It looks like truck and engine manufacturer Navistar (NYSE:NAV) has finally bowed to the inevitable and is changing up its engine technology. While the company's press release reads as though this is a big leap forward, the reality is that management has struggled mightily with its existing advanced exhaust gas recirculation (EGR) technology and had little choice but to abandon an all-EGR approach in favor of urea-based after treatment. Although this switch is a necessary step for the company, it remains to be seen how much implementing this new approach (and getting EPA certification) is going to cost.

Investopedia Broker Guides: Enhance your trading with the tools from today's top online brokers.

Out with the New, in with the Old?
Navistar didn't exactly hand out detailed technical specs, and I'm not an engineer, but it looks like the company is going to try to preserve some of its prior proprietary technology and combine it with aspects of the selective catalytic reduction (SCR) technology used by others like Cummins (NYSE:CMI), PACCAR (Nasdaq:PCAR), Daimler and Volvo (OTC:VOLVY). In doing so, the company hopes to be able to finally achieve EPA certification and avoid sizable fines and/or outright bans on engine sales for non-compliance.

At the most basic level, Navistar's new "In-Cylinder Technology Plus" is going to use urea to reduce nitrogen oxide emissions. Assuming that the EPA goes along with it (and the EPA has thus far been surprisingly accommodating to Navistar), new engines could be on the market early next year.

SEE: 9 Cars That Can Rebuild The American Auto Industry

A Worthwhile Effort, but a Risky Move
In using what sounds like a hybrid of EGR and SCR technologies, Navistar is going down a similar road as John Deere (NYSE:DE), as this large manufacturer of agricultural and construction equipment builds engines with emissions control systems that integrate features of both technologies.

While the pure EGR approach clearly did not work for Navistar, it is not as though this was a completely radical or unique idea. As mentioned, Deere uses aspects of EGR technology, as have Caterpillar (NYSE:CAT) and Cummins. Where Navistar arguably went wrong was in placing so much emphasis on making its Advanced EGR (A-EGR) technology work at the cost of having SCR options available while they worked out the kinks in EGR and got EPA approval.

As it turns out, this "no SCR" orthodoxy on the part of Navistar carried a very high price; warranty costs have been much higher than expected and the company has lost credibility with customers and investors. There's also still the matter of the final bill to the EPA, to say nothing of the costs of bringing the new technology to market.

SEE: Green Energy: Why We're Still Not Using It

Go with the Risky Rebound or the More Expensive Leader?
As I have mentioned, the costs for introducing this new engine technology, let alone its chance of getting EPA approval and market acceptance, are significant unknowns. What's more, it is not clear yet as to whether Navistar will need to buy components externally (most likely from Cummins) to make this new approach work. For that matter, Navistar may still find itself in a similar predicament next year and may ultimately be forced to go back to Cummins as an engine supplier.

With all of those unknowns, it's no surprise that these shares trade at a fraction of per-share revenue while Cummins trades at around one times sales. Although Cummins is certainly exposed to the risk that North American heavy vehicle demand slows and that demand in Europe, China and Brazil doesn't recover quickly, nobody seems to doubt the quality of Cummins' leadership, technology or products.

In contrast, the quality of Navistar's leadership is very much open to debate, and much-celebrated growth opportunities like its venture with Clean Energy (Nasdaq:CLNE) won't materially impact the bottom line for a while (if ever).

SEE: 4 Ways Rising Fuel Costs Influence The Auto Industry

The Bottom Line
So, investors have a familiar choice here. Go with the troubled turnaround candidate (Navistar) and the prospects of significant market-beating appreciation potential if the company can get itself back on track, or take the surer bet with its lower appreciation potential.

At the time of writing, Stephen D. Simpson did not own shares in any of the companies mentioned in this article.

Related Articles
  1. Investing News

    Bank Stocks: Time to Buy or Avoid? (WFC, JPM, C)

    Bank stocks have been pounded. Is this the right time to buy or should they be avoided?
  2. Stock Analysis

    Why the Bullish Are Turning Bearish

    Banks are reducing their targets for the S&P 500 for 2016. Here's why.
  3. Stock Analysis

    How to Find Quality Stocks Amid the Wreckage

    Finding companies with good earnings and hitting on all cylinders in this environment, although possible, is not easy.
  4. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Sirius XM's Return on Equity (ROE) (SIRI)

    Learn more about the Sirius XM's overall 2015 performance, return on equity performance and future predictions for the company's ROE in 2016 and beyond.
  5. Stock Analysis

    Will Virtusa Corporation's Stock Keep Chugging in 2016? (VRTU)

    Read a thorough review and analysis of Virtusa Corporation's stock looking to project how well the stock is likely to perform for investors in 2016.
  6. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Porter's Five Forces on JPMorgan Chase (JPM)

    Examine the major money-center bank holding firm, JPMorgan Chase & Company, from the perspective of Porter's five forces model for industry analysis.
  7. Investing News

    What You Can Learn from Carl Icahn's Mistakes

    Carl Icahn has been a stellar performer in the investment world for decades, but following his lead these days could be dangerous.
  8. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Dish Network's Return on Equity (ROE) (DISH, TWC)

    Analyze Dish Network's return on equity (ROE), understand why it has vacillated so greatly in recent years and learn what factors are influencing it.
  9. Fundamental Analysis

    5 Must-Have Metrics For Value Investors

    Focusing on certain fundamental metrics is the best way for value investors to cash in gains. Here are the most important metrics to know.
  10. Stock Analysis

    Analyzing Altria's Return on Equity (ROE) (MO)

    Learn about Altria Group's return on equity (ROE) and analyze net profit margin, asset turnover and financial leverage to determine what is causing its high ROE.
  1. When does a growth stock turn into a value opportunity?

    A growth stock turns into a value opportunity when it trades at a reasonable multiple of the company's earnings per share ... Read Full Answer >>
  2. What is the formula for calculating EBITDA?

    When analyzing financial fitness, corporate accountants and investors alike closely examine a company's financial statements ... Read Full Answer >>
  3. How do I calculate the P/E ratio of a company?

    The price-earnings ratio (P/E ratio) is a valuation measure that compares the level of stock prices to the level of corporate ... Read Full Answer >>
  4. How do you calculate return on equity (ROE)?

    Return on equity (ROE) is a ratio that provides investors insight into how efficiently a company (or more specifically, its ... Read Full Answer >>
  5. How do you calculate working capital?

    Working capital represents the difference between a firm’s current assets and current liabilities. The challenge can be determining ... Read Full Answer >>
  6. What is the formula for calculating the current ratio?

    The current ratio is a financial ratio that investors and analysts use to examine the liquidity of a company and its ability ... Read Full Answer >>
Trading Center