The late economist and Nobel Laureate Paul Samuelson said this in 1967 about mutual funds: "There was only one place to make money in the mutual fund business - as there is only one place for a temperate man in a saloon - behind the bar and not in front ... so I invested in a management company." Not much has changed in 43 years. Investors will always be better served buying the stocks of asset management companies than the mutual funds these companies manage. To illustrate my point, I'll examine the share repurchase activities of management companies in fiscal 2006, comparing these hypothetical returns to the end of 2009 with the returns of one of their large domestic equity funds. The results are hardly surprising. (This popular investment vehicle has seen its share of ups and downs, successes and scandals. Read all about it! A Brief History Of The Mutual Fund.)

IN PICTURES: 7 Tools Of The Trade

Five Top Mutual Fund Companies

Company Market Cap Return To Date
2006 Share Repurchases
BlackRock (NYSE:BLK) $28.0B 75.1%
T. Rowe Price Group (Nasdaq:TROW) $13.0B 40.2%
Franklin Resources (NYSE:BEN) $22.8B 20.7%
Eaton Vance (NYSE:EV) $3.5B 9.7%
Federated Investors (NYSE:FII) $2.5B (18.9%)

80% Success Rate
Using an average of the S&P 500 at both the beginning and end of 2006, you get 1333.30. It closed 2009 at 1115.60, meaning the index lost approximately 16.3% over the last three years on a cumulative basis compared to positive returns for four out of five fund companies. Only Federated messed up their share repurchases. At the end of the day, the funds did much worse over the same three-year period. The results are in the table below.

Five Top Mutual Funds

Fund Assets Cumulative Return 2007-2009
BlackRock Equity Dividend A (MDDVX) $7.0B 3.6%
T. Rowe Price Capital Appreciation (PRWCX) $9.3B 10.5%
Templeton Growth A (TEPLX) $19.1B (10.5%)
Eaton Vance Large-Cap Growth A (EALCX) $147.0B 10.6%
Federated Capital Appreciation A (FEDEX) $1.5B (4.3%)

The Index Loses
All five of the funds, however, did better than the S&P 500 between 2007 and 2009. Using my method for calculating the cumulative return for the index, they did so by a significant margin. For instance, the Eaton Vance Large-Cap Growth fund (the top performer of the five) beat the index by 26.9%. Given its small size, it makes sense that it would do the best. After all, the larger a fund gets, the harder it is to outperform the index, because the fund will often begin to track the index rather than engage in stock picking. Interestingly, the Eaton Vance fund did better than management did buying back stock. This is one situation where fund investors actually made out better than shareholders. As you can see by the two tables, it doesn't usually happen.

Bottom Line
Mutual fund companies, as Paul Samuelson pointed out over 40 years ago, are in the business of marketing products, not managing money. They no longer have your best interests at heart (not that they ever did) but those of their shareholders. If you want to invest in mutual funds, be my guest. However, the evidence suggests you're better served investing in the companies themselves. That's where the real money is. (Forget the sock drawer - learn how to earn big bucks over the short term. Check out Money Market Mutual Funds: A Better Savings Account.)

Use the Investopedia Stock Simulator to trade the stocks mentioned in this stock analysis, risk free!

Related Articles
  1. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    The Democratization of the Hedge Fund Industry

    The coveted compensations of hedge fund managers are protected by barriers of entry to the industry, but one recent startup is working to break those barriers.
  2. Retirement

    Two Heads Are Better Than One With Your Finances

    We discuss the advantages of seeking professional help when it comes to managing our retirement account.
  3. Stock Analysis

    Allstate: How Being Boring Earns it Billions (ALL)

    A summary of what Allstate Insurance sells and whom it sells it to including recent mergers and acquisitions that have helped boost its bottom line.
  4. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    American Funds' Top Funds for Retirement

    Planning for retirement in this economic and investment environment is far from easy. American Funds might offer an answer.
  5. Options & Futures

    Cyclical Versus Non-Cyclical Stocks

    Investing during an economic downturn simply means changing your focus. Discover the benefits of defensive stocks.
  6. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Buying Vanguard Mutual Funds Vs. ETFs

    Learn about the differences between Vanguard's mutual fund and ETF products, and discover which may be more appropriate for investors.
  7. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    ETFs Vs. Mutual Funds: Choosing For Your Retirement

    Learn about the difference between using mutual funds versus ETFs for retirement, including which investment strategies and goals are best served by each.
  8. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    The 8 Most Popular Vanguard Funds for a 401(k)

    Learn about some of the mutual funds in Vanguard's lineup that are popular among 401(k) investors, and find out why you should consider them.
  9. Investing Basics

    How to Deduct Your Stock Losses

    Held onto a stock for too long? Selling at a loss is never ideal, but it is possible to minimize the damage. Here's how.
  10. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    Best 3 Vanguard Mutual Funds for Retirement

    Discover the top Vanguard target-date retirement funds with target dates in 2020, 2030 and 2050, and learn about the characteristics of these funds.
  1. How liquid are Vanguard mutual funds?

    The Vanguard mutual fund family is one of the largest and most well-recognized fund family in the financial industry. Its ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. Which mutual funds made money in 2008?

    Out of the 2,800 mutual funds that Morningstar, Inc., the leading provider of independent investment research in North America, ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Does OptionsHouse have mutual funds?

    OptionsHouse has access to some mutual funds, but it depends on the fund in which the investor is looking to buy shares. ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. Should mutual funds be subject to more regulation?

    Mutual funds, when compared to other types of pooled investments such as hedge funds, have very strict regulations. In fact, ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. How do mutual funds work in India?

    Mutual funds in India work in much the same way as mutual funds in the United States. Like their American counterparts, Indian ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. When are mutual fund orders executed?

    Whether buying or selling shares of a fund, mutual fund trades are executed once per day after the market close at 4 p.m. ... Read Full Answer >>

You May Also Like

Trading Center