It feels as though it was a very long time ago when Arch Capital (Nasdaq:ACGL) last traded at a meaningful discount to fair value. But then, that's the price of excellence – there are few insurance management teams I'd rather invest with and the market is not shy about rewarding the shares for the skill of the team here. While there's always a chance that an active storm season could create an investment opportunity in Arch Capital, investors shouldn't this stock to offer many opportunities to buy at significant discounts to fair value.
Can Pricing Stay Strong?
Pricing has been pretty solid in the P&C market over the past couple of years, as losses haven't been too bad and companies have appeared to use a little more discipline with pricing. But nothing good ever lasts, and while Arch Capital did see U.S. rate growth of about 4%, management mentioned that a few areas of the market are showing tougher pricing environments. To that end, while gross insurance premiums were up 4% in the second quarter, reinsurance premiums written fell 10% (13% on a net basis) on lower property cat and mortgage premiums. 
On one hand, insurance “supply” seems pretty robust right now. Berkshire Hathaway (NYSE:BRK.A) has entered the commercial P&C market and Arch Capital itself decided to enter the mortgage insurance market and compete with the likes of Genworth (NYSE:GNW) and Radian (NYSE:RDN).
On the other hand, we're entering the peak season for Atlantic hurricanes. As much as I hate to put it this way, the industry probably “needs” storm damage on the order of $20 billion to maintain rates into 2014, while it would take a Katrina-sized level of losses ($50 billion) to lead to meaningful rate growth.
The good news for Arch Capital shareholders is that, along with ACE (NYSE: ACE), this company is among the best-positioned to continue growing during a stable rate environment. Some of that is due to the company's strong capital position and robust reserves, but a lot of it also has to do with a very intelligently-run business approach that can quickly allocate capital across businesses as rates and returns evolve.
Will Results Have to Regress to the Mean?
One of the bearish arguments is that Arch Capital can't be better than everybody forever. As the company grows, it becomes more difficult to redeploy capital and the company's returns should approach the industry average. I'm not sure I buy this completely.
Yes, it will be difficult for the company to continually out-underwrite its peer group, but as the recent entry into the mortgage insurance business suggests, there are still areas where Arch has little or no presence. What's more, on a long-term basis you can do really well in insurance simply by avoiding the huge mistakes that your peers are likely to make sooner or later and Arch Capital has shown a good history of doing precisely that.
A Hurricane Trade?
Perhaps not surprisingly, Arch Capital makes sure that it doesn't have all that much exposure to the Atlantic hurricane market. But it may also surprise investors that reinsurance companies often outperform in the month of September, as truly devastating storms are relatively rare and “manageable” levels of damage can strengthen rates going into the next year.
To that end, investors who want to play insurance names with more exposure to Atlantic hurricanes may want to consider names like RenaissanceRe (NYSE:RNR), Everest Re (NYSE:RE), PartnerRe (NYSE:PRE), or Montpelier Re (NYSE:MRH).
The Bottom Line
Even if I project a long-term return on equity of 14% (only slightly below the prior decade average of about 16%), an excess returns model suggests a fair value of only about $59 – 10% above today's price, and only with a long-term ROE well in excess of what most sell-side analysts project for the company. Likewise, creating an industry-wide TBV/ROE regression suggests that Arch Capital's current P/TBV ratio of 1.35x is almost spot-on with how the industry is pricing stocks these days.
There are certainly worse decisions than buying a well-run company at fair value, but the perpetual bargain hunter in me wants to hold back in the slim hope that worries about storms and/or pricing could make these shares a little cheaper before year end.
Disclosure: As of this writing, the author has no financial positions in any companies mentioned.

Related Articles
  1. Home & Auto

    The Beginner's Guide To Homeowners' Insurance

    Discover everything new homeowners need to know before they sign on the dotted line.
  2. Home & Auto

    Life Insurance Clauses Determine Your Coverage

    Understanding these key parts of your policy will help you to ensure that your family will be covered.
  3. Stock Analysis

    Allstate: How Being Boring Earns it Billions (ALL)

    A summary of what Allstate Insurance sells and whom it sells it to including recent mergers and acquisitions that have helped boost its bottom line.
  4. Insurance

    How To Read a Permanent Life Insurance Illustration

    To help you understand your life insurance policy, companies provide a permanent life insurance illustration. Here is how to read and understand it.
  5. Insurance

    Millennials Guide: Too Young for Life Insurance?

    Unless you have kids, it's easy to think you don't need life insurance Here are the reasons why you might– as well as which type and how much to get.
  6. Insurance

    Buying Insurance: Can You Trust

    Startup PolicyGenius is transforming the insurance-shopping experience by helping consumers find out which policies they need with its unique set of tools.
  7. Insurance

    How to Compare Permanent Life Insurance Policies

    How you can use the internal rate of return to compare and purchase a permanent life insurance policy.
  8. Stock Analysis

    Prudential Financial's Profits Run on this Product

    Expansion into global markets while focussing on tried and true policies at home has helped Prudential Financial grow and remain successful.
  9. Investing Basics

    What is the Buy Side?

    Buy-side firms are those that comprise Wall Street’s investing institutions.
  10. Insurance

    Top 7 Car Insurance Companies in California

    Understand what makes a auto insurance company good in the state of California. Learn about the top seven largest auto insurers in California.
  1. What changes might I need to make to my insurance policy?

    The number one thing to remember about insurance is that, just like everything else, it changes over time. The top-of-the-line ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Why would you want a monthly benefit versus a daily benefit?

    An insurance benefit is the amount of money paid to or on behalf of the policyholder. Depending on what kind of insurance ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. How do I choose which insurance company to use?

    Picking an insurance company to use is not an easy task, considering the financial crisis of 2008 and 2009. Several financial ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Does homeowners insurance cover fires?

    House fires are one of the most common causes of damage to homes, and almost every homeowners insurance policy covers against ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What are the best ways to sell an annuity?

    The best ways to sell an annuity are to locate buyers from insurance agents or companies that specialize in connecting buyers ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. How does life insurance help high net worth individuals protect their businesses ...

    Life insurance protects the businesses and personal wealth of high-net-worth individuals, or HNWI, by guaranteeing their ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center