On August 10, former Aeropostale (NYSE:ARO) CEO Julian Geiger will receive a supplemental executive retirement payment of $16.5 million. This is in addition to the $34.9 million in total compensation he received over the past three years. The man is definitely going to be able to enjoy his retirement. Thankfully, for shareholders, Aeropostale stock gained 12.3% annually over this period, compared to negative 11% for the S&P 500. Don't misinterpret my recognition of its stock's excellent performance as an endorsement of the company's compensation policy. Far from it. In my opinion, SERPs are just as evil, perhaps more so than deferred compensation.
IN PICTURES: How To Make Your First $1 Million

Pensions for Royalty
Executive compensation expert Graef Crystal believes SERPs should disappear entirely, and explains how these pension benefits came to pass in a recent article. The Employment Retirement Income Security Act of 1974 made it impossible for companies to pay executives more than $75,000 a year in pension benefits. While a janitor could receive 60% of his $30,000 final pay in annual pension benefits, the CEO could only receive 25% (max. $75,000) of his $300,000 salary. In order to make things right, companies were allowed to create SERPs to make up the difference. Unfortunately, what was intended as an act of fairness has turned into a giant slush fund for already prosperous executives, and shareholders are always the one's who pay.

Fair Pay
Crystal did an interactive study for Bloomberg in May that looked at the 2009 pay of S&P 500 CEOs relative to the performance of their stocks. If a company's stock and revenues were higher, so too should be the CEOs pay, Crystal reasoned. He called this redistribution of compensation "fair pay" and the results are quite astonishing. In total, about $2.7 billion in compensation would have moved around under his method, with Alan Mulally of Ford (NYSE:F) deserving the highest pay of all S&P 500 CEOs and Frank Baldino of Cephalon (Nasdaq:CEPH) deserving the least. The most underpaid CEO, according to Crystal, is Eric Schmidt of Google (Nasdaq:GOOG) who received just $245,322 in 2009 compared to what he should have received under fair pay, which is $17.4 million. In the retail world, one of the most underpaid CEOs, according to Crystal's model, is Blake Nordstrom of Nordstrom (NYSE:JWN) fame, who's paid just 26% of his fair pay based on shareholder returns. The most overpaid retail CEO - Glen Senk of Urban Outfitters (Nasdaq:URBN) earned 238% of his fair pay. However, in fairness to Mr. Senk, $25.6 million of his $29.9 million in total compensation were performance stock units that won't vest until 2015 at the earliest, so it's definitely not money in the bank. In addition, Urban Outfitters doesn't have any deferred compensation or executive retirement plans, so it is definitely better than many when it comes to transparent compensation.

Top 10 S&P Retailers by Fair Pay
Company CEO Pay as % Of Fair Pay Total Equity Return
Office Depot (NYSE:ODP) 21% 116.4%
Nordstrom (NYSE:JWN) 26% 180.4%
AutoNation (NYSE:AN) 33% 93.8%
Gap (NYSE:GPS) 34% 72.5%
O\'Reilly Automotive (Nasdaq:ORLY) 44% 24.0%
Tiffany & Co. (NYSE:TIF) 61% 100.3%
J.C. Penney (NYSE:JCP) 65% 52.7%
Limited Brands (NYSE:LTD) 67% 151.7%
Radio Shack (NYSE:RSH) 67% 65.5%
Big Lots (NYSE:BIG) 68% 111.2%

SERP Madness
Some of the worst offenders when it comes to fair pay also happen to pay out quite generously when it comes to SERPs. Donald James, CEO of Vulcan Materials (NYSE:VMC) received $11.1 million in total compensation in 2009. According to Crystal's model, he should have got just $1.5 million and his SERP is valued at $14.3 million. Obviously, CEOs aren't paid for stock performance; Vulcan's stock dropped by 21.7% in fiscal 2009. Then there's the case of Midwestern bank Marshall & Isley (NYSE:MI). It's managed to lose nearly $3 billion in the last two fiscal years, yet CEO Mark Furlong has accumulated benefits in his SERP worth $2.4 million. That's some trick.

The Bottom Line
When my grandfather retired as President of Famous Players Theatres (at the time a division of Paramount) in 1970, they gave him a watch and a party. It was a nice party, mind you, but that was pretty much it. Today, CEOs are given so much unnecessary compensation it's impossible for companies to stop feeding the habit. In many ways, it's worse than drugs because at least with drugs there's a rational explanation for the addiction. Executive compensation, on the other hand, is clearly irrational. If you own a stock with a SERP or deferred compensation plan, I'd recommend dropping it like a hot potato. If a CEO can't get by with $10 million in annual pay, he or she isn't cut out to run any company. Period. (For more stock analysis, take a look at 4 Stocks The Insiders Are Buying.)

Use the Investopedia Stock Simulator to trade the stocks mentioned in this stock analysis, risk free!

Related Articles
  1. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Altria's Return on Equity (ROE) (MO)

    Learn about Altria Group's return on equity (ROE) and analyze net profit margin, asset turnover and financial leverage to determine what is causing its high ROE.
  2. Investing News

    Icahn's Bet on Cheniere Energy: Should You Follow?

    Investing legend Carl Icahn continues to lose money on Cheniere Energy, but he's increasing his stake. Should you follow his lead?
  3. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Google's Return on Equity (ROE) (GOOGL)

    Learn about Alphabet's return on equity. How has its ROE changed over time, how does it compare to its peers and what factors are driving ROE for the company?
  4. Investing News

    Is Buffett's Bet on Oil Right for You? (XOM, PSX)

    Oil stocks are getting trounced, but Warren Buffett still likes one of them. Should you follow the leader?
  5. Investing News

    Chipotle Served with Criminal Probe

    Chipotle's beat muted expectations and got a clear bill from the CDC, but it now appears that an investigation into its E.coli breakout has expanded.
  6. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Sprint Corp's Return on Equity (ROE) (S)

    Learn about Sprint's return on equity. Find out why its ROE is negative and how asset turnover and financial leverage impact ROE relative to Sprint's peers.
  7. Stock Analysis

    Why Alphabet is the Best of the 'FANGs' for 2016

    Alphabet just impressed the street, but is it the best FANG stock?
  8. Investing News

    A 2016 Outlook: What January 2009 Can Teach Us

    January 2009 and January 2016 were similar from an investment standpoint, but from a forward-looking perspective, they were very different.
  9. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    3 Vanguard Equity Fund Underperformers

    Discover three funds from Vanguard Group that consistently underperform their indexes. Learn how consistent most Vanguard low-fee funds are at matching their indexes.
  10. Investing News

    Alphabet Earnings Beat Expectations (GOOGL, AAPL)

    Alphabet's earnings crush analysts' expectations; now bigger than Apple?
  1. How do dividends affect retained earnings?

    When a company issues a cash dividend to its shareholders, the retained earnings listed on the balance sheet are reduced ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What is the difference between called-up share capital and paid-up share capital?

    The difference between called-up share capital and paid-up share capital is investors have already paid in full for paid-up ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Why would a corporation issue convertible bonds?

    A convertible bond represents a hybrid security that has bond and equity features; this type of bond allows the conversion ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. How does additional paid in capital affect retained earnings?

    Both additional paid-in capital and retained earnings are entries under the shareholders' equity section of a company's balance ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What types of capital are not considered share capital?

    The money a business uses to fund operations or growth is called capital, and there are a number of capital sources available. ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is the difference between issued share capital and subscribed share capital?

    The difference between subscribed share capital and issued share capital is the former relates to the amount of stock for ... Read Full Answer >>
Trading Center