On New Year's Day, a popular investment site ran an article picking its top six consumer goods stocks for 2010. All of them are good companies. In fact, Scotts Miracle-Gro is one of the most promising mid-caps in the coming years. It's interesting to look at each of the six in terms of capital allocation and, more specifically, how each has fared when repurchasing its shares over the last three fiscal years. Companies that wisely allocate free cash often make better investments than those that don't.

IN PICTURES: World's Greatest Investors

Six Consumer Goods Stock Picks
Company Three-Year Return
Stock Repurchases
Scotts Miracle-Gro (NYSE:SMG) -27.6%
Clorox (NYSE:CLX) -1.2%
Procter & Gamble (NYSE:PG) -7.4%
Philip Morris (NYSE:PM) -2.6%
Johnson & Johnson (NYSE:JNJ) 0.1%
Pepsico (NYSE:PEP) -8.5%

A Caveat to These Findings
It's important to remember that share repurchases are just one of four options companies have with their free cash. The others are dividends, acquisitions and debt repayment. Every business chooses its own preferred course of action with the results of these decisions often not felt for several years. Dividends are the easiest way to keep score, but share repurchases aren't too far behind. The table above makes me question my choice of Scotts Miracle-Gro. If it can't accurately assess the value of its own shares, how confident should I be that it wouldn't overpay when making acquisitions? While it is something to keep in mind, Scotts also paid a special dividend of $8 a share ($508 million) in February, 2007, in addition to its $246.8 million share repurchase, as part of a recapitalization move. It could just as easily have used the half-billion to repurchase a larger number of shares. But it didn't, and that's the important thing. To me, it shows a reasonable level of restraint.

Companies Moving to Repurchases
Interestingly, Procter & Gamble's 2009 10-K states, "Our first discretionary use of cash is dividend payments." Yet, if you look at its last three fiscal years, it paid out $13.9 billion in dividends while repurchasing $22 billion of its stock. Would shareholders be better off if it stuck to its guns and put more towards dividends and less to buying back stock? At this moment in time, yes.

Of course, a good year in 2010 could change all that. P&G spent 158% more on share repurchases in the last three years than it did dividends. In fact, all the companies listed above with the exception of Scotts Miracle-Gro spent more on share repurchases than on dividend payments. Unfortunately, none of them were very good at picking up their stock cheap. The worst offender was Pepsi, which spent almost double dividend payouts only to see its stock lose 8.5% on the average price paid for its shares. It would be interesting to know if Pepsi shareholders believe the company is paying a reasonable price for Pepsi Bottling Group (NYSE:PBG) and Pepsi Americas (NYSE:PAS).

The Bottom Line
Allocating capital isn't easy. Most corporate boards in recent years have chosen share repurchases over dividends because they aren't locked into a cash commitment. If a company announces a new $5 billion share repurchase program, the markets barely notice. However, if a company reduces or eliminates a dividend payment, you can kiss the stock price goodbye. Therefore, it's understandable why most are hesitant to payout more. Perhaps, the best solution is to use a special dividend when times are good. It's not something routinely expected, but nice to receive nonetheless. As for this group of stocks, they all could definitely do a better job of allocating capital, but then again, who couldn't? (To learn more, check out How Buybacks Warp The Price-To-Book Ratio.)

Related Articles
  1. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Altria's Return on Equity (ROE) (MO)

    Learn about Altria Group's return on equity (ROE) and analyze net profit margin, asset turnover and financial leverage to determine what is causing its high ROE.
  2. Investing News

    Icahn's Bet on Cheniere Energy: Should You Follow?

    Investing legend Carl Icahn continues to lose money on Cheniere Energy, but he's increasing his stake. Should you follow his lead?
  3. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Google's Return on Equity (ROE) (GOOGL)

    Learn about Alphabet's return on equity. How has its ROE changed over time, how does it compare to its peers and what factors are driving ROE for the company?
  4. Investing News

    Is Buffett's Bet on Oil Right for You? (XOM, PSX)

    Oil stocks are getting trounced, but Warren Buffett still likes one of them. Should you follow the leader?
  5. Investing News

    Chipotle Served with Criminal Probe

    Chipotle's beat muted expectations and got a clear bill from the CDC, but it now appears that an investigation into its E.coli breakout has expanded.
  6. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Sprint Corp's Return on Equity (ROE) (S)

    Learn about Sprint's return on equity. Find out why its ROE is negative and how asset turnover and financial leverage impact ROE relative to Sprint's peers.
  7. Stock Analysis

    Why Alphabet is the Best of the 'FANGs' for 2016

    Alphabet just impressed the street, but is it the best FANG stock?
  8. Investing News

    A 2016 Outlook: What January 2009 Can Teach Us

    January 2009 and January 2016 were similar from an investment standpoint, but from a forward-looking perspective, they were very different.
  9. Mutual Funds & ETFs

    3 Vanguard Equity Fund Underperformers

    Discover three funds from Vanguard Group that consistently underperform their indexes. Learn how consistent most Vanguard low-fee funds are at matching their indexes.
  10. Investing News

    Alphabet Earnings Beat Expectations (GOOGL, AAPL)

    Alphabet's earnings crush analysts' expectations; now bigger than Apple?
RELATED FAQS
  1. How do dividends affect retained earnings?

    When a company issues a cash dividend to its shareholders, the retained earnings listed on the balance sheet are reduced ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What is the difference between called-up share capital and paid-up share capital?

    The difference between called-up share capital and paid-up share capital is investors have already paid in full for paid-up ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. Why would a corporation issue convertible bonds?

    A convertible bond represents a hybrid security that has bond and equity features; this type of bond allows the conversion ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. How does additional paid in capital affect retained earnings?

    Both additional paid-in capital and retained earnings are entries under the shareholders' equity section of a company's balance ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. What types of capital are not considered share capital?

    The money a business uses to fund operations or growth is called capital, and there are a number of capital sources available. ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is the difference between issued share capital and subscribed share capital?

    The difference between subscribed share capital and issued share capital is the former relates to the amount of stock for ... Read Full Answer >>
COMPANIES IN THIS ARTICLE
Trading Center