long-term NPV analysis can produce a target near $30, which suggests meaningful undervaluation and pretty attractive relative valuation compared to Arch Coal and Cloud Peak. While it will probably take time for the coal markets to recover, Peabody offers a pretty interesting mix of quality-enhanced risk and long-term upside, even with the higher multiples that the stock usually gets from the market.

At the time of writing, Stephen D. Simpson did not own shares in any of the companies mentioned in this article.

Related Articles
  1. Markets

    Relative Valuation Of Stocks Can Be A Trap

    This method of valuing a company can make it look like a bargain when it is not.
  2. Investing

    5 Common Trading Multiples Used In Oil And Gas Valuation

    Before you decide to invest in oil and gas, you should understand these multiples.
  3. Personal Finance

    An Introduction To Capital Budgeting

    We look at three widely used valuation methods and figure out how companies justify spending.
  4. Markets

    How To Choose The Best Stock Valuation Method

    Don't be overwhelmed by the many valuation techniques out there - knowing a few characteristics about a company will help you pick the best one.
  5. Bonds & Fixed Income

    Equity Valuation In Good Times And Bad

    Learn how to filter out the noise of the market place in order to find a solid way of determing a company's value.
  6. Markets

    Investment Valuation Ratios

    Learn about per share data, price/book value ratio, price/cash flow ratio, price/earnings ratio, price/sales ratio, dividend yield and the enterprise multiple.
  7. Investing

    How to Ballast a Portfolio with Bonds

    If January and early February performance is any guide, there’s a new normal in financial markets today: Heightened volatility.
  8. Stock Analysis

    Performance Review: Emerging Markets Equities in 2015

    Find out why emerging markets struggled in 2015 and why a half-decade long trend of poor returns is proving optimistic growth investors wrong.
  9. Investing News

    Today's Sell-off: Are We in a Margin Liquidation?

    If we're in market liquidation, is it good news or bad news? That party depends on your timeframe.
  10. Investing News

    Bank Stocks: Time to Buy or Avoid? (WFC, JPM, C)

    Bank stocks have been pounded. Is this the right time to buy or should they be avoided?
  1. How do dividends affect retained earnings?

    When a company issues a cash dividend to its shareholders, the retained earnings listed on the balance sheet are reduced ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What is the difference between called-up share capital and paid-up share capital?

    The difference between called-up share capital and paid-up share capital is investors have already paid in full for paid-up ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Why would a corporation issue convertible bonds?

    A convertible bond represents a hybrid security that has bond and equity features; this type of bond allows the conversion ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. How does additional paid in capital affect retained earnings?

    Both additional paid-in capital and retained earnings are entries under the shareholders' equity section of a company's balance ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What types of capital are not considered share capital?

    The money a business uses to fund operations or growth is called capital, and there are a number of capital sources available. ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is the difference between issued share capital and subscribed share capital?

    The difference between subscribed share capital and issued share capital is the former relates to the amount of stock for ... Read Full Answer >>
Trading Center