Like so many other banks in Europe, Santander (NYSE:SAN) has been through the wringer. Its home market of Spain has seen devastating economic decline, and relatively healthier operations in faster-growing areas like Brazil and Mexico haven't made up the difference. The bank's shares have dropped more than 50% over the past five years.
Bad as things have been, investors in the U.S. have seen plenty of examples of how bank stocks can recover significantly once credit costs begin to stabilize and then improve. On one hand, then, is the possibility of a Bank of America (NYSE:BAC) or Citigroup-like (NYSE:C) rise from the ashes. But on the other hand is the truly scary state of affairs in Spain and the risk that Latin America is starting to slow to a significant degree. Although Santander shares may be a little cheap today and would certainly have significant upside if/when the market believes Spain has stabilized (and with it, Santander's credit costs), the risk/reward tradeoff does not seem appealing enough to me when considering the options available to investors in other European and Latin American banking stocks.
Spain – A Small Part of Profits, but Still a Big Risk
Although Spain only accounts for a small part of Santander's profits (less than 10% in the last quarter), it still makes up about 15% of the bank's labor force, over 30% of its branch network and deposits, and about 25% of its loans.
That's a big problem, as Spain continues to struggle to an extent that Americans may find hard to believe. Spain's first quarter unemployment rate was a whopping 27% and unemployment among the youth (age 25 or younger) was close to 60%. While the second quarter unemployment rate fell to 26%, it appears that the decline had more to do with emigration and workers giving up their search for work.
Not surprisingly, it's difficult to make progress against that backdrop. While banks in the U.S. like BB&T (NYSE:BBT) had the option to deal relatively aggressively with their problem credits (writing down properties and loans and moving them off the balance sheet), that has proven to be more challenging for Spanish banks like Santander and BBVA (Nasdaq:BBVA) as the only prices at which they can sell weaken their credit more than just hanging on and hoping for improvements.
Consequently, there's something of a deja vu case here with the “zombie banks” that weighed on Japan's economy for so long. With only about 50% coverage of Santander's NPLs, I believe credit and capital risks are still relevant here.
Can Latin America Save the Day?
Both BBVA and Santander can look outside of their borders to healthier banking markets in Latin America, or at least that was the hope. Unfortunately, Latin American profits came in about 5% below expectations in the second quarter the major markets of both Brazil and Mexico are showing signs of weakness.
While Brazil's results did show better credit quality, major consumer-facing companies like Wal-Mart (NYSE:WMT) and Arcos Dorados (Nasdaq:ARCO) have talked of growing economic pressures on consumers. Though I'm not predicting any sort of banking collapse in Latin America, it's worth noting that major Latin American banks like Itau Unibanco (Nasdaq:ITUB), Bradesco (NYSE:BBD), Creditcorp (NYSE:BAP), and Santander's own Mexican subsidiary Santander Mexico (Nasdaq:BSMX) are all well off their highs on weaker loan growth and rising rates.
The Bottom Line
Although I've seen some analysts argue that Spain is stabilizing and that conditions in Latin America are just temporary, I'm more cautious on those topics with respect to Santander. With the bank's NPLs up for multiple quarters in a row and tangible equity per share declining, I just don't believe that Santander has the “wiggle room” for things to get any worse.
Moreover, neither a return on equity model nor a TBV/RoTCE model suggest major upside from today's price (5% to 15%) despite relatively optimistic assumptions. Now, there are certainly plenty of examples from the U.S. banking sector that show how well a bank stock can respond once credit costs have bottomed and started to improve, I'd be cautious about assuming that Santander is poised to see that same sort of rebound in the remainder of 2013.
Disclosure – As of this writing, the author owns shares of BB&T.

Related Articles
  1. Bonds & Fixed Income

    Introduction To Commercial Paper

    Commercial paper is a short-term instrument that can be a viable alternative for retail fixed-income investors looking for a better rate of return on their money.
  2. Investing Basics

    The Role of Commercial Banks in the Economy

    We interact with commercial banks daily to carry out simple financial tasks. That said, the function and creation of a commercial bank is anything but simple.
  3. Investing Basics

    How Banks Set Interest Rates On Your Loans

    On the face of it, figuring out how a bank makes money is a pretty straightforward affair. A bank earns a spread on the money it lends out from the money it takes in as a deposit. The net interest ...
  4. General

    Retail Banking Vs. Corporate Banking

    Retail banking refers to the division of a bank that deals directly with retail customers. Also known as consumer banking or personal banking, retail banking is the visible face of banking to ...
  5. Economics

    Long-Term Investing Impact of the Paris Attacks

    We share some insights on how the recent terrorist attacks in Paris could impact the economy and markets going forward.
  6. Savings

    Opening a Bank Account in Costa Rica as an American

    It shouldn’t be too hard to do, provided you have the appropriate documentation and forms. But be prepared for lots of paperwork!
  7. Investing

    How the Rothschild Family Created Their Wealth

    An overview of how the Rothschild dynasty became one of the most powerful families in the world.
  8. Investing Basics

    4 Iconic Financial Companies That No Longer Exist

    Learn how poor management, frauds, scandals or mergers wiped out some of the most recognizable brands in the finance industry in the United States.
  9. Credit & Loans

    Personal Loans: Compare the 6 Biggest Banks

    Need a personal loan? You may stop by one of these big banks for help. Their offerings vary in size, rates and loan types, which means you have options.
  10. Investing

    2 Undervalued Bank Stocks

    Banks in the industry sweet spot are positioned to perform.
  1. Does the FDIC cover credit unions?

    The Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (FDIC) does not cover credit unions. The FDIC only insures deposits in banks and ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What are Santander's escheatment services?

    Escheatment is the process where an individual's assets are considered abandoned and the custody of said assets is assigned ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Do banks have working capital?

    The concept of working capital does not apply to banks since financial institutions do not have typical current assets and ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Who decides to print money in Canada?

    In Canada, new money comes from two places: the Bank of Canada (BOC) and chartered banks such as the Toronto Dominion Bank ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. Who decides when to print money in India?

    The Reserve Bank of India, or RBI, manages currency in India. The bank's additional responsibilities include regulating the ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is the difference between a Debit Order and a Standard Order in a bank reconciliation?

    While both debit orders and standard orders represent recurring transactions that must be considered in bank reconciliations, ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center